Quarry School

The number i and the square root of a negative number

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Real numbersLeans on: What a square root asksLeans on: Squaring a negative numberLeans on: Perfect squaresLeans on: Pulling a perfect square out of a rootLeans on: Squaring a productLeans on: Squaring a square rootLeans on: Multiplying in any orderLeans on: The quadratic formula
Level 1 · FoundationsAbout 24 min read2 new termsKeystone idea. Later lessons build on this one.
How this was estimated

Programmatic estimate. Rung levels, worked steps, prerequisites, terms and sentence length contribute to this level. It describes the lesson, not your ability.

Reading counts the whole lesson, including folded explanations, at 180 words a minute. Practice allows two minutes per item. These are planning assumptions; take the time you need.

AI estimate unavailable.

Path to here

Open the unit’s lesson list to follow the lesson order.

    Quick review (2 minutes)

    In plain words

    The big picture
    Use i to simplify square roots of negative numbers.

    Rule

    The imaginary unit i is the number with i2 = −1, so i = −1. For any positive number a: −a = ia. Example: −16 = i16 = 4i. Warning: a · b = ab is safe only when a and b are not both negative. When both are negative, write each root with i first, then multiply.

    Step

    1. For −75, use the negative-root rule −a = ia: −75 = i75. Here a = 75 is positive, so this rule handles the negative sign before you simplify the real root.

    2. Factor 75 = 25 · 3. Use the largest square factor, 25, because its square root is a whole number and 3 has no square factor greater than 1.

    3. Use the product rule for nonnegative roots: 75 = 25 · 3 = 53. Both factors under the roots are positive, so this split is valid.

    4. Put the i back with the simplified root: i · 53 = 5i3. The order of multiplication can change. Write i before the root so it is clearly outside.

    5. Check by squaring with i2 = −1: (5i3)2 = 25 · (−1) · 3 = −75. Also check the sign: the square root symbol chooses the positive imaginary coefficient, 53. Squaring alone would also accept the negative of this answer.

    Question

    Simplify −75. In plain words: find the number this root stands for, written with i and with the leftover root made as small as possible.

    Answer

    −75=5i3

    Trap

    Multiplying under the roots before taking out i. −4 · −9 is not 36 = 6. Each root of a negative hides one i, so the product is 2i · 3i = 6i2 = −6. Whenever a negative sits under a square root, take the i out first, and only then multiply.

    Strategy

    1. Look at the sign of the number under the root. If it is zero or positive, no i is needed.

    2. If it is negative, take out one i: −a = ia. From here on you work with the positive number a.

    3. Simplify a the ordinary way: take the root if a is a perfect square, or pull out the largest perfect square that divides a.

    4. Write the answer in the order plain number, then i, then any leftover root, such as 6i2.

    5. Check by squaring the answer. Replace i2 with −1. You should land on the negative number you started with.

    6. If two square roots of negatives are multiplied, do steps 1 to 4 on each root before multiplying, then replace i2 with −1.

    Term

    imaginary unit

    Definition

    The number i, defined by i2 = −1. No real number squares to a negative, so i is a new number added to the ones you already know.

    1 In plain words

    The big picture
    Use i to simplify square roots of negative numbers. The key fact is i2 = −1. This extends the square roots you know from real numbers. Next, you will combine real numbers and i in one number.

    Every number you have met so far sits somewhere on the number line. Multiply any of them by itself and the answer is zero or positive: 3 × 3 = 9, and (−3) × (−3) = 9 as well. So no number on that line, multiplied by itself, gives −1. This kind of gap has shown up before. A thermometer that stopped at zero could not show a freezing night, so people added marks below zero. Here the fix is one new number, called i. Its full name is the imaginary unit. It is built for one job: i times i equals −1. Once i exists, the square root of any negative number has an answer. For example, −16 = 4i, because 4i times 4i gives −16.

