Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b
Quick review (2 minutes)
Picture a Ferris wheel whose seats sit 1 unit from the center, with your seat starting at the far right.
cos(a + b) ≠ cos a + cos b in general: for example, cos( + ) = cos = 0, while cos + cos = . Sine behaves the same way: sin(a + b) ≠ sin a + sin b in general.
Read the parentheses as an instruction: cos(a + b) means add the angles first, then take one cosine of the total.
To test a claim such as cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, pick angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle: 0, , , , or π.
Work the left side: add the angles, find where the total turn lands on the unit circle, and read the x of that point.
Work the right side: read the x for each angle on its own, then add the two numbers.
Compare the two sides. If they differ, the claim is false and your pair is a counterexample. If they agree, nothing is proved yet: try another pair.
Finish with a size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1, so a side outside that range cannot be a single cosine.
Write the claim with its two sides apart: the left side cos(a + b) and the right side cos a + cos b.
Choose angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle. For a cosine claim, b = 0 is the fastest choice; for a sine claim, avoid 0 and use or .
Work out each side on its own, inside the parentheses first.
Compare. Different numbers: the claim is false, and your pair is a counterexample. Equal numbers: try another pair, because one match proves nothing.
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = and b = .
cos( + ) = cos = 0
cos + cos = ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
The sides differ, so cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b is false.
Splitting the cosine over the plus sign: writing cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, or its twin cos(2a) = 2 cos a. Avoid it by adding the angles first and taking one cosine of the total, then checking that the answer lies from −1 to 1.
sum formula
A sum formula gives the sine, cosine or tangent of two angles added together, a + b, from the values of each angle on its own.
exact value
An exact value is a number written so that it is perfectly right, using whole numbers, fractions, square roots or π, such as . A decimal like 0.866 is only a rounded copy.
1 In plain words
Picture a Ferris wheel whose seats sit 1 unit from the center, with your seat starting at the far right. The cosine of a turn tells how far right of the center your seat ends up. Turn 45° upward: your seat is about 0.7 to the right. Turn 45° more: you are at the very top, 0 to the right. Now try the tempting shortcut and add the two single-turn answers: 0.7 + 0.7 = 1.4. That would put your seat 1.4 to the right, farther out than any seat on the wheel can go. Two turns in a row do not add their cosines, because the wheel is round. Turn first, then read the cosine of the whole turn.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Sine and cosine on the unit circle, Radians and degrees, Inside the parentheses first, Adding fractions with π, Adding like radicals, The special values, Negative angles
- Sine and cosine on the unit circle. A turn of θ from the positive x-axis lands at a point (x, y) on the circle of radius 1; cos θ = x and sin θ = y. Example: lands at (0, 1), so cos = 0 and sin = 1.
- Radians and degrees. π = 180°, so = 30°, = 45°, = 60° and = 90°.
- Inside the parentheses first. As in 2 × (3 + 4) = 2 × 7 = 14, the parentheses in cos(a + b) say to add the angles before taking the cosine.
- Adding fractions with π. Same bottoms: add the tops, then reduce, so + = = . Different bottoms: rewrite first, so + = + = = .
- Adding like radicals. Count the roots like apples: + = = , since one plus one is two , and = 1.
- The special values. cos 0 = 1, cos = ≈ 0.866, cos = sin = ≈ 0.7071, cos = , cos = 0 and cos π = −1 (decimals rounded).
- Negative angles. A negative angle turns clockwise. − = −60° lands at (, −), so cos(−) = , the same x as for .
3 Why
Every cosine is an x coordinate on the unit circle, so no cosine is bigger than 1. Yet cos a + cos b reaches 1 + 1 = 2 when a = b = 0, so the two sides cannot always agree. Sharper still, keep any a and put b = 0. Turning by 0 changes nothing, so the left side is cos a, while the right side is cos a + cos 0 = cos a + 1. No number equals itself plus 1. One failing case, called a counterexample, is enough to throw a rule out.
