Quarry School

Order changes the result, and units must fit

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: SubstitutionLeans on: DistributionLeans on: Subtracting parenthesesLeans on: Composition orderLeans on: Function equalityLeans on: Discount fractionsLeans on: Divide a fraction by a whole number
Level 2 · BuildingAbout 27 min read8 new terms
How this was estimated

Programmatic estimate. Rung levels, worked steps, prerequisites, terms and sentence length contribute to this level. It describes the lesson, not your ability.

Reading counts the whole lesson, including folded explanations, at 180 words a minute. Practice allows two minutes per item. These are planning assumptions; take the time you need.

AI estimate unavailable.

Path to here

Open the unit’s lesson list to follow the lesson order.

    Quick review (2 minutes)

    In plain words

    Picture a store applying a discount and a coupon.

    Rule

    Usually f(g(x)) ≠ g(f(x)) as functions. Check both orders rather than assuming equality.
    For a meaningful composition, the inner output must be an acceptable outer input, including its units.

    Step

    1. 1. For each order, identify the function nearest the original input.

    2. 2. Evaluate or substitute that inner function into the other function.

    3. 3. Compare the resulting formulas and their domains. A different answer at one allowed input proves the functions differ.

    4. 4. For an application, label the starting input, intermediate output, and final output with units.

    5. 5. Check that the intermediate unit matches the outer function's expected input unit.

    Question

    (a) Let f(x) = 2x + 5 and g(x) = x2. Find f(g(x)) and g(f(x)). Decide whether they are the same function. (b) A delivery van drives at a steady speed, so the distance it covers in t hours is D(t) = 60t miles. The van uses fuel according to G(d) = d30 gallons for d miles driven. Find the meaningful composition that gives gallons used after t hours, and evaluate it at t = 3. Explain why the other order, D(G(d)), is not meaningful.

    Answer

    (a) f(g(x)) = 2x2 + 5 and g(f(x)) = 4x2 + 20x + 25. They are different functions, since at x = 1 the outputs are 7 and 49. (b) G(D(t)) = 2t gallons, and G(D(3)) = 6 gallons. D(G(d)) is not meaningful because G outputs gallons while D needs hours.

    Trap

    Treating a valid arithmetic calculation as proof that an application makes sense. Label the units as well as the numbers.

    Strategy

    1. Find the combined formula inside first.

    2. Set that final output equal to the requested number.

    3. Solve for the original input, stating what it locates.

    4. Check the original functions at that input.

    Strategy

    1. Write each function as its input quantity → its output quantity. A unit is a named measure such as hours or miles.

    2. Start with the function accepting the given input quantity; put it inside the other name.

    3. Pass its output to a function accepting that output quantity.

    4. For pure-number functions, calculate both formulas and their domains. One different output proves they differ; equality requires the same outputs everywhere and the same domain.

    Term

    Function

    Definition

    A rule that gives exactly one output for each input it accepts.

    Term

    Input

    Definition

    The starting value you give a function. It goes inside the parentheses in function notation.

    Term

    Output

    Definition

    The answer a function produces from an accepted input.

    Term

    Evaluate

    Definition

    Find the output of a function or the value of an expression for a given input.

    Term

    Domain

    Definition

    All inputs for which a function is defined.

    Term

    Inner function

    Definition

    The function evaluated first in a composition. Its output becomes the next function's input.

    Term

    Outer function

    Definition

    The function evaluated second in a two-function composition. It receives the inner function's output.

    Term

    Commutative

    Definition

    Describing an operation whose result stays the same when the order is reversed. Function composition usually does not have this property.

    Term

    Unit

    Definition

    The named measure attached to a quantity, such as hours, miles, gallons, or dollars.

    Term

    Substitution

    Definition

    Replacing a variable with a number or expression everywhere that variable appears. Parentheses hold a multi-term replacement together.

    Term

    Square root

    Definition

    The nonnegative number whose square is the given nonnegative number. Here the √ symbol names that one nonnegative value.

    Term

    Formula

    Definition

    A written rule using numbers, symbols, and operations to describe how a quantity is calculated.

    Term

    Graph

    Definition

    A picture of coordinate pairs. A function graph shows each input horizontally and its output vertically.

    Term

    Real number

    Definition

    A number on the ordinary number line, including negatives, zero, fractions, and numbers such as 2.

    Term

    Nonnegative

    Definition

    Greater than or equal to zero. Zero is included, while positive means greater than zero and excludes zero.

    Term

    Fraction

    Definition

    One number divided by another nonzero number. The top is divided by the bottom; equal pieces give a picture of its size.

    Term

    Intermediate answer

    Definition

    The in-between output of the first function, which becomes the next function’s input.

    Term

    Linear

    Definition

    A formula built from a constant times the input plus a constant. Its graph is a straight line.

    Term

    Solve

    Definition

    Find every input that makes a stated equality or inequality true. This differs from evaluating at a given input.

    Term

    Equation

    Definition

    A statement that two expressions have equal values.

