Equations that factor like a quadratic
Quick review (2 minutes)
A trigonometric equation such as 2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0 looks crowded.
An equation a· t + b·sin t + c = 0, with a ≠ 0, is a quadratic in sin t: writing u = sin t gives a + bu + c = 0. Its solutions are the angles t with sin t = u, for each answer u of the quadratic with −1 ≤ u ≤ 1; an answer outside [−1, 1] gives no angle. Cosine works the same way. For tangent, keep every real answer, since tangent takes every real value.
Get 0 on one side: add or subtract on both sides until every term sits on the left and the right side is 0.
Make sure only one trig function appears (all sin t, or all cos t, or all tan t), with its square in one term.
Write u for that function, so t becomes and sin t becomes u.
Factor the quadratic in u: pull out a common factor when there is no plain number term; otherwise split the middle term and group. Multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored, such as (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0, skips this step.
Set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u (the zero-product rule). Plug each u back into the factored form to see the product is 0.
Put the function back: each value of u becomes a basic equation such as sin t = −.
Throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1: no angle has it. Keep every value of tangent.
Solve each remaining basic equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants. For sine or cosine, the values 1 and −1 give one angle each; the other values give two.
List all the angles in order and put each one back into the original equation.
Solve 2 t − 7 sin t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side equal 4.
t =
t =
Stopping at the values of sin t. Factoring hands you numbers such as sin t = − and sin t = 4, not angles. Each number still needs two more steps: throw it out if it is below −1 or above 1, and otherwise turn it into every angle on one turn with that sine (one angle for 1 and −1, two for the others). Only those angles are the answers.
Zero: move every term to one side so the other side is 0.
Rename: write u for the one trig function in the equation.
Factor the quadratic in u and multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored skips this step.
Zero-product: set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u.
Return: turn each u into a basic equation, such as sin t = −.
Filter: throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1.
Angles: solve each kept equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants.
Check: put every angle back into the original equation.
trigonometric equation
An equation with sine, cosine or tangent of an unknown angle, such as 2 cos t = 1. Most are true at some angles and false at the others; solving one means finding every angle that makes it true. One that is true at every angle is called an identity, and one such as sin t = 2 is true at none.
solution on one turn
A solution inside one trip around the circle, the interval [0, 2π). The start, 0, is included; the end, 2π, is left out because it is the same spot as 0.
general solution
One formula naming every solution: the solutions on one turn plus any whole number of periods, as in t = a + 2kπ, where k is any integer, negative, zero or positive.
period
How far you go along before a function's pattern starts over. Sine and cosine repeat every 2π, one full turn; tangent repeats every π, half a turn.
reference angle
The angle between an angle's ending ray, its terminal side, and the nearest part of the x-axis, from 0 to . Angles sharing one have the same sine and cosine except for sign.
1 In plain words
A trigonometric equation such as 2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0 looks crowded. ( t means sin t times itself.) The trick: cover every sin t with a sticky note marked u. What is left, 2 − 7u − 4 = 0, is a quadratic you already know how to factor. So you solve in two stages, like finding a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1: first the height (the value of sin t), then the spots on the wheel at that height (the angles). No seat is ever more than 1 above or below the center, so if the algebra hands you a height of 4, nothing matches. You cross it out.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: The zero-product rule, Factoring by splitting the middle term, Pulling out a common factor, Moving a term across the equals sign, Solving 2u + 1 = 0, What t means, Sine and cosine stay from −1 to 1, A basic equation on one turn, Adding and subtracting fractions of π
- The zero-product rule. If a product is 0, one of its factors is 0: (u − 3)(u + 4) = 0 means u = 3 or u = −4. It works only when the other side is 0.
- Factoring by splitting the middle term. For a + bu + c, find two numbers that multiply to a·c and add to b, split the middle term with them, and group. For 2 + 5u + 3: a·c = 6, and 2 + 3 = 5, so 2 + 2u + 3u + 3 = 2u(u + 1) + 3(u + 1) = (2u + 3)(u + 1).
- Pulling out a common factor. When every term has a u, take it out front: 2 + u = u(2u + 1). Multiply back to check: u·2u + u·1 = 2 + u.
- Moving a term across the equals sign. Do the same thing to both sides: from = 4u − 3, subtract 4u and add 3 to get − 4u + 3 = 0.