4 The rule
in general: for example, , while .
Sine behaves the same way: in general.
The same idea, five ways
the cosine of the quantity a plus b is, in general, not the cosine of a plus the cosine of b.
Taking the cosine of the whole turn a + b usually gives a different number from taking the cosine of each turn and adding the two.
- cos(a + b) ≠ cos a + cos b, in general
- cos( + ) = 0, but cos + cos =
- cos(2a) ≠ 2 cos a, in general (the case a = b)
- sin(a + b) ≠ sin a + sin b, in general
- Graph words: on the graph of y = cos x, the height at x = a + b is, in general, not the height at x = a plus the height at x = b
A taxi charges a $3 flat fee plus $2 a mile. One 10-mile ride costs $23, but two 5-mile rides cost $26, because splitting the trip pays the flat fee twice.
The same idea, other ways
Start at (1, 0) on the unit circle. Turn a = 45°: the point lands at (, ), about (0.7071, 0.7071). Turn b = 45° more, starting where you stopped: the point lands at the top, (0, 1). The x, which is the cosine, went from 1 to about 0.7071 to 0. The first turn moved it left by about 0.29, the second by about 0.71, because the circle curves. Adding the two single-turn cosines, 0.7071 + 0.7071 = 1.4142, would put the point past the circle's right edge at x = 1.
A taxi charges a $3 flat fee plus $2 a mile. One 10-mile ride costs 3 + 2 × 10 = $23. Two 5-mile rides cost 3 + 2 × 5 = $13 each, so $26 in all, because the flat fee is paid twice. The fare for a whole trip is not the fare for its first half plus the fare for its second half. Cosine has a flat fee of its own: a turn of 0 still has cosine 1. Turning by a and then by 0 is the same as turning by a, yet the shortcut cos a + cos 0 adds that 1 on top.
Most functions do not split over a plus sign, and you have met this before. (3 + 4 = = 49, but + = 9 + 16 = 25. = = 5, but + = 3 + 4 = 7. Cosine joins the list. One kind of splitting that does work is multiplying by a number: 3(2 + 5) = 3 · 7 = 21, and 3 · 2 + 3 · 5 = 6 + 15 = 21. The cos in cos(a + b) is not a number being multiplied; it is the name of a function. Work out the inside first, then apply the function once.
(3 + 4 = 49, but + = 25
= 5, but + = 7
cos( + ) = 0, but cos + cos =
Inside first, then the function once
Suppose cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b were true for every pair of angles, and put b = 0. Turning by a and then by 0 is the same as turning by a, so the left side is cos a. The right side is cos a + cos 0 = cos a + 1, because a turn of 0 leaves the point at (1, 0), whose x is 1. The rule would then say cos a = cos a + 1: a number equal to itself plus 1. No number is, so the rule breaks for every angle a as soon as b = 0.
Try three small pairs, each with a = b. With a = b = 0, the left side is cos 0 = 1 and the right side is 1 + 1 = 2. With a = b = , the left side is cos π = −1 and the right side is 0 + 0 = 0. With a = b = , the left side is cos = 0 and the right side is ≈ 1.414 (rounded). Three pairs, three mismatches: the shortcut is wrong, not unlucky.
| a | b | a + b | cos(a + b) | cos a + cos b | Equal? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 + 1 = 2 | no |
| no | |||||
| 0 | no | ||||
| 0 | no | ||||
| π | 0 + 0 = 0 | no | |||
| 0 | 1 | yes, by luck |
5 How
- Read the parentheses as an instruction: cos(a + b) means add the angles first, then take one cosine of the total.
- To test a claim such as cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, pick angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle: 0, , , , or π.
- Work the left side: add the angles, find where the total turn lands on the unit circle, and read the x of that point.
- Work the right side: read the x for each angle on its own, then add the two numbers.