    2 Picture it

    i2=−1

    i=−1

    −a = ia when a > 0

    −16=4i

    −4 · −9 = 2i · 3i = −6, not 6

    Reminder

    Reminder: Real numbers, What a square root asks, Squaring a negative number, Perfect squares, Pulling a perfect square out of a root, Squaring a product, Squaring a square root, Multiplying in any order, The quadratic formula
    • Real numbers. The real numbers are all the numbers on the number line: whole numbers, fractions, decimals and roots such as 2, whether positive, negative or zero. Examples: 3, −7, 12, 0.
    • What a square root asks. 9 asks: which number, zero or positive, times itself gives 9? The answer is 3, because 3 · 3 = 9.
    • Squaring a negative number. A negative times a negative is positive: (−4)2 = (−4) · (−4) = 16.
    • Perfect squares. These are the numbers made by squaring a whole number. After 0, the first ten are 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49, 64, 81, 100, and the list goes on. For example, 36 = 6 · 6.
    • Pulling a perfect square out of a root. Split the number into a perfect square times what is left: 50 = 25·2 = 25 · 2 = 52.
    • Squaring a product. Square each factor: (3 · 5)2 = 32 · 52 = 9 · 25 = 225, and 152 = 225.
    • Squaring a square root. Squaring undoes a square root: (3)2 = 3.
    • Multiplying in any order. 2 · 7 · 5 = 2 · 5 · 7 = 70. The same holds with i: 2i · 3i = 2 · 3 · i · i.
    • The quadratic formula. The solutions of ax2 + bx + c = 0 are x = −b±b2−4ac2a. Example: x2 − 5x + 6 = 0 has b2 − 4ac = 25 − 24 = 1, so x = 5±12, which gives x = 3 or x = 2.

    3 Why

    The number i is a definition, not a discovery: people chose to add a number whose square is −1, the same way they once added negative numbers and fractions. It earns its place because every ordinary rule of adding and multiplying keeps working with it. That is why −16 = 4i: (4i)2 = 4 · 4 · i · i = 16 · (−1) = −16. The number −4i also squares to −16. By convention the square root symbol picks 4i, with the positive 4 in front, the same way 16 means 4 and not −4. Without that convention, one symbol would stand for two numbers.

    4 The rule

    The imaginary unit i is the number with i2=−1, so i=−1.source 1

    For any positive number a: −a=ia. Example: −16=i16=4i. Warning: a·b=ab is safe only when a and b are not both negative. When both are negative, write each root with i first, then multiply.

    Sources (1)
    1. Jay Abramson. Precalculus 2e, 3.1 Complex Numbers. OpenStax, 2021. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Read 16 Nov 2026.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    i squared equals negative one. Say −16 = 4i as: the square root of negative sixteen is four i.

    Write it

    The imaginary unit i is the number that gives −1 when it is multiplied by itself, and the square root of a negative number is i times the square root of the matching positive number.

    In math
    • i2=−1
    • i=−1
    • −16=4i
    • −a = ia when a > 0
    Like

    A quarter turn done twice makes a half turn. Multiplying by i twice makes a multiplication by −1.

    See it
    √−16take out one i, thentake the ordinaryroot: i · √16inputoutput4i
    Notice that the negative sign leaves the root as a single i, and the ordinary root of 16 does the rest.

    The same idea, other ways

    As a picture

    Look at the graph of y = x2. Every point of the curve sits on or above the horizontal axis, because a number times itself is never negative. The height −1 is below the axis, so the curve never reaches it. That gap is the reason i was invented: no number on the number line can be squared to give −1, so a new number was added that can.

    no square ever lands below 0(−3, 9)(3, 9)(0, 0)−33−49
    Notice that the curve never dips below the horizontal axis, so no real number has a square of −1.
    As a story

    Sharing 1 loaf between 2 people had no answer among the whole numbers, so people added fractions. Taking 5 away from 3 had no answer either, so people added negative numbers to record debts and cold nights, and 3 − 5 became −2. The question of which number squares to −1 is the same kind of gap. The number i is the same kind of fix: one new number, added so that the question has an answer.