    1 In plain words

    Picture a store applying a discount and a coupon. A 64-dollar price falls to 48 dollars after 25% off. An 8-dollar coupon then leaves 40 dollars. Reverse the jobs: the coupon leaves 56 dollars, and 25% off that amount leaves 42 dollars. The order changes what the second job receives. Composition can work the same way. Commutative means switching two jobs always preserves the result; composition does not have that property in general. Meaning matters too. If a driving rule gives miles from hours, a fuel rule accepting miles can follow it. The miles fit its input slot, the way a matching key fits a lock.

    2 Picture it

    hoursmileagefuel usefirstsecondmilesgallons
    Miles fit the fuel rule's input slot.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Substitution, Distribution, Subtracting parentheses, Composition order, Function equality, Discount fractions, Divide a fraction by a whole number
    • Substitution. Replacing x with 3 − x in 2x + 1 gives 2(3 − x) + 1.
    • Distribution. 2(3 − x) = 6 − 2x, because 2 multiplies each term.
    • Subtracting parentheses. 3−(2x+1)=3−2x−1.
    • Composition order. G(m(2)) starts with m(2), then puts that answer into G.
    • Function equality. A formula accepting every x differs from the same formula restricted to x ≠ 1.
    • Discount fractions. 25% off leaves 75%, so multiply the price by 0.75. At 64 dollars, 0.75 × 64 = 48 dollars.
    • Divide a fraction by a whole number. 65 ÷ 2 = 65 × 12 = 35. Likewise 96r2 ÷ 8 = 12r2.

    3 Why

    The first function changes what the second function receives. Reversing them therefore changes the second input, which can change the final answer. Agreement at a single input is not enough to establish equal functions: they must have the same domain and agree at every input there. In an application, a unit tells you what a number measures. A number labeled gallons cannot fill an input slot labeled hours, even when the bare formulas permit the arithmetic.

    4 The rule

    Usually f(g(x))≠g(f(x)) as functions.

    Check both orders rather than assuming equality.
    For a meaningful composition, the inner output must be an acceptable outer input, including its units.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    order matters; f after g may differ from g after f

    Write it

    Changing which job happens first can change the next input and the final output.

    In math
    • f(g(x)) and g(f(x)) are usually different functions
    • 2 + 3 = 3 + 2: addition is commutative
    • 5 − 2 ≠ 2 − 5: subtraction is not commutative
    • hours → miles → gallons
    Like

    A discount and a coupon act on different intermediate prices when reversed.

    See it
    $6425% off$8 couponfirstsecond$48$40
    Discount then coupon gives 40 dollars; the reverse order gives 42 dollars.

    The same idea, other ways

    As two jobs

    The first job sets up the second. Adding a coat after washing an object is a different process from washing after adding the coat.

    First job changes the second input

    Switching jobs can switch the answer

    As labeled packages

    The inner function hands over a package with a label. If the label says miles, the next function must accept miles. A number alone does not tell you its meaning.

    2 hours× 45÷ 30firstsecond90 miles3 gallons
    The unit on each output matches the next input.

    Part 1: Compare both orders

    Composition can happen to commute for a particular pair. You still need to check. Two functions can also happen to agree at one input without being equal everywhere.

    • One unequal output proves functions differ.
    • One equal output does not prove functions equal.
    both give 1f(g(1)) = 2g(f(1)) = 4−22246810
    y = x2 + 1, solid, beside y = (x + 1)2, dashed.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Compare both orders

    Write it

    Composition can happen to commute for a particular pair. You still need to check. Two functions can also happen to agree at one input without being equal everywhere.

    In math
    • One unequal output proves functions differ.
    • One equal output does not prove functions equal.
    Like

    Composition can happen to commute for a particular pair. You still need to check. Two functions can also happen to agree at one input without being equal everywhere.

    See it
    both give 1f(g(1)) = 2g(f(1)) = 4−22246810
    The same picture again: y = x2 + 1, solid, beside y = (x + 1)2, dashed.

    Worked example

    A coincidence is not function equality

    For f(x) = x + 1 and g(x) = x2, compare both orders at 0 and at 1. You want to test whether one matching answer tells the whole story. Plan: use the quantity or input named in the question, write the first result, then finish the stated operation.

    Show the steps and the answer

    One matching input: not enough

    One differing input: functions differ

    Compare x2 + 1 with x2 + 2x + 1

    1. At 0, f(g(0))=f(0)=1 and g(f(0))=g(1)=1.Both paths happen to end at 1 for this input.
    2. At 1, f(g(1))=f(1)=2 and g(f(1))=g(2)=4.The first stage now sends different numbers to the second stage.
    Answer
    They agree at 0, but differ at 1, so they are different functions.
    Double-check Their formulas are x2 + 1 and (x + 1)2 = x2 + 2x + 1. The extra 2x disappears at 0 but not at 1.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Composition never commutes for any pair.
    Two adding machines can commute: adding 1 then 2 has the same effect as adding 2 then 1.
    ✓ Instead: Composition is not commutative in general; particular pairs may commute.

    Tips and tricks

    • Use a small test input to catch a difference, then use formulas and domains to establish equality.

    Part 2: Interpret a composition with units

    Read the composition as a sentence. If s takes minutes and returns sit-ups, and c takes sit-ups and returns calories, c(s(t)) is calories burned during t minutes of sit-ups.

