Reading a formula backwards
Quick review (2 minutes)
In the earlier lessons each sum formula and difference formula worked forwards: one thing, sin(x − y), came apart into four pieces.
sin x cos y − cos x sin y = sin(x − y), for every pair of angles x and y. Every other sum formula and difference formula can be read from right to left in the same way, the tangent ones wherever they are defined; the table lists all six.
Name the two functions in each product. A sine times a cosine in both products points to a sine formula. A cosine times a cosine in one product and a sine times a sine in the other point to a cosine formula. A fraction of tangents points to a tangent formula.
Check that the same two angles appear in both products, that each angle switches function from one product to the other, and that no number multiplies only one product. If any check fails, stop: no formula packs it.
Choose between x + y and x − y with Sine Same, Cosine Changes: a sine pattern keeps the sign between the products as the sign between the angles, a cosine pattern switches it, and a tangent fraction keeps it on top and switches it on the bottom.
For a difference, put first the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine the order does not matter.
Work out the one angle, giving fractions with π a common bottom, then evaluate its sine, cosine or tangent, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
Check the answer a second way: a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or a test angle put into both the start and the answer.
Find the exact value of sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23°.
Taking the angles in the order they are printed. In a sine difference, the first angle is the one whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, wherever that sine is written. So cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65° is sin(65° − 20°) = , not sin(20° − 65°). The wrong order gives the negative of the right answer, because sin(−45°) = −sin 45°. Before you subtract, find the sine in the product before the minus sign and put its angle first.
Name the two functions in each product: a sine with a cosine, a cosine with a cosine and a sine with a sine, or tangents in a fraction.
Check that the same two angles are used throughout and that no number multiplies only one product; in two products, check too that each angle switches function from one product to the other.
Find the matching row of the table, using Sine Same, Cosine Changes to choose between x + y and x − y.
For a difference, decide which angle is x: the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine either order gives the same answer.
Add or subtract the angles, giving fractions with π a common bottom, and reduce.
Evaluate the one function from the special angles, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
Check with a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or with a test angle.
sum formula
A sum formula gives the sine, cosine or tangent of two angles added together, a + b, from the values of each angle on its own.
difference formula
A difference formula gives the sine, cosine or tangent of one angle minus another, a − b, from the values of each angle on its own.
cofunction
Two trig functions are cofunctions when one's value at an angle equals the other's value at the complement, the angle that brings it up to 90°. Sine and cosine are cofunctions.
exact value
An exact value is a number written so that it is perfectly right, using whole numbers, fractions, square roots or π, such as . A decimal like 0.866 is only a rounded copy.
1 In plain words
In the earlier lessons each sum formula and difference formula worked forwards: one thing, sin(x − y), came apart into four pieces. Reading a formula backwards is the reverse. Picture a suitcase. Unpacking it lays four things out on the bed in a set arrangement. If you walk in and see those four things in exactly that arrangement, you know which suitcase they came out of, and you can pack them back into one. This pays off when the pieces are hard to work with and the suitcase is not. You cannot find sin 83° from the special angles, yet sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23° packs into sin(83° − 23°), which is sin 60° = .
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: The sine formulas, forwards, The cosine formulas, forwards, The tangent formulas, forwards, Special angle values, Order in a product, Sine and cosine of a negative angle, Subtracting a negative, Multiplying square roots, Fractions with π, Exact values outside quadrant I, Radians to degrees, Calculator mode, Cofunctions, , Combining like terms, A minus sign in front of parentheses, Pulling out a minus sign
- The sine formulas, forwards. sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y and sin(x + y) = sin x cos y + cos x sin y. With x = 90° and y = 30°: sin 60° = (1)() − (0)() = .
- The cosine formulas, forwards. cos(x − y) = cos x cos y + sin x sin y and cos(x + y) = cos x cos y − sin x sin y. With x = y = 45°: cos 0° = + = 1.