- Solving 2u + 1 = 0. Undo the steps in reverse order: subtract 1 to get 2u = −1, then divide by 2 to get u = −.
- What t means. t is (sin t: find the sine first, then square it. () = ( = , and (− = as well, because a negative times a negative is positive.
- Sine and cosine stay from −1 to 1. On the unit circle, cos t is the x and sin t is the y of a point on a circle of radius 1, so −1 ≤ sin t ≤ 1 and −1 ≤ cos t ≤ 1. Tangent has no such limit.
- A basic equation on one turn. For sin t = −: the reference angle is , and sine is negative in quadrants III and IV, so t = π + = and t = 2π − = .
- Adding and subtracting fractions of π. Rewrite π and 2π with the same bottom first: π + = + = , and 2π − = − = .
3 Why
The equation looks at t only through sin t. So if an angle t makes it true, the number sin t, put in for u, makes 2 − 7u − 4 = 0 true: sin t must be one of the quadratic's answers, − or 4. And any angle whose sine is one of those answers makes the equation true. So the solutions are exactly those angles. The throw-out step comes from the unit circle: its radius is 1, and sin t is the height of a point on it, so sin t is never below −1 or above 1. The algebra cannot know that; the circle does.
4 The rule
An equation , with , is a quadratic in sin t: writing gives bu .
Its solutions are the angles t with , for each answer u of the quadratic with ; an answer outside gives no angle. Cosine works the same way. For tangent, keep every real answer, since tangent takes every real value.
The same idea, five ways
a quadratic in sine t. It means sine t plays the part that x plays in an ordinary quadratic. Read t aloud as sine squared of t.
An equation is a quadratic in sin t when, after you write one letter u for sin t, it has the form a + bu + c = 0 with a not equal to 0.
- a· t + b·sin t + c = 0, with a ≠ 0
- u = sin t turns it into a + bu + c = 0
- 2 t − sin t − 1 = 0 is 2 − u − 1 = 0
- keep an answer u only when −1 ≤ u ≤ 1 (sine and cosine)
Like a box with a label: put sin t in a box marked u, do the algebra with the box, and open it only at the end to find the angles.
write u for sin t
a quadratic in u
The same idea, other ways
Picture the graph of y = sin t over one turn: a wave that rises to 1 and falls to −1. Each answer the quadratic gives for sin t is a flat line across that picture, and each place where the wave crosses the line is an angle. A line at 1 touches the top of the wave once. A line at crosses it twice. A line at −2 passes below the whole wave and crosses nothing: that miss is the throw-out step.
A Ferris wheel has radius 1, and heights are measured from its center. A friend works out on paper that your seat must be at height 4 or at height −. You look up: the top seat is at height 1, so height 4 is empty sky far above the wheel. Cross it out. Height − is below the center, and a seat passes it twice on every turn, once on the way down and once on the way back up. Those two moments are the two angles.
Take t − cos t − 2 = 0. Write u for cos t: − u − 2 = 0. Two numbers that multiply to −2 and add to −1 are −2 and 1, so (u − 2)(u + 1) = 0, and u = 2 or u = −1. Put cosine back: cos t = 2 has no angle, since cosine never goes above 1; cos t = −1 is the leftmost point of the circle: t = π on one turn, and t = π + 2kπ for every integer k in general. Check: (−1 − (−1) − 2 = 1 + 1 − 2 = 0.
The equation looks at t only through the number sin t. Two angles with the same sine, like and , look identical to it. So the question splits in two: which numbers u make 2 − 7u − 4 = 0, a plain algebra question, and which angles have those numbers as their sine, a unit circle question. Splitting it this way loses nothing and adds nothing.
Algebra first, circle second, check last. The algebra does not know that sine and cosine stop at 1, so every number it hands you must pass the circle's test, from −1 to 1, before it turns into angles.
1. algebra: find the values of sin t
2. filter: keep −1 ≤ value ≤ 1
3. circle: turn each kept value into angles
4. check each angle in the original
| value from the factoring | sin t = value: angles in [0, 2π) | cos t = value: angles in [0, 2π) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | (one angle) | 0 (one angle) |
| 0 | 0, π | |
| (one angle) | π (one angle) | |
| below −1 or above 1, such as 4, −3 or − | none: throw it out | none: throw it out |
5 How
- Get 0 on one side: add or subtract on both sides until every term sits on the left and the right side is 0.