    • The inner s output counts sit-ups.
    • The outer c output counts calories.
    • The input and output letters are placeholders; the units explain their meaning.
    4 minutess: 12tc: n ÷ 4firstsecond48 sit-ups12 calories
    4 minutes goes into s: 12t, then 48 sit-ups into c: n ÷ 4: 12 calories.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Interpret a composition with units

    Write it

    Read the composition as a sentence. If s takes minutes and returns sit-ups, and c takes sit-ups and returns calories, c(s(t)) is calories burned during t minutes of sit-ups.

    In math
    • The inner s output counts sit-ups.
    • The outer c output counts calories.
    • The input and output letters are placeholders; the units explain their meaning.
    Like

    Read the composition as a sentence. If s takes minutes and returns sit-ups, and c takes sit-ups and returns calories, c(s(t)) is calories burned during t minutes of sit-ups.

    See it
    4 minutess: 12tc: n ÷ 4firstsecond48 sit-ups12 calories
    The same picture again: 4 minutes goes into s: 12t, then 48 sit-ups into c: n ÷ 4: 12 calories.

    Worked example

    Minutes to sit-ups to calories

    Use the illustrative models s(t) = 12t sit-ups and c(n) = n4 calories. Interpret and evaluate c(s(4)). You want the calories assigned by this model to the sit-ups completed in 4 minutes. Plan: use the quantity or input named in the question, write the first result, then finish the stated operation.

    Show the steps and the answer
    4 minutesscfirstsecond48 sit-ups12 calories
    The function labels tell you what each stage measures.
    1. s(4)=12×4=48 sit-ups.s accepts minutes and returns the exercise count.
    2. c(s(4))=c(48)=484=12 calories.c accepts the count produced by s.
    Answer
    • Interpretation: c(s(4)) is the modeled calories burned in 4 minutes of sit-ups.
    • Value: c(s(4)) = 12 calories.
    Double-check c(s(t)) = 12t4 = 3t, so at 4 minutes the combined model gives 3 × 4 = 12 calories.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: c(s(4)) counts the sit-ups done in 4 minutes.
    The inner s output counts sit-ups. The outer c output counts calories.
    ✓ Instead: s(4) counts sit-ups; c(s(4)) counts the modeled calories burned doing those sit-ups.

    Tips and tricks

    • Read inside to outside, naming each quantity: minutes, sit-ups, calories.
    • An interpretation question needs a sentence. A numerical value can be found only when the functions’ rules or values are supplied.

    Part 3: Check whether the reverse order makes sense

    A numerical formula may accept a number that its application cannot interpret. In the driving story, fuel use must follow distance. Feeding gallons into a driving-time rule gives the wrong kind of input.

    • If m accepts hours and returns miles, and G accepts miles and returns gallons, G(m(h)) is meaningful.
    • m(G(h)) does not match these units; G cannot start with hours and m cannot take gallons.
    2 hoursm: ×45G: ÷30firstsecond90 miles3 gallons
    2 hours goes into m: ×45, then 90 miles into G: ÷30: 3 gallons.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Check whether the reverse order makes sense

    Write it

    A numerical formula may accept a number that its application cannot interpret. In the driving story, fuel use must follow distance. Feeding gallons into a driving-time rule gives the wrong kind of input.

    In math
    • If m accepts hours and returns miles, and G accepts miles and returns gallons, G(m(h)) is meaningful.
    • m(G(h)) does not match these units; G cannot start with hours and m cannot take gallons.
    Like

    A numerical formula may accept a number that its application cannot interpret. In the driving story, fuel use must follow distance. Feeding gallons into a driving-time rule gives the wrong kind of input.

    See it
    2 hoursm: ×45G: ÷30firstsecond90 miles3 gallons
    The same picture again: 2 hours goes into m: ×45, then 90 miles into G: ÷30: 3 gallons.

    Worked example

    Hours to distance to fuel

    Let m(h) = 45h miles and G(d) = d30 gallons. Evaluate the meaningful composition at 2 hours and explain the order. You want gallons used for the distance driven in 2 hours. Plan: use the quantity or input named in the question, write the first result, then finish the stated operation.

    Show the steps and the answer
    2 hoursmGfirstsecond90 miles3 gallons
    Follow the units to choose the order.
    1. m(2)=45×2=90 miles.The mileage rule accepts hours.
    2. G(m(2))=G(90)=9030=3 gallons.The fuel rule accepts miles.
    3. Reject m(G(h)) as an interpretation for these models.G expects miles rather than hours, and m expects hours rather than G's gallon output.
    Answer
    • G(m(2)) = 3 gallons.
    • The order is hours to miles to gallons.
    Double-check The model uses 1 gallon per 30 miles; 3 gallons cover 3 × 30 = 90 miles, the distance obtained from 2 hours.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: m(G(2)) converts 2 hours into gallons.
    G accepts miles, and its gallon output cannot enter m, which accepts hours.
    ✓ Instead: G(m(2)) converts hours to miles to gallons.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write the input and output unit under each function name before deciding which name goes inside.

    Part 4: Both orders can be meaningful and can sometimes commute

    When two rules both accept and return ordinary real numbers, you can often use either order. The outputs can still differ, as the earlier linear pair showed. Some particular pairs do give equal functions in both orders.