    −4−2024−5lands on −2
    Starting at 3 and moving 5 to the left lands on −2, a number that had to be added to the line before 3 − 5…
    As a turn

    Stand on the number line at 3, facing right. Multiplying by −1 sends you to −3, which is a half turn around zero. Now ask which single move, done twice, makes a half turn. The answer is a quarter turn. Multiplying by i is that quarter turn: do it twice and you have multiplied by i · i = −1. A quarter turn from 3 points straight up, off the number line. That is why i cannot be found anywhere on the line.

    × i
    One quarter turn stands for multiplying by i, and two of them make the half turn that multiplies by −1.
    With small numbers

    In the table, the top row holds numbers and the bottom row holds their squares. Look along the bottom row: no entry is below zero. Now use the new number. (2i)2 = 2 · 2 · i · i = 4 · (−1) = −4. (3i)2 = 3 · 3 · i · i = 9 · (−1) = −9. (4i)2 = 4 · 4 · i · i = 16 · (−1) = −16. So −4 = 2i, −9 = 3i and −16 = 4i.

    input xoutput x²−39−24−1100112439
    Look along the bottom row: every square is zero or positive, so −1 never appears.
    As a rule of thumb

    Every square root of a negative number hides exactly one i. Take it out and what remains is an ordinary square root: −16 is i times 16, which is 4i. One root, one i. Two such roots multiplied together bring two i factors, and i · i = −1. That is why −4 · −9 comes out negative: 2i · 3i = 6i2 = −6.

    Square rootWritten with iCheck by squaring
    −1ii2=−1
    −42i(2i)2=4·(−1)=−4
    −93i(3i)2=9·(−1)=−9
    −164i(4i)2=16·(−1)=−16
    −2i2(i2)2=(−1)·2=−2
    −505i2(5i2)2=25·(−1)·2=−50

    Part 1: Counting real and nonreal solutions from a graph

    A quadratic equation with real coefficients (the number in front of x2, the number in front of x and the number on its own are all real), such as x2 − 4x + 6 = 0, has exactly two solutions once complex numbers count. The graph of y = x2 − 4x + 6 shows how many of the two are real. A real solution is an x where the curve meets the x-axis, because on that axis the output is 0. Think of the x-axis as a floor. A parabola that passes through the floor in two places has two real solutions. One that only touches the floor with its tip has one real solution, which counts twice. One that never reaches the floor has no real solutions, so both of its solutions are nonreal: complex numbers with an i part. Nonreal solutions of a quadratic with real coefficients always come as a pair of conjugates, a + bi and a − bi.

    • A quadratic with real coefficients has exactly two solutions when complex numbers count, and a repeated solution counts twice.
    • A real solution is an x where the graph meets the x-axis, since the output there is 0.
    • Two crossings: 2 real solutions and 0 nonreal.
    • One touch at the tip, with the vertex on the x-axis: 1 real solution that counts twice, and 0 nonreal.
    • No crossing: 0 real solutions and 2 nonreal, a pair of conjugates a + bi and a − bi.
    • A check with the formula: the number under the root of the quadratic formula, b2 − 4ac, is positive for two crossings, 0 for a touch and negative for no crossing.

    Two crossings: 2 real, 0 nonreal

    A touch at the tip: 1 real (counted twice), 0 nonreal

    No crossing: 0 real, 2 nonreal (a conjugate pair)

    Real and nonreal together: always 2

    Worked example

    A parabola that never reaches the x-axis

    The graph of y = x2 − 4x + 6 is a parabola that opens up, with its lowest point at (2, 2). How many real solutions and how many nonreal solutions does x2 − 4x + 6 = 0 have? Find them. In plain words: count where the curve meets the x-axis, then find the two solutions with the quadratic formula.