- The tangent formulas, forwards. tan(x + y) = and tan(x − y) = . With x = y = 45°: tan 0° = = 0.
- Special angle values. sin 0° = 0, sin 30° = , sin 45° = , sin 60° = , sin 90° = 1. Cosine is the same list from the other end, so cos 0° = 1 and cos 60° = . And tan 45° = 1.
- Order in a product. Swapping two factors does not change a product: 3 × 5 = 5 × 3 = 15, and cos 10° sin 40° = sin 40° cos 10°.
- Sine and cosine of a negative angle. sin(−θ) = −sin θ, but cos(−θ) = cos θ: sin(−30°) = −, while cos(−60°) = .
- Subtracting a negative. Subtracting a negative number adds it: 5 − (−3) = 5 + 3 = 8.
- Multiplying square roots. A square root times itself is the number inside: ()() = = , since · = 2.
- Fractions with π. Give them the same bottom first, then reduce: − = − = = .
- Exact values outside quadrant I. Use the reference angle, then the quadrant's sign: cos 120° has reference angle 60°, and cosine is negative in quadrant II, so cos 120° = −.
- Radians to degrees. π radians is 180°, so put 180° in place of π: = = 45°.
- Calculator mode. Degree mode reads sin(30) as sin 30° = 0.5; radian mode reads it as 30 radians and gives about −0.988 (rounded). Match the mode to the angles.
- Cofunctions. sin(90° − t) = cos t and cos(90° − t) = sin t: cos 60° = sin 30° = , since 90° − 30° = 60°.
- . It holds for every angle: at 30°, ( + ( = + = 1.
- Combining like terms. 7θ − 3θ = 4θ, as 7 apples minus 3 apples is 4 apples.
- A minus sign in front of parentheses. It flips every sign inside: 10 − (6 − 2) = 10 − 6 + 2 = 6.
- Pulling out a minus sign. a − b = −(b − a): 3 − 8 = −5, and −(8 − 3) = −5.
3 Why
An equals sign works in both directions. The difference formula says sin(x − y) and sin x cos y − cos x sin y are the same number for every pair of angles, so wherever you meet the long side you may write the short side instead, the way 3 × 4 = 12 lets you write 12 wherever you see 3 × 4. People read it this way because the long side needs four values and the short side needs one. Problems are often built so that the four values are hard to find while the single angle left over is special.
4 The rule
, for every pair of angles x and y.
Every other sum formula and difference formula can be read from right to left in the same way, the tangent ones wherever they are defined; the table lists all six.
The same idea, five ways
Sine x cosine y minus cosine x sine y is the sine of x minus y.
When you see the sine of one angle times the cosine of a second angle, minus the cosine of the first angle times the sine of the second, you may write the whole thing as the sine of the first angle minus the second.
- sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y, the same equation read forwards
- sin a cos b − cos a sin b = sin(a − b), the same pattern with other letters
Like a cashier trading four quarters for one dollar bill: the same amount of money, carried as one piece instead of four.
four values in, one value out
The same idea, other ways
Start pointing right and turn 83° counterclockwise, then turn back 23°. You stop at 60°. The long expression sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23° is the sine of the place where you stop: one angle, one height on the unit circle, sin 60° = .
You have done this with plain numbers. Nobody wants to work out 17 × 46 + 17 × 54 piece by piece. Spot the shared 17 and pack it: 17 × (46 + 54) = 17 × 100 = 1700. That is the distributive law read backwards. Reading a trig formula backwards is the same move: the pieces sin 83° and cos 23° are hard to find, and the packed angle, 60°, is special.
