Checking for extra solutions after squaring
Quick review (2 minutes)
Some trigonometric equations mix sine and cosine in a way none of the earlier methods can untangle, so you square both sides.
If a = b, then = , but = only tells you that a = b or a = −b. So squaring both sides never loses a solution and can add extraneous solutions: keep a candidate only if it makes the original equation true.
Write the original equation where you will see it at the end. It is the judge.
Square both sides, the whole of each side at once, keeping the middle term: (a + b = + 2ab + .
Use t + t = 1, get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π). Every answer you get is a candidate.
Put each candidate into the original equation, not the squared one. Keep it only if the two sides match, sign included.
Each kept solution on one turn, a, gives the general solution t = a + 2kπ, k any integer.
Write the original equation where you will see it at the end: it is the judge.
Pick a shape: square both sides as they stand, or first move one term across so each side holds a single function.
Square the whole of each side, keeping the middle term: (a − b = − 2ab + .
Use t + t = 1 to cancel the squares or to rewrite everything in one function.
Get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π): these are the candidates.
Put each candidate into the original equation and keep it only if both sides match, sign included.
For the general solution, add 2kπ to each kept answer.
Solve cos t − sin t = 1 on one turn, [0, 2π), then write the general solution. In plain words: find every angle where the cosine minus the sine comes out to exactly 1, then describe all such angles on every turn.
On one turn: t = 0 and t =
General solution: t = 2kπ or t = + 2kπ, k any integer
Extraneous: and π
Writing the candidates as the answer. After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, the list 0, , π, looks finished, but at t = π the left side is sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, and fails the same way. Put every candidate back into the original equation, never the squared one, before you write the answer.
solution on one turn
A solution inside one trip around the circle, the interval [0, 2π). The start, 0, is included; the end, 2π, is left out because it is the same spot as 0.
general solution
One formula naming every solution: the solutions on one turn plus any whole number of periods, as in t = a + 2kπ, where k is any integer, negative, zero or positive.
period
How far you go along before a function's pattern starts over. Sine and cosine repeat every 2π, one full turn; tangent repeats every π, half a turn.
reference angle
The angle between an angle's ending ray, its terminal side, and the nearest part of the x-axis, from 0 to . Angles sharing one have the same sine and cosine except for sign.
extraneous solution
A value that a solving step produced but that fails the original equation. Squaring both sides can create one, so every candidate goes back into the equation you started with.
1 In plain words
Some trigonometric equations mix sine and cosine in a way none of the earlier methods can untangle, so you square both sides. Squaring is like fishing with a wide net: you catch every fish you wanted, plus a few you did not. After squaring, then, each answer you find is only a candidate, an answer that still has to pass a test. The test is the original equation, the one you started with. Put each candidate back into it. Keep the ones that make it true and throw the others back. A candidate that fails is an extraneous solution: extra, not real. Squaring sin t + cos t = 1, for example, hands you four candidates on one turn, and only two pass.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Squaring a sum or a difference, The Pythagorean identity, Moving a term across, Distributing, The zero-product rule, Factoring, Sine and cosine where the circle meets the axes, The reference angle and quadrant method, Fractions of π, Sign rules, The square-root sign, The general solution
- Squaring a sum or a difference. (a + b = + 2ab + and (a − b = − 2ab + : (x + 3 = + 6x + 9, not + 9.
- The Pythagorean identity. t + t = 1 for every angle, so t = 1 − t: at t = , + = 1.
- Moving a term across. Adding the same thing to both sides keeps an equation true: add cos t to both sides of sin t − cos t = 1 to get sin t = 1 + cos t.
- Distributing. A number in front multiplies every piece in the brackets: 3(1 − ) = 3 − 3.
- The zero-product rule. If A · B = 0, then A = 0 or B = 0, and it works only with 0 alone on one side: 2 sin t cos t = 0 gives sin t = 0 or cos t = 0.