    (2, 2)−2246−2246810
    The lowest point, (2, 2), sits above the x-axis, so the curve never meets it.
    Show the steps and the answer
    1. A solution of x2 − 4x + 6 = 0 is an x whose output is 0, which is where the graph meets the x-axis.
    2. The lowest point is 2 units above the x-axis and the curve opens up, so it never comes down to the axis.
    1. Say what a real solution looks like on the graph: an x where the curve meets the x-axis.On the x-axis the output y is 0, and x2 − 4x + 6 = 0 asks for the inputs whose output is 0.
    2. Read the graph: the curve opens up, and its lowest point, (2, 2), is 2 units above the x-axis.A parabola that opens up is lowest at its vertex, so every other point is higher.
    3. Count the crossings: 0. So there are 0 real solutions.Each place the curve meets the x-axis is one real solution, and this curve meets it nowhere.
    4. A quadratic has two solutions in all, so both are nonreal: 2 nonreal solutions.Counting complex numbers, a quadratic always has exactly two solutions.
    5. Find them with the quadratic formula, with a = 1, b = −4 and c = 6: x=4±(−4)2−4·1·62=4±−82.The formula is x = −b±b2−4ac2a. Here −b = 4, 2a = 2 and b2 − 4ac = 16 − 24 = −8.
    6. Write the root with i: −8=i8=2i2. So x=4±2i22.8 = 4 · 2 and 4 = 2, so 8 = 22.
    7. Divide each part by 2: x=2+i2 or x=2−i2.Dividing a sum by 2 divides each of its parts by 2: 42 = 2 and 2i22 = i2.
    Answer
    • 0 real solutions
    • 2 nonreal solutions: x = 2 + i2 and x = 2 − i2
    Double-check Put x = 2 + i2 back in. x2 = 4 + 4i2 + 2i2 = 2 + 4i2, and −4x = −8 − 4i2. So x2 − 4x + 6 = (2 + 4i2) + (−8 − 4i2) + 6 = 0. The two answers are conjugates, as a nonreal pair always is.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: The curve never meets the x-axis, so x2 − 4x + 6 = 0 has no solutions.
    It has no real solutions. Among the complex numbers it has two, 2 + i2 and 2 − i2, and a question about nonreal solutions asks for those.
    ✓ Instead: 0 real solutions and 2 nonreal solutions.
    ✗ Not this: A parabola that touches the x-axis at its tip has 1 real solution and 1 nonreal solution.
    Nonreal solutions come in conjugate pairs, so a quadratic never has only one. The touch is one real solution that counts twice, as in (x + 2)2 = 0, whose two solutions are both −2.
    ✓ Instead: A touch gives 1 real solution, counted twice, and 0 nonreal.

    5 How

    1. For −75, use the negative-root rule −a = ia: −75 = i75. Here a = 75 is positive, so this rule handles the negative sign before you simplify the real root.
    2. Factor 75 = 25 · 3. Use the largest square factor, 25, because its square root is a whole number and 3 has no square factor greater than 1.
    3. Use the product rule for nonnegative roots: 75 = 25 · 3 = 53. Both factors under the roots are positive, so this split is valid.
    4. Put the i back with the simplified root: i · 53 = 5i3. The order of multiplication can change. Write i before the root so it is clearly outside.
    5. Check by squaring with i2 = −1: (5i3)2 = 25 · (−1) · 3 = −75. Also check the sign: the square root symbol chooses the positive imaginary coefficient, 53. Squaring alone would also accept the negative of this answer.

    Simplifying the square root of a negative number

    1
    Is the number under the square root negative?
    YesTake out one i: −a = ia. Go on with the positive number a.
    NoNo i is needed. Simplify it as an ordinary root and stop.
    ↓
    2
    Is the positive number that is left a perfect square (1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, ...)?
    YesTake its root. The answer is a plain number times i, such as 4i.
    NoGo on.
    ↓
    3
    Does a perfect square larger than 1 divide it evenly?
    YesPull out the largest one: 72 = 36·2 = 62, so the answer is 6i2.
    NoLeave the root as it is: −7 = i7.
    ↓
    4
    Are two square roots of negative numbers being multiplied?
    YesChange each one to its i form first, multiply, then replace i2 with −1.
    NoCheck by squaring your answer. You should get the negative number you started with.
    1. Look at the sign of the number under the root. If it is zero or positive, no i is needed.
    2. If it is negative, take out one i: −a = ia. From here on you work with the positive number a.
    3. Simplify a the ordinary way: take the root if a is a perfect square, or pull out the largest perfect square that divides a.
    4. Write the answer in the order plain number, then i, then any leftover root, such as 6i2.
    5. Check by squaring the answer. Replace i2 with −1. You should land on the negative number you started with.
    6. If two square roots of negatives are multiplied, do steps 1 to 4 on each root before multiplying, then replace i2 with −1.

