Proving an identity by working on one side
Quick review (2 minutes)
Someone hands you a handful of coins, three quarters and five nickels, and says it is one dollar.
To prove an identity in this course, work on one side. Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by + or −) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here.
Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.
Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.
Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.
Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.
Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.
Choose the more complicated side and copy it alone; the other side is the target.
Clear negative angles: cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t; sine and tangent are odd functions, so sin(−t) = −sin t and tan(−t) = −tan t.
Rewrite tan t, cot t, sec t and csc t in sine and cosine.
Combine fractions over a common denominator, or split one fraction into two when the target is a sum.
Swap with a Pythagorean identity wherever a 1 stands beside a square.
Factor (a common factor, or a difference of squares), then cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.
If a bottom is 1 plus or minus sin t or cos t, or sec t or csc t plus or minus 1, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate.
Compare with the target after every line, and stop when they match exactly.
Prove that (csc t − sin t)·tan t = cos t is an identity. In plain words: start with one side and rewrite it, using only facts you already know, until it reads exactly as the other side.
(csc t − sin t)·tan t = ( − sin t)· = · = · = cos t, so the identity holds.
The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning t − t = 1 into t = 1 + t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.
identity
An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.
reciprocal identity
An identity writing one function as 1 divided by another: csc t = , sec t = , cot t = . Each pair multiplies to 1.
quotient identity
An identity writing tangent and cotangent as one function divided by another: tan t = and cot t = . A quotient is the answer to a division.
Pythagorean identity
One of three identities built from + = 1 on the unit circle: t + t = 1, and the two forms you get by dividing it by t or by t.
even function
A function that gives the same output at t and at −t, so its graph is a mirror image across the vertical axis. Cosine is even: cos(−t) = cos t.
odd function
A function whose output at −t is the negative of its output at t, so a half turn about the origin leaves its graph unchanged. Sine is odd: sin(−t) = −sin t.
conjugate
The same two pieces with the sign between them switched: the conjugate of 1 + sin t is 1 − sin t. Multiplying the pair gives a difference of squares, 1 − t.
1 In plain words
Someone hands you a handful of coins, three quarters and five nickels, and says it is one dollar. To prove it, you do not argue. You trade: five nickels for one quarter, then four quarters for a dollar bill. Each trade keeps the value the same, so when you hold one dollar bill, you have shown the handful was a dollar all along. Proving an identity works the same way. The messy side is the handful of coins. Each trade is a fact you already know, such as tan t = . You keep trading on that one side until it reads exactly like the other side. You never reach across and change the other side to make them match.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Reciprocal and quotient identities, Pythagorean identities, Even and odd, What t means, Adding fractions, Multiplying fractions, Dividing by a fraction, Squaring a fraction, Canceling, Difference of squares and common factor, A negative squared, Exact values at 30° and 60°, One test angle
- Reciprocal and quotient identities. csc t = , sec t = , cot t = , tan t = . Example: csc 30° = 1 ÷ = 2.
- Pythagorean identities. t + t = 1, 1 + t = t and 1 + t = t. Example: at 30°, + = 1.
- Even and odd. Cosine is an even function and sine is an odd function: cos(−t) = cos t, sin(−t) = −sin t, tan(−t) = −tan t. Example: sin(−30°) = −.
- What t means. t means (sin t: find the sine, then square it. Example: 30° = ( = .
- Adding fractions. Give both fractions the same bottom, then add the tops: + = + = .
- Multiplying fractions. Top times top, bottom times bottom: · = = .
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 5 ÷ = 5 · 3 = 15, and in the same way sin t ÷ = t.
- Squaring a fraction. Square the top and the bottom: ( = . So t = and t = .
- Canceling. Cancel only a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom: = , but = , not 7.
- Difference of squares and common factor. − = (a − b)(a + b), as in 25 − 9 = 2 · 8 = 16; and a·b + a·c = a(b + c), as in 3·5 + 3·2 = 3 · 7 = 21.
- A negative squared. (−a = , because a negative times a negative is positive: (−3 = 9.
