Quarry School

Checking for extra solutions after squaring — quick review

In plain words

Some trigonometric equations mix sine and cosine in a way none of the earlier methods can untangle, so you square both sides.

Rule

If a = b, then a2 = b2, but a2 = b2 only tells you that a = b or a = −b. So squaring both sides never loses a solution and can add extraneous solutions: keep a candidate only if it makes the original equation true.

Step

  1. Write the original equation where you will see it at the end. It is the judge.

  2. Square both sides, the whole of each side at once, keeping the middle term: (a + b)2 = a2 + 2ab + b2.

  3. Use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1, get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.

  4. Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π). Every answer you get is a candidate.

  5. Put each candidate into the original equation, not the squared one. Keep it only if the two sides match, sign included.

  6. Each kept solution on one turn, a, gives the general solution t = a + 2kπ, k any integer.

Strategy

  1. Write the original equation where you will see it at the end: it is the judge.

  2. Pick a shape: square both sides as they stand, or first move one term across so each side holds a single function.

  3. Square the whole of each side, keeping the middle term: (a − b)2 = a2 − 2ab + b2.

  4. Use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 to cancel the squares or to rewrite everything in one function.

  5. Get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.

  6. Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π): these are the candidates.

  7. Put each candidate into the original equation and keep it only if both sides match, sign included.

  8. For the general solution, add 2kπ to each kept answer.

Question

Solve cos t − sin t = 1 on one turn, [0, 2π), then write the general solution. In plain words: find every angle where the cosine minus the sine comes out to exactly 1, then describe all such angles on every turn.

Answer

On one turn: t = 0 and t = 3π2
General solution: t = 2kπ or t = 3π2 + 2kπ, k any integer
Extraneous: π2 and π

Trap

Writing the candidates as the answer. After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, the list 0, π2, π, 3π2 looks finished, but at t = π the left side is sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, and 3π2 fails the same way. Put every candidate back into the original equation, never the squared one, before you write the answer.

Term

solution on one turn

Definition

A solution inside one trip around the circle, the interval [0, 2π). The start, 0, is included; the end, 2π, is left out because it is the same spot as 0.

Term

general solution

Definition

One formula naming every solution: the solutions on one turn plus any whole number of periods, as in t = a + 2kπ, where k is any integer, negative, zero or positive.

Term

period

Definition

How far you go along before a function's pattern starts over. Sine and cosine repeat every 2π, one full turn; tangent repeats every π, half a turn.

Term

reference angle

Definition

The angle between an angle's ending ray, its terminal side, and the nearest part of the x-axis, from 0 to π2. Angles sharing one have the same sine and cosine except for sign.

Term

extraneous solution

Definition

A value that a solving step produced but that fails the original equation. Squaring both sides can create one, so every candidate goes back into the equation you started with.