    6 Worked example

    Worked example

    Simplifying −75

    Simplify −75. In plain words: find the number this root stands for, written with i and with the leftover root made as small as possible.

    Show the steps and the answer

    −75=−1·75

    =i·25·3

    =i·53

    =5i3

    1. Look under the root: −75 is negative.No real number squares to a negative, so the answer will contain i.
    2. Split off the negative: −75=(−1)·75=−1·75.−75 is the same as (−1) · 75, and a root may be split across a product when at most one of the two numbers is negative.
    3. Replace −1 with i. This gives i·75.i is defined as the number whose square is −1, so i is −1.
    4. Find the largest perfect square that divides 75. Trying 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49 and 64 in turn, only 25 divides 75 evenly: 75÷25=3.Perfect squares are the only numbers that leave a root as whole numbers, and the largest one finishes the job in one move.
    5. Simplify the ordinary root: 75=25·3=25·3=53.25 and 3 are both positive, so the root splits safely, and 25 = 5.
    6. Put the pieces together: i·53=5i3.Multiplying in a different order does not change the answer, and writing i in front of the root keeps it from looking as if i were under the root.
    Answer
    −75=5i3
    Double-check Square the answer: (5i3)2 = 52 · i2 · (3)2 = 25 · (−1) · 3 = −75, the number under the original root. As a second look at the size, a calculator gives 75 ≈ 8.660 and 5 · 3 ≈ 5 · 1.732 = 8.660 (both rounded to three decimals).

    Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

    Try each rung before you open its steps.

    Rung 1 of 9

    A perfect square under the root

    Simplify −49. In plain words: write the number this root stands for, using i.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Notice that −49 is negative, and write −49=−1·49.−49 = (−1) · 49, and a negative under a square root always gives one factor of −1.
    2. Replace −1 with i. This gives i·49.That is the definition of i.
    3. Take the ordinary root: 49=7, so the answer is 7i.7 · 7 = 49, and the plain number is written in front of i.
    Answer
    −49=7i
    Double-check (7i)2 = 7 · 7 · i · i = 49 · (−1) = −49, the number under the root.

    Rung 2 of 9

    No perfect square to pull out

    Simplify −7. In plain words: write this root with i, and make the leftover root as small as it can be.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Take out the i: −7=−1·7=i7.The negative under the root comes out as one i.
    2. Look for a perfect square larger than 1 that divides 7. The only positive perfect squares up to 7 are 1 and 4, and 4 does not divide 7 evenly.Only a perfect square factor can leave a root as a whole number.
    3. Leave the answer as i7.An exact answer keeps the root. A decimal would only be a rounded value.
    Answer
    • −7=i7
    • Rounded to three decimals, this is about 2.646i.
    Double-check (i7)2 = i2 · (7)2 = (−1) · 7 = −7, the number under the root.

    Rung 3 of 9

    Pull out the largest perfect square

    Simplify −72. In plain words: write this root with i, with the smallest possible number left under the root.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Take out the i: −72=−1·72=i72.One negative under the root gives one i.
    2. Find the largest perfect square that divides 72. Among 4, 9, 16, 25 and 36, three work: 72÷4=18,72÷9=8 and 72÷36=2. The largest is 36.Using the largest perfect square finishes the root in one move.
    3. Simplify: 72=36·2=36·2=62.36 and 2 are both positive, so the root splits safely, and 36 = 6.
    4. Put it together: i·62=6i2.The order of multiplying does not matter, and i is written in front of the leftover root.
    5. Gotcha: pulling out 4 instead gives 2i18, which is not finished. Since 18=9·2,18=32, and 2i·32=6i2.A smaller perfect square still works, but it leaves another one hiding under the root.
    Answer
    −72=6i2
    Double-check (6i2)2 = 36 · i2 · 2 = 36 · (−1) · 2 = −72. For the size: 72 ≈ 8.485 and 6 · 2 ≈ 6 · 1.4142 = 8.485 (rounded to three decimals).