    • Both orders can be meaningful when the input and output quantities match.
    • A pair that commutes does not make composition commutative in general.
    • For f(x) = x + 1 and g(x) = x + 2, both compositions give x + 3 on all real inputs.

    f(x) = x + 1; g(x) = x + 2

    f(g(x)) = (x + 2) + 1 = x + 3

    g(f(x)) = (x + 1) + 2 = x + 3

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Both orders can be meaningful and can sometimes commute

    Write it

    When two rules both accept and return ordinary real numbers, you can often use either order. The outputs can still differ, as the earlier linear pair showed. Some particular pairs do give equal functions in both orders.

    In math
    • Both orders can be meaningful when the input and output quantities match.
    • A pair that commutes does not make composition commutative in general.
    • For f(x) = x + 1 and g(x) = x + 2, both compositions give x + 3 on all real inputs.
    Like

    When two rules both accept and return ordinary real numbers, you can often use either order. The outputs can still differ, as the earlier linear pair showed. Some particular pairs do give equal functions in both orders.

    See it

    f(x) = x + 1; g(x) = x + 2

    f(g(x)) = (x + 2) + 1 = x + 3

    g(f(x)) = (x + 1) + 2 = x + 3

    Worked example

    A pair whose order does not change the function

    Let f(x) = x + 1 and g(x) = x + 2, both with all real inputs. Find both compositions and compare them. You want to see a case where reversing two connected rules gives the same complete function. Plan: use the quantity or input named in the question, write the first result, then finish the stated operation.

    Show the steps and the answer
    4g: add 2f: add 1firstsecond67
    Adding 2 then 1 gives 7.
    4f: add 1g: add 2firstsecond57
    Adding 1 then 2 also gives 7.
    1. f(g(x))=f(x+2)=(x+2)+1=x+3.g adds 2 first, then f adds 1.
    2. g(f(x))=g(x+1)=(x+1)+2=x+3.f adds 1 first, then g adds 2.
    3. Both composite domains are all real numbers.Both component rules accept every real intermediate answer.
    Answer
    Both compositions equal x + 3 on (−∞, ∞), so this pair commutes.
    Double-check At x = 4 the first path is 4 to 6 to 7 and the reverse path is 4 to 5 to 7. The symbolic calculations establish the agreement for every real input.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: This example proves that all function compositions commute.
    It proves equality for this specific pair; the earlier pair gave different formulas.
    ✓ Instead: Check each pair and its domains separately.

    Tips and tricks

    • Functions with the same input and output units can permit both orders without giving equal answers.

    Part 5: Distance to force to acceleration

    A distance rule can return a force, and a force rule can return an acceleration. Acceleration measures how quickly speed or direction changes. To find acceleration from distance, hand the distance rule's force output to the acceleration rule. In this model, G names the force rule, F names its force input to a, and r names distance. The letters are labels for their quantities.

    • For the scaled practice model below, the meaningful order is a(G(r)).
    • The units pass from distance to force to acceleration.
    • a(G(r)) means the modeled acceleration of a planet at distance r from the sun.
    r = 4G: 96 ÷ r²a: F ÷ 8firstsecondF = 63/4
    r = 4 goes into G: 96 ÷ r2, then F = 6 into a: F ÷ 8: 3/4.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Distance to force to acceleration

    Write it

    A distance rule can return a force, and a force rule can return an acceleration. Acceleration measures how quickly speed or direction changes. To find acceleration from distance, hand the distance rule's force output to the acceleration rule. In this model, G names the force rule, F names its force input to a, and r names distance. The letters are labels for their quantities.

    In math
    • For the scaled practice model below, the meaningful order is a(G(r)).
    • The units pass from distance to force to acceleration.
    • a(G(r)) means the modeled acceleration of a planet at distance r from the sun.
    Like

    A distance rule can return a force, and a force rule can return an acceleration. Acceleration measures how quickly speed or direction changes. To find acceleration from distance, hand the distance rule's force output to the acceleration rule. In this model, G names the force rule, F names its force input to a, and r names distance. The letters are labels for their quantities.

    See it
    r = 4G: 96 ÷ r²a: F ÷ 8firstsecondF = 63/4
    The same picture again: r = 4 goes into G: 96 ÷ r2, then F = 6 into a: F ÷ 8: 3/4.

    Worked example

    Choose a meaningful gravity-model composition

    In an invented scaled model, G(r) = 96r2 force units for r > 0 distance units, and a(F) = F8 acceleration units for F ≥ 0 force units. Interpret and evaluate a(G(4)). You want acceleration obtained from the force at distance 4. Plan: use the quantity or input named in the question, write the first result, then finish the stated operation.

    Show the steps and the answer
    4Gafirstsecond63/4
    The handoff is force, and the final number measures acceleration in this invented scaled model.
    1. G(4)=9642=9616=6 force units.The distance input goes into the inner force model first.
    2. a(G(4))=a(6)=68=34 acceleration units.The outer model accepts the force output and divides it by 8.
    3. The reverse connection does not match the stated quantity labels.G expects distance, not the acceleration returned by a.
    Answer
    • a(G(4)) = 34 acceleration units.
    • It means the modeled acceleration at distance 4.
    Double-check a(G(r)) = 96r2 ÷ 8 = 12r2 for r > 0. At 4 it gives 1216 = 34, agreeing with the two-stage route.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Use G(a(r)) to obtain acceleration from distance.
    a expects force, and G expects distance; that order mixes the quantity labels.
    ✓ Instead: Use a(G(r)).