- Factoring. Pull out a common factor, 2 + 2s = 2s(s + 1), or find two brackets, 2 + c − 1 = (2c − 1)(c + 1). Multiply back to check.
- Sine and cosine where the circle meets the axes. cos t is the x-coordinate and sin t the y-coordinate: (1, 0) at t = 0, (0, 1) at , (−1, 0) at π, (0, −1) at .
- The reference angle and quadrant method. sin t = : reference angle , sine positive in quadrants I and II, so t = and t = π − = .
- Fractions of π. Write both over the same bottom before adding: π + = + = .
- Sign rules. A negative times a negative is positive, (−1 = (−1)(−1) = 1; subtracting a negative adds, 0 − (−1) = 0 + 1 = 1.
- The square-root sign. means the root that is not negative: = 3, never −3.
- The general solution. The period of sine and cosine is 2π, so a kept answer a gives t = a + 2kπ, k any integer (…, −1, 0, 1, …): t = + 2kπ.
3 Why
Squaring works in one direction only. If two numbers are equal, their squares are equal, so no true answer is lost. Going back fails: = 1 and (−1 = 1, so a squared equation cannot tell 1 from −1. Squaring sin t + cos t = 1 gives (sin t + cos t = 1, which is true when the sum is 1 and also when the sum is −1. Every later step solves that wider equation, so the candidates include angles where the sum is −1, such as t = π. Only the original equation can tell the two kinds apart.
4 The rule
If , then , but only tells you that or .
So squaring both sides never loses a solution and can add extraneous solutions: keep a candidate only if it makes the original equation true.
The same idea, five ways
Say “π is an extraneous solution” (ek-STRAY-nee-us). It means π came out of the work but does not solve the original equation.
An extraneous solution is a candidate that the squared equation accepts and the original equation rejects.
- (sin π + cos π = (−1 = 1: the squared equation accepts π
- sin π + cos π = −1 ≠ 1: the original equation rejects π
- on [0, 2π): candidates {0, , π, }; solutions {0, }; extraneous {π, }
- = means a = b or a = −b
- graph words: y = sin t + cos t meets the line y = −1 at t = π, not the line y = 1
A fish that came up in your net but is the wrong kind: it was caught along with the rest, and you throw it back.
The same idea, other ways
Start with x = 3. It has one answer, 3. Square both sides: = 9. Now two numbers work, 3 and −3, because (−3 = 9 as well. Put each one back into x = 3: 3 = 3 is true, −3 = 3 is false. Squaring turned one answer into two candidates, and the original equation threw one back. Trig equations do the same thing, with angles in place of 3 and −3.
x = 3: one answer
= 9: candidates 3 and −3
back into x = 3: 3 passes, −3 fails
On the unit circle, cos t is the x-coordinate and sin t is the y-coordinate, so sin t + cos t = 1 asks for a point whose two coordinates add to 1. Squaring gives four candidates, the points where the circle crosses the axes: (1, 0) at t = 0, (0, 1) at t = , (−1, 0) at t = π and (0, −1) at t = . Adding coordinates gives 1 + 0 = 1, 0 + 1 = 1, −1 + 0 = −1 and 0 + (−1) = −1. The last two sums have the right size and the wrong sign, and size is all that squaring can see.
A friend tells you their apartment is one floor away from yours. That could be the floor above or the floor below: the message keeps the distance and loses the direction. Squaring does the same to a number. The square depends only on how far the number is from 0, not on which side of 0 it is on, so 1 and −1 both square to 1. You knock on both doors, the candidates, and only the original equation tells you which door is your friend's.
Equal numbers have equal squares, so every true answer survives squaring. The reverse fails: = says only that a and b are the same distance from 0, so a = b or a = −b. Once you square sin t + cos t = 1, you are solving two equations at once, sin t + cos t = 1 or sin t + cos t = −1, and no algebra step on the squared equation can tell them apart; only a check in the original can. The card shows the whole chain: every line after the squaring accepts all four candidates, and only the last line, the check, sorts them.