    Rung 4 of 9

    Both numbers whose square is negative

    Find every number whose square is −25. In plain words: the result of squaring is −25. Find each number that gives it.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Start with the square root: −25=i25=5i.Take out one i, then take the ordinary root of 25.
    2. Test it: (5i)2=5·5·i·i=25·(−1)=−25.A number whose square is −25 is exactly what the question asks for.
    3. Try its opposite, −5i: (−5i)2=(−5)·(−5)·i·i=25·(−1)=−25.A negative times a negative is positive, so the sign in front disappears when you square, the same way both 5 and −5 square to 25.
    4. List both numbers: 5i and −5i.The question asks for every number, not only the one the square root symbol names.
    Answer
    • 5i
    • −5i
    Double-check Both squares were worked out in full and both equal −25. The pair matches the pattern for 25, whose two square roots are 5 and −5. No real number joins the list, because the square of a real number is never negative.

    Rung 5 of 9

    Multiplying two roots of negatives

    Multiply −25 · −4. In plain words: find the single number this product equals.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Stop before multiplying under the roots. Both numbers under the roots are negative.The shortcut a · b = ab fails when both numbers are negative.
    2. Change each root to its i form: −25=5i and −4=2i.Each square root of a negative hides one i.
    3. Multiply: 5i·2i=5·2·i·i=10i2.Numbers may be multiplied in any order, so gather the plain numbers together and the i factors together.
    4. Replace i2 with −1: 10·(−1)=−10.i2 = −1 is the definition of i.
    Answer
    • −25
    • −4=−10
    Double-check The tempting shortcut gives (−25)(−4) = 100 = 10, which has the right size but the wrong sign. To confirm the sign, count the i factors: two roots of negatives bring two i factors, and i · i = −1, so the product must be negative. Multiplying in the other order agrees: 2i · 5i = 10i2 = −10.

    Rung 6 of 9

    Two roots of negatives that are not perfect squares

    Multiply −6 · −15 and simplify. In plain words: find the single number this product equals, with the smallest possible number left under any root.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. Change each root to its i form: −6=i6 and −15=i15.Both numbers under the roots are negative, so the i must come out of each one before anything is multiplied.
    2. Multiply and regroup: i6·i15=i·i·6·15=i2·6·15.Multiplying in a different order does not change the answer.
    3. Now use the shortcut: 6·15=90.6 and 15 are both positive, so the shortcut is safe here.
    4. Replace i2 with −1. The product is −90.i2 = −1 is the definition of i.
    5. Simplify 90. The largest perfect square that divides 90 is 9, and 90=9·10, so 90=9·10=310.Among 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49, 64 and 81, only 9 divides 90 evenly.
    6. Write the answer: −310.No i is left, because the two i factors turned into −1.
    Answer
    • −6·−15=−310
    • Rounded to three decimals, this is about −9.487.
    Double-check By calculator, 6 ≈ 2.4495 and 15 ≈ 3.8730, and their product is about 9.487. Also 3 · 10 ≈ 3 · 3.1623 = 9.487. The sizes agree, and the sign is negative because two i factors multiply to −1 (decimals rounded).

    Rung 7 of 9

    Two crossings from a graph

    The graph of y = −x2 + 5 is a parabola that opens down, with its highest point at (0, 5). How many real solutions and how many nonreal solutions does −x2 + 5 = 0 have? In plain words: count where the curve meets the x-axis; the rest of the two solutions are nonreal.

    (0, 5)−4−224−4−2246
    The top point, (0, 5), is above the x-axis and the curve falls on both sides.
    Show the steps and the answer
    1. The curve starts above the x-axis at its top point and falls on both sides. Does it have to pass through the axis?
    2. Each crossing is one real solution, and a quadratic has two solutions in all.
    1. The highest point, (0, 5), is above the x-axis, and the curve opens down, so it falls on both sides.Opening down means the outputs get smaller as x moves away from 0 to the left or to the right.
    2. The curve passes down through the x-axis once on the left of 0 and once on the right: 2 crossings.It starts above the axis and keeps falling on each side, so it must cross on each side.
    3. 2 crossings give 2 real solutions, which uses up both solutions: 0 nonreal.A quadratic has two solutions in all.
    Answer
    • 2 real solutions
    • 0 nonreal solutions
    Double-check Solve it: −x2 + 5 = 0 gives x2 = 5, so x = 5 or x = −5, about 2.236 and −2.236. Both are real, one on each side of 0.