    Tips and tricks

    • Read the input and output names before manipulating an application formula.

    Part 6: A price example makes order visible

    A percentage reduction changes with the price it receives. A coupon removes a fixed amount. This is why moving the coupon earlier changes the later percentage savings. Compare the numeric prices first, then write the two formulas.

    • On starting prices x ≥ 11 dollars, both composed prices are nonnegative and both store instructions make sense.
    • The reverse order in this example costs 2 dollars more.
    $6425% off$8 offfirstsecond$48$40
    $64 goes into 25% off, then $48 into $8 off: $40.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    A price example makes order visible

    Write it

    A percentage reduction changes with the price it receives. A coupon removes a fixed amount. This is why moving the coupon earlier changes the later percentage savings. Compare the numeric prices first, then write the two formulas.

    In math
    • On starting prices x ≥ 11 dollars, both composed prices are nonnegative and both store instructions make sense.
    • The reverse order in this example costs 2 dollars more.
    Like

    A percentage reduction changes with the price it receives. A coupon removes a fixed amount. This is why moving the coupon earlier changes the later percentage savings. Compare the numeric prices first, then write the two formulas.

    See it
    $6425% off$8 offfirstsecond$48$40
    The same picture again: $64 goes into 25% off, then $48 into $8 off: $40.

    Worked example

    A store’s two orders

    Let d(x) = 0.75x apply 25% off a price, and c(x) = x − 8 apply an 8-dollar coupon. Compare c(d(64)) and d(c(64)), then find both formulas. You want the price in each order. Plan: keep a separate line for each discount or coupon.

    Show the steps and the answer
    $6425% off$8 offfirstsecond$48$40
    The same picture a third time: $64 goes into 25% off, then $48 into $8 off: $40.
    $64$8 off25% offfirstsecond$56$42
    Reversing the jobs applies 25% off to 56 dollars.
    1. d(64)=0.75×64=48; c(48)=48−8=40.The percentage discount comes first in c(d(64)); the coupon acts on its remaining price.
    2. c(64)=64−8=56; d(56)=0.75×56=42.In the reverse order, the percentage discount acts on the price after the coupon.
    3. c(d(x))=0.75x−8; d(c(x))=0.75(x−8)=0.75x−6.Substitute the whole inner price; distribution gives 0.75 × 8 = 6.
    Answer
    • Discount then coupon: 40 dollars.
    • Coupon then discount: 42 dollars.
    • c(d(x))=0.75x−8.
    • d(c(x))=0.75x−6.
    Double-check The discount after the coupon saves 25% of 56, which is 14 dollars: 56 − 14 = 42. The discount before the coupon saves 16 dollars, giving 64 − 16 − 8 = 40.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: A discount and coupon always give the same final price in either order.
    The percentage reduction depends on its current input price: it saves 16 dollars before the coupon but 14 afterward.
    ✓ Instead: For this 64-dollar item the two prices are 40 and 42 dollars.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write the current price after each instruction. Do not apply both instructions separately to the original price.

    Part 7: Interpret a word-only composition

    You can explain a composition even when no numerical formulas are given. Each function’s description tells you the kind of input and output. Follow those descriptions as you would follow labels on packages. The outside function names the final quantity.

    • Interpret means state what the expression measures in words.
    • A quantity description by itself does not supply a numerical rate.
    3 minutesscfirstsecondsit-upscalories
    3 minutes goes into s, then sit-ups into c: calories.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Interpret a word-only composition

    Write it

    You can explain a composition even when no numerical formulas are given. Each function’s description tells you the kind of input and output. Follow those descriptions as you would follow labels on packages. The outside function names the final quantity.

    In math
    • Interpret means state what the expression measures in words.
    • A quantity description by itself does not supply a numerical rate.
    Like

    You can explain a composition even when no numerical formulas are given. Each function’s description tells you the kind of input and output. Follow those descriptions as you would follow labels on packages. The outside function names the final quantity.

    See it
    3 minutesscfirstsecondsit-upscalories
    The same picture again: 3 minutes goes into s, then sit-ups into c: calories.