1 + 2 sin t cos t = 1
sin t cos t = 0
sin t = 0 or cos t = 0
candidates on [0, 2π): 0, , π,
check in sin t + cos t = 1: keep 0 and
Square it, then check it. Each time you square both sides, write CHECK in the margin, and do not write the answer until every candidate has gone back into the very first line of your work.
| candidate t | sin t | cos t | sin t + cos t | keep it? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | yes |
| 1 | 0 | 1 | yes | |
| π | 0 | no, extraneous | ||
| 0 | no, extraneous |
5 How
- Write the original equation where you will see it at the end. It is the judge.
- Square both sides, the whole of each side at once, keeping the middle term: (a + b = + 2ab + .
- Use t + t = 1, get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
- Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π). Every answer you get is a candidate.
- Put each candidate into the original equation, not the squared one. Keep it only if the two sides match, sign included.
- Each kept solution on one turn, a, gives the general solution t = a + 2kπ, k any integer.
Solving by squaring, then checking
- Write the original equation where you will see it at the end: it is the judge.
- Pick a shape: square both sides as they stand, or first move one term across so each side holds a single function.
- Square the whole of each side, keeping the middle term: (a − b = − 2ab + .
- Use t + t = 1 to cancel the squares or to rewrite everything in one function.
- Get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
- Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π): these are the candidates.
- Put each candidate into the original equation and keep it only if both sides match, sign included.
- For the general solution, add 2kπ to each kept answer.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Squaring a difference, then checking
Solve cos t − sin t = 1 on one turn, [0, 2π), then write the general solution. In plain words: find every angle where the cosine minus the sine comes out to exactly 1, then describe all such angles on every turn.
Show the steps and the answer
- Keep the original equation in view: .It is the judge at the end. Every candidate goes back into this line, not into a later one.
- Square both sides: .Two different functions sit on the left, and none of the earlier methods joins them. Squaring will make t + t appear, which the identity turns into 1. Doing the same thing to both sides keeps them equal.
- Expand the left side: .(a − b = − 2ab + with a = cos t and b = sin t. The middle term −2 cos t sin t must stay.
- Replace t with 1: . t + t = 1 for every angle, so the two squares together are worth 1.
- Subtract 1 from both sides, then divide both sides by : .This puts 0 alone on one side, which the zero-product rule needs. Subtracting 1 leaves −2 cos t sin t = 0, and 0 ÷ (−2) = 0.
- Use the zero-product rule: or .A product is 0 only when one of its factors is 0, so this step finds every angle that could make the product 0.
- Solve each on one turn. at and ; at and . The candidates are 0, and .cos t is the x-coordinate on the unit circle, 0 at the top (0, 1) and the bottom (0, −1); sin t is the y-coordinate, 0 at (1, 0) and (−1, 0). Plug one back in: at t = , cos t · sin t = 0 · 1 = 0.
- Check in the original: . Keep it.The left side matches the right side, 1. In the table picture, this is the first 1 in the output row.
- Check : , not 1. Throw it out.The left side is −1. It passed the squared equation only because (−1 = 1, so it is an extraneous solution.
- Check : , not 1. Throw it out.Again the left side is −1, the sign that squaring hid.
- Check : . Keep it.Subtracting −1 is the same as adding 1, so the left side is 1 and matches.
- Write the general solution: or , k any integer.The period of cosine and sine is 2π, so each kept answer comes back every full turn; 0 + 2kπ is written 2kπ.
- On one turn: t = 0 and t =
- General solution: t = 2kπ or t = + 2kπ, k any integer
- Extraneous: and π
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 5
Rung 1: watch squaring add answers
Solve cos t = − on one turn by squaring both sides on purpose, then check. You could solve it directly; squaring here lets you watch what squaring does. In plain words: find the angles on one turn whose cosine is −.
Show the steps and the answer
- Square both sides: .(− = (−) · (−) = , since a negative times a negative is positive and · = 3.