    Rung 8 of 9

    A touch at the tip

    The graph of y = x2 + 4x + 4 is a parabola that opens up, with its lowest point at (−2, 0), on the x-axis. How many real solutions and how many nonreal solutions does x2 + 4x + 4 = 0 have? In plain words: count where the curve meets the x-axis, and say how many times that solution counts.

    (−2, 0)−6−4−22−2246
    The lowest point, (−2, 0), sits on the x-axis: the curve touches it and turns back up.
    Show the steps and the answer
    1. The lowest point is on the x-axis itself. Every other point of the curve is above it.
    2. A touch is one real solution that counts twice: x2 + 4x + 4 = (x + 2)(x + 2).
    1. The lowest point, (−2,0), is on the x-axis, and every other point of the curve is above the axis.A parabola that opens up is lowest at its vertex.
    2. So the curve meets the x-axis only at x=−2, where it touches and turns back up.A curve that stays on or above the axis can meet it only at its lowest point.
    3. x2+4x+4=(x+2)(x+2), and each factor gives x=−2. So there is 1 real solution, counted twice.Multiply back: x2 + 2x + 2x + 4 = x2 + 4x + 4. Both factors give the same solution.
    4. Both solutions are used up by −2, so there are 0 nonreal solutions.A quadratic has two solutions in all, and the repeated −2 counts as both.
    Answer
    • 1 real solution, x = −2, counted twice
    • 0 nonreal solutions
    Double-check Put x = −2 in: (−2)2 + 4(−2) + 4 = 4 − 8 + 4 = 0. The number under the root of the quadratic formula is 42 − 4 · 1 · 4 = 0, which means one repeated solution.

    Rung 9 of 9

    No crossing, then the two nonreal solutions

    The graph of y = −x2 + 4x − 5 is a parabola that opens down, with its highest point at (2, −1), below the x-axis. How many real solutions and how many nonreal solutions does −x2 + 4x − 5 = 0 have? Find the nonreal ones. In plain words: count the crossings, then use the quadratic formula.

    (2, −1)24−6−4−22
    The top point, (2, −1), is below the x-axis and the curve opens down: no crossing.
    Show the steps and the answer
    1. The highest point is already below the x-axis, and the curve only goes down from there.
    2. In the quadratic formula a = −1, b = 4 and c = −5, so 2a = −2. Divide each part of the top by −2.
    1. The highest point, (2,−1), is below the x-axis, and the curve opens down, so every point is at or below −1.A parabola that opens down is highest at its vertex.
    2. The curve never meets the x-axis: 0 real solutions, so 2 nonreal solutions.Real and nonreal solutions of a quadratic add up to 2.
    3. Quadratic formula with a=−1,b=4,c=−5: b2−4ac=16−4(−1)(−5)=16−20=−4. So x=−4±−4−2=−4±2i−2.x = −b±b2−4ac2a, with −b = −4 and 2a = −2. −4 = 2i.
    4. Divide each part by −2: −4+2i−2=2−i and −4−2i−2=2+i.Dividing by a negative number changes the sign of both parts: −4−2 = 2 and 2i−2 = −i.
    Answer
    • 0 real solutions
    • 2 nonreal solutions: x = 2 + i and x = 2 − i
    Double-check Put x = 2 + i back in: x2 = 4 + 4i + i2 = 3 + 4i, so −x2 + 4x − 5 = (−3 − 4i) + (8 + 4i) − 5 = 0.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: −4·−9=(−4)(−9)=36=6
    The shortcut a · b = ab was built for numbers that are zero or positive. Each root of a negative hides one i, and two i factors multiply to −1. The shortcut multiplies (−4)(−9) = 36 first, so the two negatives cancel before the i factors are ever counted, and the −1 is lost.
    ✓ Instead: Take the i out of each root first: −4 · −9 = 2i · 3i = 6i2 = 6 · (−1) = −6.
    ✗ Not this: −16=−4
    Squaring −4 gives (−4) · (−4) = 16, not −16. The minus sign under the root cannot hop outside the root.
    ✓ Instead: −16 = 4i, because (4i)2 = 16 · i2 = 16 · (−1) = −16.
    ✗ Not this: Since i2 = −1, the number i must be −1.
    (−1)2 = (−1) · (−1) = 1, not −1. No number on the number line has a square of −1.
    ✓ Instead: i is a new number, off the number line. It is not −1, not 1 and not 0. All that defines it is i2 = −1.
    ✗ Not this: Reading −16 and −16 as the same thing.
    In −16 the minus sits outside the root: take 16 = 4 first, then make it negative, which gives the real number −4. In −16 the minus sits under the root, and that calls for i.
    ✓ Instead: −16 = −4 and −16 = 4i. Check: (−4)2 = 16, but (4i)2 = −16.
    ✗ Not this: Putting an i into every root of a negative number, for example writing the cube root of −8 as 2i.
    The need for i comes from squaring a real number, which never gives a negative. Cubing a real number can: (−2) · (−2) · (−2) = −8. So a cube root of a negative number already has a real answer.
    ✓ Instead: The cube root of −8 is −2, with no i. The rule −a = ia is for square roots only.