- Compare the two sides. If they differ, the claim is false and your pair is a counterexample. If they agree, nothing is proved yet: try another pair.
- Finish with a size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1, so a side outside that range cannot be a single cosine.
Testing a claimed rule with numbers
- Write the claim with its two sides apart: the left side cos(a + b) and the right side cos a + cos b.
- Choose angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle. For a cosine claim, b = 0 is the fastest choice; for a sine claim, avoid 0 and use or .
- Work out each side on its own, inside the parentheses first.
- Compare. Different numbers: the claim is false, and your pair is a counterexample. Equal numbers: try another pair, because one match proves nothing.
6 Worked example
Worked example
The counterexample a = b =
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = and b = .
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: work out the left side and the right side with and , then see whether the two numbers match.A rule has to give equal sides for every pair of angles, so one pair where the sides differ shows the claim is false.
- Left side, inside first: .The parentheses say to add the angles before taking any cosine. Both bottoms are 4, so add the tops, π + π = 2π, then divide the top and bottom of by 2.
- Picture the two turns one after the other: from the positive x-axis, then more from where the first turn stopped. Together they make , which ends at the top of the unit circle, the point (0, 1).π = 180°, so = 45° and = 90°, and a 90° turn from the positive x-axis points straight up.
- So .The cosine of an angle is the x of the point where the turn lands, and the point (0, 1) has x = 0.
- Right side: , an exact value.A 45° turn lands at (, ) on the unit circle, from the 45-45-90 triangle with hypotenuse 1, and the cosine is the x of that point.
- Add the two cosines: .The bottoms match, so add the tops: one plus one is two . Then = 1 leaves .
- Compare: the left side is 0 and the right side is (rounded). They are different numbers. is a positive number, about 1.414, so it is not 0.
- Conclude: the claim is false, and the pair is a counterexample.A counterexample is one case where a claimed rule gives the wrong answer, and one is enough to throw the rule out.
- cos + cos = ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
- The sides differ, so cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b is false.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 5
No turn at all
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = 0 and b = 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out each side with and , then compare.If the two sides differ for even one pair of angles, the claim is false.
- Left side: , so .Inside the parentheses first. A turn of 0 leaves the point at (1, 0), and the cosine is its x, 1.
- Right side: .Each cos 0 is 1, for the same reason as on the left.
- Compare: , so the claim fails.The two sides give different numbers for this pair, so a = b = 0 is a counterexample.
- cos(0 + 0) = 1
- cos 0 + cos 0 = 2
- The claim fails.
Rung 2 of 5
Two quarter turns
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = and b = .
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out each side with , then compare.One pair where the sides differ is enough to show the claim is false.
- Left side, inside first: .The bottoms match, so add the tops, then divide the top and bottom of by 2.
- .π = 180°, a half turn, which ends at the far left of the unit circle, (−1, 0), and the cosine is its x.
- Right side: .A quarter turn, 90°, ends at the top, (0, 1), whose x is 0.
- Compare: , so the claim fails again.The two sides give different numbers.
- The claim fails.
Rung 3 of 5
Two different special angles
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = and b = .
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out each side with , which is , and , which is , then compare.One pair where the sides differ is enough to show the claim is false.
- Left side, inside first: .The bottoms differ, so rewrite with bottom 6 by multiplying its top and bottom by 2. Then add the tops, and divide the top and bottom of by 3.
- .60° + 30° = 90°, a quarter turn to the top point (0, 1), whose x is 0.
- Right side: .60° lands at (, ) and 30° at (, ), from the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 1, so the cosines are and . The bottoms match, so the tops go over one bottom. 1 and are different kinds of number, so 1 + stays as it is; it is not .
- Compare: (rounded), which is not 0. The claim fails. ≈ 1.732 (rounded), and a positive number divided by 2 is still positive, so it cannot be 0.
- cos + cos = ≈ 1.366 (rounded)
- The claim fails.
