Quarry School

What an identity is and how it differs from an equation — quick review

In plain words

An equation is a question: for which angles do the two sides come out equal?

Rule

An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined. One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.

Step

  1. Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.

  2. Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.

  3. Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.

  4. Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.

  5. If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.

  6. If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.

Strategy

  1. Write the left side and the right side apart, so you work on each on its own.

  2. List the angles to leave out: those that make some bottom 0.

  3. Choose an allowed test angle with exact values; 30° and 60° are the safest.

  4. Work out each side exactly and compare the two numbers.

  5. Different numbers: the claim is not an identity, and you have a counterexample. Same numbers: no verdict; test again or look for a reason that covers every allowed angle.

Question

Decide whether sin t + cos t = 1 is an identity. If it is not, give an angle that shows it.

Answer

Not an identity.
Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is 1+32 ≈ 1.366 and the right side is 1.
It holds at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, so it is an equation, not an identity.

Trap

Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is 1+32 ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.

Term

identity

Definition

An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.