    Worked example

    Two orders of composition, and a pool hose with water cost

    (a) Let f(x) = 3x − 4 and g(x) = x. Find f(g(x)) and g(f(x)), give the domain of each, and decide whether they are the same function. (b) A hose fills a pool at a steady rate, so after t minutes the pool holds V(t) = 12t gallons. The water company charges W(v) = 0.005v dollars for v gallons. Decide which composition, W(V(t)) or V(W(t)), is meaningful. Find a formula for the meaningful one and evaluate it at t = 50. Label every quantity with its units.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. For f(g(x)), the inner function is g, because g acts on x first. For g(f(x)), the inner function is f.In a composition the function written closest to x is applied first. Its output becomes the input of the outer function.
    2. f(g(x))=f(x)=3x−4. The domain is x≥0.Replace x in f with x. The inner root needs x ≥ 0, and f accepts any real number, so no further restriction is added.
    3. g(f(x))=g(3x−4)=3x−4. The domain needs 3x−4≥0, so x≥43.Replace x in g with 3x − 4. A square root needs a non-negative input, so the inner output must be at least 0.
    4. Test x=4, which is in both domains: f(g(4))=3·2−4=2, and g(f(4))=8≈2.83. The values are 2 and 8, which differ.One allowed input that gives different outputs proves the two functions are different. The domains also differ, [0, ∞) against [43, ∞), which is a second reason.
    5. In part (b), label the units. V takes t in minutes and returns gallons. W takes v in gallons and returns dollars.A composition makes sense only when the inner output is an acceptable input for the outer function, units included.
    6. W(V(t)): the starting input is t minutes, the intermediate output V(t) is in gallons, and the final output W is in dollars. Gallons is exactly what W expects, so this order is meaningful.The intermediate unit (gallons) matches W's input unit (gallons).
    7. V(W(t)) would feed W's output, which is in dollars, into V, which expects minutes. This order is not meaningful.The intermediate unit (dollars) does not match V's input unit (minutes). The formula can be written, but it does not describe anything real.
    8. W(V(t))=0.005(12t)=0.06t dollars. At t=50: V(50)=600 gallons, so W(600)=0.005·600=3 dollars.Substitute the inner formula into the outer one, then evaluate. The result is the cost of the water after t minutes.
    Answer
    (a) f(g(x)) = 3x − 4 with domain x ≥ 0. g(f(x)) = 3x−4 with domain x ≥ 43. They are not the same function, since at x = 4 they give 2 and 8. (b) W(V(t)) is the meaningful composition. W(V(t)) = 0.06t dollars, and W(V(50)) = 3 dollars, so 50 minutes of filling costs $3. V(W(t)) is not meaningful, because it would feed dollars into a function that expects minutes.
    Double-check (a) Recompute at x = 9: f(g(9)) = 3·3 − 4 = 5, and g(f(9)) = 23 ≈ 4.80. These still differ. (b) 50 minutes × 12 gallons per minute = 600 gallons, and 600 gallons × $0.005 per gallon = $3. Also 0.06 × 50 = 3, which agrees.

    Work to write

    1. f(g(x)) = 3x − 4, domain x ≥ 0
    2. g(f(x)) = 3x−4, domain x ≥ 43
    3. At x = 4: f(g(4)) = 2 and g(f(4)) = 8, so f(g(x)) ≠ g(f(x))
    4. t (minutes) → V(t) (gallons) → W(V(t)) (dollars); gallons matches W's input
    5. V(W(t)) is not meaningful: dollars cannot be input as minutes
    6. W(V(t)) = 0.06t dollars
    7. W(V(50)) = W(600) = 3 dollars

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: c(s(3)) means 3 calories.
    The 3 is the time input to s, not the final output of c.
    ✓ Instead: It means calories burned during 3 minutes of sit-ups; the number of calories is not supplied.

    Tips and tricks

    • Answer template: starting input, inner quantity, final outer quantity.

    Part 8: Units alone choose an order

    No speed or fuel formula is needed to choose the meaningful order. The matching labels decide the connection, like matching a plug to its socket. Here hours enter f and miles leave it; those miles fit g, whose final output measures gallons.

    • For these definitions, g(f(x)) is meaningful.
    • Bare-number substitution does not prove that an applied interpretation matches its units.
    x hoursfgfirstsecondmilesgallons
    x hours goes into f, then miles into g: gallons.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Units alone choose an order

    Write it

    No speed or fuel formula is needed to choose the meaningful order. The matching labels decide the connection, like matching a plug to its socket. Here hours enter f and miles leave it; those miles fit g, whose final output measures gallons.

    In math
    • For these definitions, g(f(x)) is meaningful.
    • Bare-number substitution does not prove that an applied interpretation matches its units.
    Like

    No speed or fuel formula is needed to choose the meaningful order. The matching labels decide the connection, like matching a plug to its socket. Here hours enter f and miles leave it; those miles fit g, whose final output measures gallons.

    See it
    x hoursfgfirstsecondmilesgallons
    The same picture again: x hours goes into f, then miles into g: gallons.

    Worked example

    Choose the textbook’s meaningful notation

    OpenStax problem

    f(x) gives miles driven in x hours, and g(y) gives gallons used for driving y miles. Which is meaningful: f(g(y)) or g(f(x))? You want the order whose handoff has the unit the second rule expects. Plan: label each input and output before choosing an order.

    Show the steps and the answer
    x hoursfgfirstsecondmilesgallons
    The same picture a third time: x hours goes into f, then miles into g: gallons.
    1. f: hours → miles; g: miles → gallons.Each description names its input and output quantity.
    2. Choose g(f(x)): f(x) supplies miles, which g accepts.The quantity passed between functions matches.
    3. Reject f(g(y)): g(y) supplies gallons, while f needs hours.Gallons cannot fill the time slot in these definitions.
    Answer
    • g(f(x)) is meaningful: gallons used for the miles driven in x hours.
    • f(g(y)) does not match these quantity definitions.
    Double-check Trace the chosen path: hours → miles → gallons. The middle miles appear both as f’s output and g’s required input.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: f(g(y)) must be meaningful because f is written first.
    The written first name is outer and must accept the inner output, here gallons.
    ✓ Instead: g(f(x)) has the matching hours → miles → gallons path.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write hours → miles and miles → gallons, then join the repeated unit.