- Make sure only one trig function appears (all sin t, or all cos t, or all tan t), with its square in one term.
- Write u for that function, so t becomes and sin t becomes u.
- Factor the quadratic in u: pull out a common factor when there is no plain number term; otherwise split the middle term and group. Multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored, such as (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0, skips this step.
- Set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u (the zero-product rule). Plug each u back into the factored form to see the product is 0.
- Put the function back: each value of u becomes a basic equation such as sin t = −.
- Throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1: no angle has it. Keep every value of tangent.
- Solve each remaining basic equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants. For sine or cosine, the values 1 and −1 give one angle each; the other values give two.
- List all the angles in order and put each one back into the original equation.
Solving a trig equation that factors like a quadratic
- Zero: move every term to one side so the other side is 0.
- Rename: write u for the one trig function in the equation.
- Factor the quadratic in u and multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored skips this step.
- Zero-product: set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u.
- Return: turn each u into a basic equation, such as sin t = −.
- Filter: throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1.
- Angles: solve each kept equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants.
- Check: put every angle back into the original equation.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Two values of sine, one thrown out
Solve 2 t − 7 sin t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side equal 4.
Show the steps and the answer
- Subtract 4 from both sides: 2 .The zero-product rule, used in a moment, needs a 0 on one side. Subtracting the same number from both sides keeps them equal.
- Write u for sin t: . t means (sin t, which is . Every t in the equation sits inside a sin t, so with this one letter the trigonometric equation becomes a plain quadratic.
- Find two numbers that multiply to and add to . They are and 1.(−8)·1 = −8 and −8 + 1 = −7. These two numbers show how to split the middle term so the four pieces group in pairs.
- Split and group: . So .Both pairs contain (u − 4), so it comes out as a common factor. Multiply back to check: 2 − 8u + u − 4 = 2 − 7u − 4, the quadratic you started with.
- Set each factor equal to 0: gives ; gives .This finds the values of u that make the product 0 (the zero-product rule). For 2u + 1 = 0, subtract 1, then divide by 2. Plug back in: u = − gives (0)(−) = 0, and u = 4 gives (9)(0) = 0.
- Put sine back: or .u was only a stand-in for sin t. These are values of sine, not angles yet.
- Throw out .sin t is the height of a point on the unit circle, whose radius is 1, so −1 ≤ sin t ≤ 1. Height 4 is far above the whole circle: no angle has sine 4.
- Solve . The reference angle is , since . Sine is negative in quadrants III and IV.This is a basic equation, solved by the reference angle and quadrant method: the reference angle gives the size, and the sign of sine picks the quadrants.
- Quadrant III: . Quadrant IV: .In quadrant III you go half a turn, then the reference angle more; in quadrant IV you stop the reference angle short of a full turn. In sixths: + = and − = .
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
Already factored
Solve (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the product on the left equal 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Set each factor equal to 0: or .This finds what sin t must be for the product to be 0. A product is 0 only when one of its factors is 0 (the zero-product rule), and the right side here is already 0.
- Solve each one for sin t: or .Add 1 to both sides of the first; subtract 2 from both sides of the second. Plug back in: with sin t = 1 the product is (0)(3) = 0, and with sin t = −2 it is (−3)(0) = 0.
- Throw out .sin t is the height of a point on the unit circle, so it is never below −1. No angle has sine −2.
- Solve : height 1 is the top of the unit circle, the point (0, 1), a quarter turn from the start, so .Only one point of the circle sits at height 1, so this value gives one angle on one turn, not two.
Rung 2 of 7
A plain trinomial, one value thrown out
Solve t + 2 cos t − 3 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Write u for cos t: . t means (cos t, which is . The right side is already 0, so nothing has to move.
- Find two numbers that multiply to and add to 2: they are 3 and . So .3·(−1) = −3 and 3 + (−1) = 2. When has no number in front, those two numbers go straight into the brackets. Multiply back to check: − u + 3u − 3 = + 2u − 3.
- Set each factor equal to 0: gives ; gives .This finds the values of u that make the product 0. Plug back in: (−3 + 3)(−3 − 1) = 0·(−4) = 0 and (1 + 3)(1 − 1) = 4·0 = 0.
- Put cosine back: or . Throw out .cos t is the x-coordinate of a point on the unit circle, and no point of that circle lies left of −1.