- List every value of cos t whose square is : or .Both and − square to . This is the moment the minus sign gets lost.
- Solve : and .cos = , so the reference angle is ; cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV.
- Solve : and .The same reference angle, placed in quadrants II and III, where cosine is negative.
- Check the four candidates in : , throw out; , keep; , keep; , throw out.Only the original equation still knows the cosine must be negative. In the table picture, only the columns holding − are lit.
- t = and t =
- Extraneous: and
Rung 2 of 5
Rung 2: square a whole sum
Solve sin t + cos t = −1 on one turn, then write the general solution. In plain words: find the angles where the sine plus the cosine comes out to exactly −1.
Show the steps and the answer
- Square both sides: .Doing the same thing to both sides keeps them equal, and squaring will make t + t appear.
- Expand the left side: .(a + b = + 2ab + with a = sin t and b = cos t; the middle term is 2 sin t cos t.
- Replace t with 1, then subtract 1 from both sides: .The identity t + t = 1 gives 1 + 2 sin t cos t = 1, and subtracting 1 leaves 0 alone on the right.
- Use the zero-product rule: or . The candidates are 0 and (where ) and and (where ).2 is not 0, so one of sin t and cos t must be 0. Read both off the points where the unit circle meets the axes.
- Check in . At 0: , throw out. At : , throw out. At : , keep. At : , keep.The squared equation cannot see the sign and the original can. The two fakes are the angles where the sum is 1.
- Write the general solution: or , k any integer.The period of sine and cosine is 2π, so each kept answer comes back every full turn.
- On one turn: t = π and t =
- General solution: t = π + 2kπ or t = + 2kπ, k any integer
- Extraneous: 0 and
Rung 3 of 5
Rung 3: move a term first, then square
Solve sin t − cos t = 1 on one turn by first moving cos t to the right side. In plain words: find the angles where the sine minus the cosine is exactly 1.
Show the steps and the answer
- Add cos t to both sides: .With one function alone on the left, its square is the single term t, which the identity can replace.
- Square both sides: t.(1 + cos t = + 2 · 1 · cos t + t, and squaring both sides keeps them equal.
- Replace t with t: t.From t + t = 1. Now cos t is the only function left.
- Subtract t from both sides: .This gets 0 alone on one side: 1 − 1 = 0, and t − (− t) = 2 t.
- Factor and use the zero-product rule: (), so or .2 cos t divides both terms. Plug one back in to see it work: with cos t = −1, 2(−1)(−1 + 1) = 2(−1)(0) = 0.
- List the candidates: at and ; at .On the unit circle x = 0 at the top and the bottom, and x = −1 at the far left. This route gives only three candidates.
- Check in . At : , keep. At : , keep. At : , throw out.Subtracting −1 adds 1. At the moved equation sin t = 1 + cos t reads −1 = 1: equal size, opposite sign, which squaring cannot see. In the table picture, the −1 under is the fake.
- On one turn: t = and t = π
- General solution: t = + 2kπ or t = π + 2kπ, k any integer
- Extraneous:
Rung 4 of 5
Rung 4: a square root on one side
Solve = cos t on one turn. In plain words: find the angles where the square root of 1 − sin t equals the cosine. The square-root sign always means the root that is not negative.
Show the steps and the answer
is never negative
cos π = −1 is negative
so t = π cannot be an answer
kept: t = 0 and t =
- Square both sides: t.Squaring undoes the root: ( = 1 − sin t. The inside is never negative, since sin t is at most 1, so the root always exists.
- Replace t with t: t.From t + t = 1. Now sin t is the only function left.
- Subtract 1 from both sides, then add t to both sides: .This gets 0 alone on one side: −sin t = − t becomes t − sin t = 0.
- Factor: sin t , so or .sin t divides both terms, then the zero-product rule. Plug back: with sin t = 1, 1 · (1 − 1) = 0.