Sine Same, Cosine Changes. Look at the sign between the two products. In a sine pattern it is the same as the sign between the angles; in a cosine pattern it is the opposite. So sin x cos y − cos x sin y is sin(x − y), but cos x cos y − sin x sin y is cos(x + y).
sin x cos y + cos x sin y = sin(x + y)
An equation says its two sides are the same number. The difference formula sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y was proved for every pair of angles, so read from right to left it is still true: sin x cos y − cos x sin y = sin(x − y). Nothing new needs proving. You are only choosing which of two names for one number to write, and the short name is usually the one you can evaluate.
| The long side you see | How to spot it | Pack it into |
|---|---|---|
| each product a sine times a cosine, minus between | ||
| sin x cos y + cos x sin y | each product a sine times a cosine, plus between | sin(x + y) |
| cos x cos y + sin x sin y | cosines together, sines together, plus between | |
| cosines together, sines together, minus between | cos(x + y) | |
| tangents, minus on top, plus on the bottom | ||
| tangents, plus on top, minus on the bottom | tan(x + y) |
5 How
- Name the two functions in each product. A sine times a cosine in both products points to a sine formula. A cosine times a cosine in one product and a sine times a sine in the other point to a cosine formula. A fraction of tangents points to a tangent formula.
- Check that the same two angles appear in both products, that each angle switches function from one product to the other, and that no number multiplies only one product. If any check fails, stop: no formula packs it.
- Choose between x + y and x − y with Sine Same, Cosine Changes: a sine pattern keeps the sign between the products as the sign between the angles, a cosine pattern switches it, and a tangent fraction keeps it on top and switches it on the bottom.
- For a difference, put first the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine the order does not matter.
- Work out the one angle, giving fractions with π a common bottom, then evaluate its sine, cosine or tangent, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
- Check the answer a second way: a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or a test angle put into both the start and the answer.
Matching an expression to a formula and packing it
- Name the two functions in each product: a sine with a cosine, a cosine with a cosine and a sine with a sine, or tangents in a fraction.
- Check that the same two angles are used throughout and that no number multiplies only one product; in two products, check too that each angle switches function from one product to the other.
- Find the matching row of the table, using Sine Same, Cosine Changes to choose between x + y and x − y.
- For a difference, decide which angle is x: the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine either order gives the same answer.
- Add or subtract the angles, giving fractions with π a common bottom, and reduce.
- Evaluate the one function from the special angles, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
- Check with a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or with a test angle.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Packing sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23°
Find the exact value of sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23°.
Show the steps and the answer
x = 83°, y = 23°
- Say what the question asks: one number for the whole expression, written exactly with fractions and roots, not as a rounded decimal.An exact value is the number itself, such as . A decimal such as 0.866 is only close to it.
- Name the functions in each product: is a sine times a cosine, and is a cosine times a sine.When each product holds one sine and one cosine, only a sine formula can have produced it.
- Check the angles: both products use and , and no number stands in front of either product.The formula packs only when the same two angles fill both products.
- The sign between the products is minus, so the pattern is .Sine Same: in a sine formula the sign between the products is the sign between the angles.
- and .x is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, and that product is sin 83° cos 23°.
- Pack it: .The two sides of the difference formula are the same number, so the long side may be traded for the short one.
- .60° is a special angle: in the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side opposite 60° is , and opposite over hypotenuse is .
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 8
A sine difference
Write sin 47° cos 17° − cos 47° sin 17° as one sine, then give its exact value.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: trade the four values for a single sine, then name that sine's exact value.Packing comes first, and the value of the packed sine comes second.
- Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use and , and a minus sits between them.That is the shape of sin x cos y − cos x sin y.
- and .sin 47° sits in the product before the minus sign.
- Pack it: .The difference formula read from right to left.
- .In the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side opposite 30° is 1.
- As one sine: sin 30°
- Exact value:
Rung 2 of 8
A plus sign, so a sine sum
Find the exact value of sin 52° cos 38° + cos 52° sin 38°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.Neither 52° nor 38° is a special angle, so their four values will not give an exact answer one at a time.
- Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use and , and a plus sits between them.That is the shape of sin x cos y + cos x sin y.