- Solve : x-coordinate 1 belongs to the rightmost point of the circle, (1, 0), so .Only one point is that far right. A full turn, 2π, lands on the same point, but [0, 2π) leaves 2π out, so 0 is the only answer on this turn.
Rung 3 of 7
No number term, so pull out a common factor
Solve 2 t + cos t = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Write u for cos t: .Renaming shows the quadratic. There is no plain number term, so both terms contain u.
- Pull out the common factor u: .Multiply back to check: u·2u + u·1 = 2 + u. Do not divide both sides by u instead: dividing by a number that might be 0 deletes the answers where it is 0.
- Set each factor equal to 0: or , so or .This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u + 1 = 0, subtract 1 and divide by 2. Plug back in: u = 0 gives 0·(2·0 + 1) = 0·1 = 0, and u = − gives 2u + 1 = −1 + 1 = 0, so the product is 0.
- Put cosine back: or . Both lie from to 1, so both stay.Neither value is below −1 or above 1.
- Solve : x-coordinate 0 means the top or the bottom of the circle, so and .The two points of the unit circle on the vertical axis are (0, 1) and (0, −1).
- Solve : the reference angle is , since . Cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so and .The reference angle gives the size; the sign of cosine picks the quadrants. In thirds: − = and + = .
- List the angles in order: .Both factors give angles, and the answer is all of them.
Rung 4 of 7
Move the terms first, with a 2 in front
Solve 2 t + 1 = 3 sin t for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes both sides equal.
Show the steps and the answer
- Subtract 3 sin t from both sides: 2 .The zero-product rule needs 0 on one side. Write the terms from the square down, the way a quadratic is written.
- Write u for sin t: .Renaming shows the quadratic.
- Find two numbers that multiply to and add to : they are and . Split the middle term: .(−2)·(−1) = 2 and −2 + (−1) = −3. Splitting makes two pairs that share a factor.
- Group: .Both pairs contain (u − 1). Multiply back to check: 2 − 2u − u + 1 = 2 − 3u + 1.
- Set each factor equal to 0: gives ; gives .This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u − 1 = 0, add 1 and divide by 2. Plug back in: u = gives (2· − 1)( − 1) = 0·(−) = 0, and u = 1 gives (2 − 1)(1 − 1) = 1·0 = 0.
- Put sine back: or . Both lie from to 1, so both stay.Nothing to throw out this time.
- Solve : the reference angle is ; sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so and .Two quadrants share a positive sine. In sixths: − = .
- Solve : only the top of the circle, .Height 1 is a single point of the circle.
- List in order: .The answer is every angle from both factors.
Rung 5 of 7
Tangent, where nothing is thrown out
Solve (tan t − )(tan t + 1) = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the product on the left equal 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Set each factor equal to 0: or , so or .This finds what tan t must be for the product to be 0 (the zero-product rule). Plug back in: ( − )( + 1) = 0 and (−1 − )(−1 + 1) = 0.
- Keep both values, even though is bigger than 1.The limit from −1 to 1 belongs to sine and cosine, the coordinates of a point on a circle of radius 1. Tangent is sin t ÷ cos t, and a quotient can be any number.
- Solve : the reference angle is , since . Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III, so and .Dividing by is the same as multiplying by 2. Tangent is positive where sine and cosine have the same sign.
- Solve : the reference angle is , since . Tangent is negative in quadrants II and IV, so and .Tangent is negative where sine and cosine have opposite signs. In fourths: − = and − = .
- List in order: .The answer is every angle from both factors.
Rung 6 of 7
A 4 in front, and a fraction out of range
Solve 4 t + 4 cos t − 3 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Write u for cos t: .Renaming shows the quadratic; the right side is already 0.
- Find two numbers that multiply to and add to 4: they are 6 and . Split the middle term: .The pairs that multiply to −12 are 1 and −12, 2 and −6, 3 and −4, 4 and −3, 6 and −2, 12 and −1. Only 6 and −2 add to 4.
- Group: .Both pairs contain (2u + 3). Multiply back to check: 4 + 6u − 2u − 3 = 4 + 4u − 3.
- Set each factor equal to 0: gives ; gives .This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u + 3 = 0, subtract 3, then divide by 2. Plug back in: when u = , 2u = 1 and the product is (1 − 1)(1 + 3) = 0; when u = −, 2u = −3 and it is (−3 − 1)(−3 + 3) = 0.
