Quarry School

Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b — quick review

In plain words

Picture a Ferris wheel whose seats sit 1 unit from the center, with your seat starting at the far right.

Rule

cos(a + b) ≠ cos a + cos b in general: for example, cos(π4 + π4) = cos π2 = 0, while cos π4 + cos π4 = 2. Sine behaves the same way: sin(a + b) ≠ sin a + sin b in general.

Step

  1. Read the parentheses as an instruction: cos(a + b) means add the angles first, then take one cosine of the total.

  2. To test a claim such as cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, pick angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle: 0, π6, π4, π3, π2 or π.

  3. Work the left side: add the angles, find where the total turn lands on the unit circle, and read the x of that point.

  4. Work the right side: read the x for each angle on its own, then add the two numbers.

  5. Compare the two sides. If they differ, the claim is false and your pair is a counterexample. If they agree, nothing is proved yet: try another pair.

  6. Finish with a size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1, so a side outside that range cannot be a single cosine.

Strategy

  1. Write the claim with its two sides apart: the left side cos(a + b) and the right side cos a + cos b.

  2. Choose angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle. For a cosine claim, b = 0 is the fastest choice; for a sine claim, avoid 0 and use π4 or π2.

  3. Work out each side on its own, inside the parentheses first.

  4. Compare. Different numbers: the claim is false, and your pair is a counterexample. Equal numbers: try another pair, because one match proves nothing.

Question

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = π4 and b = π4.

Answer

cos(π4 + π4) = cos π2 = 0
cos π4 + cos π4 = 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
The sides differ, so cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b is false.

Trap

Splitting the cosine over the plus sign: writing cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, or its twin cos(2a) = 2 cos a. Avoid it by adding the angles first and taking one cosine of the total, then checking that the answer lies from −1 to 1.

Term

sum formula

Definition

A sum formula gives the sine, cosine or tangent of two angles added together, a + b, from the values of each angle on its own.

Term

exact value

Definition

An exact value is a number written so that it is perfectly right, using whole numbers, fractions, square roots or π, such as 32. A decimal like 0.866 is only a rounded copy.