- List the candidates: at 0 and ; at .On the unit circle y = 0 at (1, 0) and (−1, 0), and y = 1 at the top, (0, 1).
- Check in . At 0: and , keep. At : and , keep. At : but , throw out.A square root is never negative, so it can never equal −1. Squaring hid that, because and (−1 are both 1.
- On one turn: t = 0 and t =
- General solution: t = 2kπ or t = + 2kπ, k any integer
- Extraneous: π
Rung 5 of 5
Rung 5: a number in front and two brackets to find
Solve sin t + cos t = 1 on one turn. In plain words: find the angles where times the sine, plus the cosine, is exactly 1.
Show the steps and the answer
- Subtract cos t from both sides: .One function on each side keeps the squares short.
- Square both sides: 3 t.( sin t = ( · t = 3 t, and (1 − cos t = 1 − 2 cos t + t.
- Replace t with t: t.From t + t = 1; the 3 multiplies both pieces, 3(1 − t) = 3 − 3 t.
- Subtract 3 and add 3 t on both sides: .This gets 0 alone on one side: 1 − 3 = −2 and t + 3 t = 4 t.
- Divide both sides by 2: .Smaller numbers factor with less work, and 0 ÷ 2 = 0.
- Factor: .Multiply back to check: 2 t − 2 cos t + cos t − 1 = 2 t − cos t − 1.
- Set each bracket equal to 0: or .The zero-product rule finds the cosines that make the product 0. Plug back: with cos t = −, 2(−) + 1 = −1 + 1 = 0.
- List the candidates: at ; at and .Reference angle , with cosine negative in quadrants II and III: π − = and π + = .
- Check : . Keep it.sin 0 = 0 and cos 0 = 1.
- Check : . Keep it.sin = and cos = −, and · = 3.
- Check : , not 1. Throw it out.In the moved equation sin t = 1 − cos t, the two sides were − and : equal size, opposite sign, exactly what squaring cannot see. In the table picture, the −2 under is the fake.
- On one turn: t = 0 and t =
- General solution: t = 2kπ or t = + 2kπ, k any integer
- Extraneous:
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: “Square it, then check it.” Squaring opens the door to fakes, and the original equation is the bouncer who checks every ticket.
- Check the sign before the size. At each candidate, ask whether the left side of the original equation is positive or negative; if the right side is 1 and the left side is negative, throw the candidate out at once.
- The fakes follow a pattern: the fakes of sin t + cos t = 1, π and , are exactly the answers of sin t + cos t = −1, because both equations square to the same equation.
- Two routes make a good second check. Squaring cos t − sin t = 1 as it stands gives four candidates, and moving sin t across first gives three, yet both end at 0 and .
- Squaring can add answers, while dividing both sides by something that can be 0, such as cos t, can lose them. After either move, look back at the original equation.
- When both sides can never be negative, as with a square root equal to a positive number, squaring adds no fakes: two numbers that are 0 or more with the same square are equal. Check anyway; it takes a minute.
7 The trap
Writing the candidates as the answer. After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, the list 0, , π, looks finished, but at t = π the left side is sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, and fails the same way. Put every candidate back into the original equation, never the squared one, before you write the answer.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
What is an extraneous solution?
What does squaring both sides do to the answers of an equation, and why?
- It keeps every true answer, because if a = b, then = .
- It can add answers that fail the original equation, because = is also true when a = −b: and (−1 are both 1.
After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, should you test the candidate t = π in the squared equation or in the original one?
- In the original one.
- The squared equation passes every candidate, π included: (sin π + cos π = (−1 = 1.
- The original catches it: sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, so t = π is extraneous.
Squaring sin t − cos t = 1 and solving leads to four candidates on one turn: 0, , π and . Which ones make the original equation true?
- and π.
- sin − cos = 1 − 0 = 1, and sin π − cos π = 0 − (−1) = 0 + 1 = 1.
- At 0 and at the left side is −1, not 1, so those two are extraneous.