- Pack it: .Sine Same: a plus between the products means a plus between the angles. With a plus the order does not matter, since 52° + 38° = 38° + 52°.
- .At 90° the point on the unit circle is (0, 1), and the sine is its height.
Rung 3 of 8
Cosine switches the sign
Find the exact value of cos 80° cos 35° + sin 80° sin 35°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.80° and 35° are not special angles, but the expression may pack into one angle that is.
- One product is a cosine times a cosine and the other a sine times a sine, both with and .Cosines together and sines together is the shape of a cosine formula.
- The sign between the products is plus, so the angles are subtracted: .Cosine Changes: in a cosine formula the sign between the angles is the opposite of the sign between the products.
- Pack it with and : .The other order, cos(35° − 80°) = cos(−45°), is the same number, because cos(−θ) = cos θ.
- .45° is a special angle, and its cosine equals its sine, .
Rung 4 of 8
A tangent fraction
Find the exact value of .
Show the steps and the answer
top: tan 33° + tan 12°, the same sign as the angles
bottom: 1 − tan 33° tan 12°, the sign switched
= tan(33° + 12°) = tan 45° = 1
- Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole fraction.tan 33° and tan 12° are not special values, but the fraction may pack into one tangent that is.
- Two tangents on top with a plus, and 1 minus the product of the same two tangents on the bottom.That is the shape of = tan(x + y).
- Check the signs: plus on top, minus on the bottom.The top keeps the sign of the angles, as sine does, and the bottom switches it, as cosine does. Matching signs on top and bottom would not pack.
- Pack it: .The tangent sum formula read from right to left.
- .In the 45-45-90 triangle the opposite and adjacent sides are equal, so opposite over adjacent is 1.
Rung 5 of 8
The angles in a scrambled order
Find the exact value of cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65°.
Show the steps and the answer
x = 65°, y = 20°
- Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.20° and 65° are not special angles, but their difference, 45°, is.
- Each product is a cosine times a sine, both use and , and a minus sits between them.One sine and one cosine in each product means a sine formula, whatever order the factors are written in.
- Rewrite each product with the sine first: , and .Swapping the two factors of a product does not change it, as 3 × 5 = 5 × 3.
- It now reads , so and .x is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, and that sine is sin 65°, even though 20° was printed first.
- Pack it: .The difference formula read from right to left, then the special angle 45°.
Rung 6 of 8
Radians with different bottoms
Find the exact value of cos() cos() − sin() sin().
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression, with the angles in radians.The formulas work the same way in radians as in degrees.
- Cosines together, sines together, both with and , and a minus between them.That is the shape of cos x cos y − sin x sin y.
- The minus between the products means the angles are added: , with and .Cosine Changes: the sign between the angles is the opposite of the sign between the products.
- Give the fractions a common bottom: , so .Fractions add only when their bottoms match, and multiplying the top and bottom of by 4 makes the bottom 12 without changing the value.
- Reduce: , dividing the top and bottom by 3.The reduced form is the one you can find on the unit circle.
- . lies in quadrant II with reference angle . cos() = , and cosine is negative in quadrant II.
Rung 7 of 8
Simplify, with a letter for the angle
Simplify sin(5θ) cos(2θ) − cos(5θ) sin(2θ).
Show the steps and the answer
θ = 30°
start: sin 150° cos 60° − cos 150° sin 60° = 1
answer: sin(3 · 30°) = sin 90° = 1
3 sin 30° = , a different number
- Say what it asks: rewrite the expression with as few trig values as possible. There is no single number to find, because can be any angle.To simplify is to make an expression shorter while keeping its value the same for every θ.
- Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use the angles and , and a minus sits between them.x and y can stand for any angles, including 5θ and 2θ.
- and .sin(5θ) sits in the product before the minus sign.
- Pack it: .The difference formula read from right to left, then 5θ − 2θ = 3θ, as 5 apples minus 2 apples is 3 apples.