    Part 9: Evaluate asks for output; solve asks for input

    Two questions can use the same machines while searching in opposite directions. Evaluate supplies a starting input and asks what comes out. Solve supplies a desired output and asks which starting input gets there. The equation records that desired output, like finding how long a trip must take to reach a chosen destination.

    • Evaluate c(s(4)) means start with time 4 and find calories.
    • Solve c(s(t)) = 45 means start with desired calories 45 and find time t.
    15 minutess: 18tc: n ÷ 6firstsecond270 sit-ups45 calories
    15 minutes goes into s: 18t, then 270 sit-ups into c: n ÷ 6: 45 calories.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Evaluate asks for output; solve asks for input

    Write it

    Two questions can use the same machines while searching in opposite directions. Evaluate supplies a starting input and asks what comes out. Solve supplies a desired output and asks which starting input gets there. The equation records that desired output, like finding how long a trip must take to reach a chosen destination.

    In math
    • Evaluate c(s(4)) means start with time 4 and find calories.
    • Solve c(s(t)) = 45 means start with desired calories 45 and find time t.
    Like

    Two questions can use the same machines while searching in opposite directions. Evaluate supplies a starting input and asks what comes out. Solve supplies a desired output and asks which starting input gets there. The equation records that desired output, like finding how long a trip must take to reach a chosen destination.

    See it
    15 minutess: 18tc: n ÷ 6firstsecond270 sit-ups45 calories
    The same picture again: 15 minutes goes into s: 18t, then 270 sit-ups into c: n ÷ 6: 45 calories.

    Worked example

    Find the time from a requested calorie output

    In an invented practice model, s(t) = 18t sit-ups and c(n) = n6 calories. How many minutes give c(s(t)) = 45 calories? You are given the output 45 and must find the input time. Plan: form the combined formula, set it equal to the requested output, solve for time, then check both original functions.

    Show the steps and the answer
    15 minutess: 18tc: n ÷ 6firstsecond270 sit-ups45 calories
    The same picture a third time: 15 minutes goes into s: 18t, then 270 sit-ups into c: n ÷ 6: 45 calories.
    1. c(s(t))=c(18t)=18t6=3t.s supplies the whole exercise count to c, and 18 ÷ 6 = 3.
    2. Solve 3t = 45. Divide both sides by 3: t=15.This locates the starting time whose final calorie output is 45; division undoes multiplication by 3.
    3. Check s(15)=18×15=270 sit-ups, then c(270)=2706=45 calories.The proposed time must produce the requested final output in the original two-stage calculation.
    Answer
    The model reaches 45 calories after 15 minutes.
    Double-check The combined rate is 3 calories per minute. Fifteen groups of 3 give 45, confirming the time separately.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Evaluate c(s(45)) to answer when 45 calories are reached.
    That treats 45 as minutes and asks a different output question.
    ✓ Instead: Solve c(s(t)) = 45; in the worked model the time is 15 minutes.

    Tips and tricks

    • Given input: evaluate. Given output and a question asking when or which input: solve.

    Part 10: A fresh interpretation to copy as a pattern

    A printer first turns time into a page count. Ink use then depends on that count. This is the same handoff idea with different quantities, so you can rebuild the interpretation by reading labels rather than memorizing one story.

    • w(p(t)) describes grams of ink used during t minutes of printing.
    10 minutespwfirstsecondpagesgrams of ink
    10 minutes goes into p, then pages into w: grams of ink.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. The name chooses a recipe and the parentheses supply its input: f(3) is the f output at input 3.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    A fresh interpretation to copy as a pattern

    Write it

    A printer first turns time into a page count. Ink use then depends on that count. This is the same handoff idea with different quantities, so you can rebuild the interpretation by reading labels rather than memorizing one story.

    In math
    • w(p(t)) describes grams of ink used during t minutes of printing.
    Like

    A printer first turns time into a page count. Ink use then depends on that count. This is the same handoff idea with different quantities, so you can rebuild the interpretation by reading labels rather than memorizing one story.

    See it
    10 minutespwfirstsecondpagesgrams of ink
    The same picture again: 10 minutes goes into p, then pages into w: grams of ink.

    Worked example

    Minutes to pages to ink

    p(t) counts pages printed in t minutes, and w(n) counts grams of ink used for n pages. Interpret w(p(10)) and explain why p(w(10)) does not match these definitions. You want a sentence about quantities. Plan: read each expression from the inside outward.

    Show the steps and the answer
    10 minutespwfirstsecondpagesgrams of ink
    The same picture a third time: 10 minutes goes into p, then pages into w: grams of ink.
    1. p(10) counts pages printed in 10 minutes.p accepts minutes and returns pages.
    2. w(p(10)) counts the grams of ink used for those pages.w accepts pages and returns grams.
    3. p(w(10)) would hand grams of ink to p, which needs minutes.The output of w cannot fill p’s time input slot under the stated definitions.
    Answer
    • w(p(10)) means grams of ink used in 10 minutes of printing.
    • p(w(10)) does not match the stated quantity labels.
    Double-check The correct route starts with minutes and ends with ink: minutes → pages → grams. The final w tells you that the answer is ink.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: w(p(10)) returns pages.
    The outside w returns grams, while only the inside p returns pages.
    ✓ Instead: The final answer measures grams of ink.

