Quarry School

Proving an identity by working on one side — quick review

In plain words

Someone hands you a handful of coins, three quarters and five nickels, and says it is one dollar.

Rule

To prove an identity in this course, work on one side. Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by + or −) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here.

Step

  1. Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.

  2. Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.

  3. Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.

  4. Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.

  5. Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.

  6. Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.

Strategy

  1. Choose the more complicated side and copy it alone; the other side is the target.

  2. Clear negative angles: cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t; sine and tangent are odd functions, so sin(−t) = −sin t and tan(−t) = −tan t.

  3. Rewrite tan t, cot t, sec t and csc t in sine and cosine.

  4. Combine fractions over a common denominator, or split one fraction into two when the target is a sum.

  5. Swap with a Pythagorean identity wherever a 1 stands beside a square.

  6. Factor (a common factor, or a difference of squares), then cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.

  7. If a bottom is 1 plus or minus sin t or cos t, or sec t or csc t plus or minus 1, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate.

  8. Compare with the target after every line, and stop when they match exactly.

Question

Prove that (csc t − sin t)·tan t = cos t is an identity. In plain words: start with one side and rewrite it, using only facts you already know, until it reads exactly as the other side.

Answer

(csc t − sin t)·tan t = (1sint − sin t)·sintcost = 1−sin2tsint·sintcost = cos2tsint·sintcost = cos t, so the identity holds.

Trap

The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning sec2t − tan2t = 1 into sec2t = 1 + tan2t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.

Term

identity

Definition

An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.

Term

reciprocal identity

Definition

An identity writing one function as 1 divided by another: csc t = 1sint, sec t = 1cost, cot t = 1tant. Each pair multiplies to 1.

Term

quotient identity

Definition

An identity writing tangent and cotangent as one function divided by another: tan t = sintcost and cot t = costsint. A quotient is the answer to a division.

Term

Pythagorean identity

Definition

One of three identities built from x2 + y2 = 1 on the unit circle: sin2t + cos2t = 1, and the two forms you get by dividing it by cos2t or by sin2t.

Term

even function

Definition

A function that gives the same output at t and at −t, so its graph is a mirror image across the vertical axis. Cosine is even: cos(−t) = cos t.

Term

odd function

Definition

A function whose output at −t is the negative of its output at t, so a half turn about the origin leaves its graph unchanged. Sine is odd: sin(−t) = −sin t.

Term

conjugate

Definition

The same two pieces with the sign between them switched: the conjugate of 1 + sin t is 1 − sin t. Multiplying the pair gives a difference of squares, 1 − sin2t.