- Stop at . Do not rewrite it as .The number inside does not come out in front: at θ = 30°, sin(3θ) = sin 90° = 1, but 3 sin 30° = .
Rung 8 of 8
Rung 8, genuinely hard: the letter cancels
Show that sin(θ + 40°) cos(θ − 20°) − cos(θ + 40°) sin(θ − 20°) has the same value for every angle θ, and find that value.
Show the steps and the answer
= 60°
- Say what it asks: pack the expression and see whether survives. If cancels, the expression is one fixed number.An expression has the same value for every θ when θ no longer appears in it.
- Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use the angles and , and a minus sits between them.x and y can be whole expressions: here x = θ + 40° and y = θ − 20°.
- Check the order: sits in the product before the minus sign, so .In a sine difference the order decides the sign of the answer.
- Pack it: .The difference formula read from right to left, with parentheses kept around each angle so that the whole of y is subtracted.
- Subtract with care: .The minus in front of (θ − 20°) flips both signs inside, so −20° becomes +20°, and θ − θ = 0.
- .60° is a special angle: opposite over hypotenuse in the 30-60-90 triangle is .
- θ cancels, so the value is the same for every θ
- The value: sin 60° =
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: Sine Same, Cosine Changes. In a sine formula the sign between the products is the same as the sign between the angles. In a cosine formula it changes to the opposite. A tangent fraction does both: its top keeps the sign, as sine does, and its bottom changes it, as cosine does.
- Look at the shape before the signs. If every product pairs a sine with a cosine, think sine. If the cosines sit together and the sines sit together, think cosine.
- The giveaway in a problem: two angles that are not special but whose sum or difference is, such as 83° and 23°, which make 60°. That is a hint the expression is meant to be packed, and once the pattern is spotted the packing takes one step.
- Check by typing the whole long side into a calculator as one line, in degree mode for degrees and radian mode for angles with π. Rounding each piece first can change the last digit and make a right answer look wrong.
- To check a simplification with θ, put one test angle such as θ = 30° into the start and into your answer. A wrong answer almost always fails this test, though one match does not prove the step.
- A number that multiplies both products can wait outside: 2 sin x cos y − 2 cos x sin y = 2 sin(x − y).
- With cosine the order of the two angles does not matter, since cos(−θ) = cos θ: cos(80° − 35°) and cos(35° − 80°) are both cos 45°. With sine and tangent the order decides the sign of the answer.
7 The trap
Taking the angles in the order they are printed. In a sine difference, the first angle is the one whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, wherever that sine is written. So cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65° is sin(65° − 20°) = , not sin(20° − 65°). The wrong order gives the negative of the right answer, because sin(−45°) = −sin 45°. Before you subtract, find the sine in the product before the minus sign and put its angle first.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Pack cos 10° sin 40° − sin 10° cos 40° into one sine. Which angle goes first, and what is the value?
- 40° goes first, because sin 40° is the sine in the product before the minus sign. Sine Same keeps the minus.
- The printed order, sin(10° − 40°), gives −: the right size with the wrong sign.
Pack cos cos + sin sin into one cosine. What is its value?
- Cosine Changes, so the plus between the products becomes a minus between the angles: cos( − ).
- The bottoms already match, so − = , and dividing top and bottom by 4 gives .
Pack into one tangent. What is its value?
- The plus on top is the sign between the angles, and the minus on the bottom is the switched sign, so the fraction matches the tangent sum formula.
Which three checks tell you that four pieces came out of one suitcase, so a sum formula or difference formula can pack them?
- The same two angles appear in both products. sin 50° cos 20° + cos 50° sin 30° fails: one product has 20°, the other 30°.
- Each angle switches function between the products. sin 30° cos 60° + cos 60° sin 30° fails: 30° sits under a sine both times, and the sum is + = , not sin 90° = 1.
- No number multiplies only one product. 2 sin x cos y + cos x sin y fails: the 2 stands in front of the first product only.