    Tips and tricks

    • The outside function names the final quantity in your answer.

    5 How

    1. For each order, identify the function nearest the original input.
    2. Evaluate or substitute that inner function into the other function.
    3. Compare the resulting formulas and their domains. A different answer at one allowed input proves the functions differ.
    4. For an application, label the starting input, intermediate output, and final output with units.
    5. Check that the intermediate unit matches the outer function's expected input unit.

    Choose an order and compare it

    1
    Do the inner output quantity and outer input quantity match?
    YesThis order is meaningful; calculate if formulas are supplied.
    NoReject this applied interpretation even if bare-number arithmetic can be carried out.
    ↓
    2
    Do the two orders have different domains or a different output at an allowed input?
    YesThey are different functions.
    NoUse complete formulas and domains to determine whether they agree everywhere.
    1. Write each function as its input quantity → its output quantity. A unit is a named measure such as hours or miles.
    2. Start with the function accepting the given input quantity; put it inside the other name.
    3. Pass its output to a function accepting that output quantity.
    4. For pure-number functions, calculate both formulas and their domains. One different output proves they differ; equality requires the same outputs everywhere and the same domain.

    6 Worked example

    Worked example

    Two orders of composition, and a unit check for fuel use

    (a) Let f(x) = 2x + 5 and g(x) = x2. Find f(g(x)) and g(f(x)). Decide whether they are the same function. (b) A delivery van drives at a steady speed, so the distance it covers in t hours is D(t) = 60t miles. The van uses fuel according to G(d) = d30 gallons for d miles driven. Find the meaningful composition that gives gallons used after t hours, and evaluate it at t = 3. Explain why the other order, D(G(d)), is not meaningful.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. For f(g(x)), the inner function is g, because it acts on x first. For g(f(x)), the inner function is f.In a composition, the function written nearest the input is applied first.
    2. Substitute g(x) = x2 into f: f(g(x))=2(x2)+5=2x2+5.f doubles its input and adds 5, and here its input is x2.
    3. Substitute f(x) = 2x + 5 into g: g(f(x))=(2x+5)2=4x2+20x+25.g squares its input, and here its input is the whole expression 2x + 5.
    4. Compare the two results at x=1. f(g(1))=2(1)+5=7 and g(f(1))=(7)2=49. Both functions have domain all real numbers.A single allowed input that gives different outputs proves the functions are different.
    5. In part (b), label the units. For D, the input t is in hours and the output is in miles. For G, the input d is in miles and the output is in gallons.A composition is meaningful only if the inner output can be used as the outer input.
    6. Use the order G(D(t)). The chain is t hours →D(t) miles →G(D(t)) gallons. So G(D(t))=60t30=2t gallons.D gives miles, and miles is the unit G expects as its input.
    7. Evaluate at t=3. D(3)=60(3)=180 miles, and G(180)=18030=6 gallons.First find the intermediate output, then feed it into the outer function.
    8. Check the order D(G(d)). G(d) gives gallons, but D expects an input in hours.The intermediate unit (gallons) does not match the input unit D expects (hours), so this composition has no real-world meaning.
    Answer
    (a) f(g(x)) = 2x2 + 5 and g(f(x)) = 4x2 + 20x + 25. They are different functions, since at x = 1 the outputs are 7 and 49. (b) G(D(t)) = 2t gallons, and G(D(3)) = 6 gallons. D(G(d)) is not meaningful because G outputs gallons while D needs hours.
    Double-check Part (a): at x = 0, f(g(0)) = 5 and g(f(0)) = 25. These still differ. Part (b): 3 hours at 60 miles per hour is 180 miles. At 30 miles per gallon, 180 miles uses 6 gallons. The formula 2t gives 2(3) = 6 and agrees.

    Work to write

    1. f(g(x))=2x2+5
    2. g(f(x))=(2x+5)2=4x2+20x+25
    3. f(g(1)) = 7 ≠ 49 = g(f(1)), so f∘g ≠ g∘f
    4. t (hours) → D(t) (miles) → G(D(t)) (gallons)
    5. G(D(t))=60t30=2t
    6. G(D(3)) = 6 gallons
    7. D(G(d)) is not meaningful: G outputs gallons, but D needs hours

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Matching at x = 0 proves two compositions are equal.
    Function equality requires matching domains and outputs at every allowed input.
    ✓ Instead: Compare formulas and domains; test another input to expose a possible difference.
    ✗ Not this: A fuel output of 3 gallons can become 3 hours without explanation.
    The same numeral can measure different quantities, but changing its unit changes its meaning.
    ✓ Instead: Only hand an output to a function that accepts that output's quantity.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write input units above the first arrow and output units above each following arrow.
    • Understand, then rebuild: the order from the parentheses or the units. Do not memorize which letter goes first; letters can change.

    7 The trap

    Treating a valid arithmetic calculation as proof that an application makes sense. Label the units as well as the numbers.

    Problems marked OpenStax come from Precalculus 2e by Jay Abramson, published by OpenStax, under the CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 licence. Access for free at https://openstax.org/books/precalculus-2e/pages/1-introduction-to-functions.