    Tips and tricks

    • Memory cue: one negative under a square root, one i out front. Take the i out before you do anything else.
    • To check a simplified root such as −16 = 4i, square your answer. Each i2 becomes −1, and you should land on the negative number that was under the root.
    • Write i in front of a leftover root: 5i3. Written the other way round, the i can look as if it sits under the root.
    • The shortcut a · b = ab still works when only one of the numbers is negative: −9 · 4 = 3i · 2 = 6i, and −36 = 6i as well. It breaks only when both are negative.
    • Whenever i2 appears, replace it with −1 at once. A final answer never keeps an i2.
    • A basic calculator shows an error for −16. Read that as: no real answer. The answer 4i exists. It is off the number line.
    • The word imaginary is a name left over from history. It does not mean pretend: i follows fixed rules and gives definite answers, as every other number does.

    7 The trap

    Multiplying under the roots before taking out i. −4 · −9 is not 36 = 6. Each root of a negative hides one i, so the product is 2i · 3i = 6i2 = −6. Whenever a negative sits under a square root, take the i out first, and only then multiply.

    Keep in mind

    • What a test asks from this lesson: write the square root of a negative number with i, add or multiply such roots, and count the real and nonreal solutions of a quadratic from its graph.
    • Take the i out of every root of a negative before you multiply: −4 · −9 = 2i · 3i = −6.
    • Real and nonreal solutions of a quadratic make 2: two crossings give 2 real; a touch gives 1 real, counted twice; no crossing gives 2 nonreal.

    Flash cards

    Say the answer out loud, then flip.

    No number on the number line, multiplied by itself, gives −1. What fills that gap?
    • One new number, i, called the imaginary unit. It is added the way marks below zero were added to a thermometer.
    • Its one job: i · i = −1.
    Simplify −18.
    • 3i2
    • Split off the negative: −1 · 18 = i · 32. Write the plain number first, then i, then the root.
    • Check: (3i2)2 = 9 · 2 · i2 = 18 · (−1) = −18.
    What is −9 · −16?
    • −12
    • Take out i first: 3i · 4i = 12i2 = 12 · (−1) = −12.
    • It is not 144 = 12. Each root of a negative hides one i.
    The symbol −81 names a single number. Which one is it, 9i or −9i, and why only one?
    • 9i
    • Both 9i and −9i square to −81, so the symbol needs a rule: it takes the one with a positive number in front of i, just as 81 is 9 and not −9. One symbol, one value.

    Sources

    1. Jay Abramson. Precalculus 2e, 3.1 Complex Numbers. OpenStax, 2021. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Read 16 Nov 2026.