Rung 4 of 5
Sine has the same problem
Test the sine version, sin(a + b) = sin a + sin b, with a = and b = .
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: this is the same test with sine in place of cosine, so work out each side and compare.Sine is the y of the point where a turn lands, so it can fail for the same reason cosine does.
- Left side: , so .Two 45° turns end at the top point (0, 1), and the sine is its y, 1.
- Right side: .A 45° turn lands at (, ), so each sine is , and two halves of make one .
- Compare: (rounded), so the sine claim fails too.The two sides give different numbers.
- Gotcha: do not test sine with . Then and , which match for every a.sin 0 = 0, so adding it changes nothing; a test pair is useful only if it can show a difference.
- sin + sin = ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
- The sine claim fails too.
Rung 5 of 5
A lucky match proves nothing
Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = and b = −. Does the result rescue the claim?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out each side with and , compare, then decide whether one match can make the claim true.A rule must hold for every pair of angles, so one pair that agrees and one pair that disagrees carry very different weight.
- Left side, inside first: , so .A number plus its negative is 0. Turning 60° one way and 60° back leaves the point where it started, at (1, 0).
- Right side: .60° lands at (, ). A negative angle turns clockwise, so −60° lands at (, −), the mirror point below the x-axis with the same x, .
- Compare: . The two sides agree for this pair.Both sides came out to the same number.
- Decide: the claim is still false, because the pair already breaks it, with 0 on the left and on the right.A pair that disagrees disproves a claim; a pair that agrees shows only that the claim happens to work there.
- The sides agree here by luck; the claim is still false.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: turn first, cosine last. Add the angles inside the parentheses, then take one cosine of the whole turn.
- Size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1. If a cosine comes out as 2 or ≈ 1.414, something was split that should not have been.
- The size check does not catch every mistake: with a = b = the two sides are −1 and 0, both inside the range and still different. Compare the numbers as well.
- Fastest test for a cosine claim: put b = 0. The left side stays cos a, but the right side becomes cos a + 1, one too big. For sine, 0 hides the mistake because sin 0 = 0, so test with a = b = instead.
- Write the parentheses. cos a + b means find cos a, then add the angle b; only cos(a + b) is the cosine of the whole turn.
- The same warning holds for tangent: tan( + ) = tan does not exist, since the top point (0, 1) would need 1 ÷ 0, while tan + tan = 1 + 1 = 2. The correct sum formula for each function is built in the lessons that follow.
- In this lesson's table, a decimal after ≈ is rounded to three places.
7 The trap
Splitting the cosine over the plus sign: writing cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, or its twin cos(2a) = 2 cos a. Avoid it by adding the angles first and taking one cosine of the total, then checking that the answer lies from −1 to 1.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Work out cos(a + b) and cos a + cos b for a = and b = . Do they match?
- cos(a + b) = cos = 0, since + = + = = .
- cos a + cos b = + = ≈ 1.37 (rounded).
- They do not match. No seat on the Ferris wheel sits 1.37 to the right of the center, so 1.37 cannot be one cosine.
Someone writes sin( + ) = sin + sin = 2. What went wrong?
- They split the sine over the plus sign.
- Angles first: + = π, a half turn that leaves your Ferris wheel seat at the far left, level with the center, so sin π = 0.
- Size check: sine is the seat's height above the center, never more than 1, so 2 cannot be one sine.
Does cos(2a) equal 2 cos a? Try a = .
- No.
- Angle doubled first: 2 · = , and cos = −.
- Cosine doubled: 2 · cos = 2 · = 1.
- Twice the turn puts your Ferris wheel seat to the left of the center, not 1 to the right.
For a = and b = π, cos(a + b) and cos a + cos b agree. Are they equal for every a and b?
- No.
- Angles first: + π = + = , and cos = −.
- Cosines added: cos + cos π = + (−1) = −, so this pair agrees by chance.
- An agreeing pair proves nothing yet; one failing pair, a counterexample such as a = b = , throws the claim out.