- Put cosine back: or . Throw out .− is −1.5, and −1.5 < −1. A fraction can still be out of range: no point of the unit circle is that far left.
- Solve : the reference angle is ; cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so and .Two quadrants share a positive cosine. In thirds: − = .
Rung 7 of 7
A doubled angle inside the quadratic
Solve 2 2t − 5 cos 2t + 2 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle t on one turn that makes the left side 0, where each cosine is taken of the doubled angle 2t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Write u for cos 2t: .The same cos 2t appears in both places, so one letter can stand for it. 2t means (cos 2t.
- Find two numbers that multiply to and add to : they are and . Split and group: .(−4)·(−1) = 4 and −4 + (−1) = −5. Multiply back to check: 2 − 4u − u + 2 = 2 − 5u + 2.
- Set each factor equal to 0: gives ; gives .This finds the values of u that make the product 0. Plug back in: u = gives (2· − 1)( − 2) = 0·(−) = 0, and u = 2 gives (4 − 1)(2 − 2) = 3·0 = 0.
- Put cosine back: or . Throw out .A cosine is never above 1, whatever angle sits inside it.
- Widen the interval: as t runs over , 2t runs over , two full turns.Doubling every t doubles both ends of the interval, as in the lesson on multiple angles.
- Solve for 2t on : the first turn gives and ; adding a full turn, , gives and .The reference angle is , cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, and cosine repeats every full turn.
- Divide each by 2: .Dividing a fraction by 2 doubles its bottom: ÷ 2 = . All four are less than 2π = , so all four lie on one turn.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Write u = sin t at the top of your work. The letter u is a nickname: when the algebra ends, put sin t back, because the answers must be angles.
- Check the factoring before you go on: multiply the brackets back out and compare with the quadratic term by term.
- Draw a box around each value of sine or cosine that lies from −1 to 1. Only boxed values go on to the unit circle. Turn a fraction into a decimal if that helps: − = −1.5 is out.
- Count before you finish: on one turn each kept value of sine or cosine gives two angles, except 1 and −1, which give one each. Every kept value of tangent gives two.
- Memory cue: find the sine, then the angle. The quadratic answers the first question; the unit circle answers the second.
- Do not divide both sides by sin t, cos t or tan t to make an equation smaller: the division drops every angle where that function is 0. Pull it out as a common factor instead, so those answers stay in.
- For the general solution of an equation in sin t, cos t or tan t, find each solution on one turn first, then add 2kπ to each one for sine and cosine (k any integer, such as −1, 0 or 2). For tangent, whose period is π, add kπ to each solution between 0 and π.
7 The trap
Stopping at the values of sin t. Factoring hands you numbers such as sin t = − and sin t = 4, not angles. Each number still needs two more steps: throw it out if it is below −1 or above 1, and otherwise turn it into every angle on one turn with that sine (one angle for 1 and −1, two for the others). Only those angles are the answers.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Factoring 2 t + cos t − 1 = 0 gives cos t = or cos t = −1. Are you done?
- No. Those are values of cos t, not angles. Both lie between −1 and 1, so each one still has to become angles on [0, 2π).
- cos t = : reference angle , and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t = and t = .
- cos t = −1: the lowest value cosine reaches, so only one angle has it, t = π.
Solving the quadratic in u gives u = 3 or u = −1. What do you keep if u stands for sin t? If u stands for tan t?
- For sin t: keep only sin t = −1, which gives t = . Throw out sin t = 3: sin t is the height of a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1, and no seat is ever more than 1 above the center.
- For tan t: keep both. tan t = , and when cos t is close to 0 that fraction can be as large as you like, positive or negative. Only sine and cosine are stuck between −1 and 1.
Why does sin t = − give two angles on [0, 2π), but sin t = 1 only one?
- sin t is the height of a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1. In one turn the seat passes every height between the bottom and the top twice, once on the left half and once on the right: height − comes at t = and t = .
- Height 1 is the very top seat, where the right and left halves meet, so it comes only once, at t = .
Solve 2 t = −sin t on [0, 2π).
- Get 0 on one side, which the zero-product rule needs: 2 t + sin t = 0. Writing u for sin t gives 2 + u = 0.
- There is no plain number term, so pull out the common factor: u(2u + 1) = 0. That gives sin t = 0 or sin t = −.
- sin t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π; sin t = − gives t = and t = .