- Exact values at 30° and 60°. sin 30° = , cos 30° = , tan 30° = ; sin 60° = , cos 60° = , tan 60° = . Flip them for csc, sec and cot: csc 30° = 2, sec 60° = 2.
- One test angle. Both sides agreeing at one angle does not prove an identity; disagreeing at one angle proves it false.
3 Why
An identity claims two expressions are equal at every angle where both are defined. A chain of steps, each one a fact you already know, carries the value along unchanged: if A = B and B = C, then A = C. That chain is the proof. Moving a term across the equals sign of the claim is different: it starts from the claim itself and shows only where the claim leads. That is a proof only when every step can be run backwards, and one step that cannot, such as squaring both sides, lets a false claim reach a true line. Start on the more complicated side because its pieces tell you what to do next; a one-term side gives no hint of what to build.
4 The rule
To prove an identity in this course, work on one side.
Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by or ) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here.
The same idea, five ways
Prove it on one side: start with the messier side and turn it into the other side, one known step at a time.
One way to prove an identity, and the way used in this course: rewrite one side, usually the more complicated one, with facts already known, until it reads exactly as the other side; nothing is moved across the equals sign of the claim.
- left side = form 1 = form 2 = … = right side
- If A = B, B = C and C = D, then A = D.
- tan t · csc t = · = = sec t
Trading a handful of coins, fair trade by fair trade, until it becomes the one dollar bill that was claimed.
The same idea, other ways
Picture a chain of links. The first link is the side you start with, the last link is the other side, and each link in between is one line of your work, joined to the one before by an equals sign you can defend with a known identity or a fraction rule. If every link holds, the first equals the last.
left side (copy it alone)
= next form (name the identity)
= next form (name the fraction rule)
= …
= right side (stop here)
You are asked to make a messy room match a photo in a catalog. You work inside the room only: fold, stack, put away. You never edit the photo to look like the room. When the room looks exactly like the photo, you are done. The messy side of an identity is the room, the other side is the photo, and each known identity is one tidying move.
Equals passes along a chain: if A = B and B = C, then A = C. Each line of a proof equals the line before it because of a fact already known, so the first line equals the last. Moving a term across the equals sign of the claim starts from the claim itself, which is not known yet. Such an argument shows only where the claim leads, and it proves the claim only if every step can be run backwards.
Prove that + = the same way. Work on the left side only: + = + = = . Each step is a fraction fact, and the last line is the right side, so the claim is proved. A trig proof has the same shape; only the facts change.
Rewrite, combine, swap, factor, cancel. Say the five verbs in that order as you work: rewrite in sine and cosine, combine fractions, swap with a Pythagorean identity, factor, cancel. If none of them helps and a bottom reads 1 + sin t, 1 − cos t or a pair like them, multiply the top and the bottom by the conjugate, which keeps the value wherever the conjugate is not 0.
| What you see | What to try | The fact that makes it legal |
|---|---|---|
| tan t, cot t, sec t or csc t | Rewrite in sine and cosine | tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t = |
| Two fractions added or subtracted | Combine over a common denominator | |
| A 1 beside a square, such as 1 − t or t − 1 | Swap the pair for one square | Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t, t − 1 = t |
| A factor in every term | Pull it out, then look inside | a·b + a·c = a(b + c) |
| A square minus a square | Factor into two parentheses | |
| A bottom such as 1 + cos t or sec t − 1 | Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate | Multiplying by is multiplying by 1 wherever 1 − cos t is not 0 |
| A negative angle, such as sin(−t) | Use the even and odd facts |
Part 1: Strategy 1: rewrite everything in sine and cosine
A recipe that mixes cups, tablespoons and grams is hard to check until you convert everything to one unit. A side that mixes tangent, secant and cosecant is like that. Sine and cosine are the common unit: each of the other four functions is a fraction built from them. Once every piece is written in sine and cosine, you can see which factors match, which cancel and which fractions combine.
- Swaps: tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t = .
- When: the side mixes two or more of the six functions, or you do not know what else to do.
- Then: multiply or combine the fractions, and cancel factors that sit on the whole top and the whole bottom.
- Gotcha: the swap makes the line longer before it gets shorter. That is normal.
cot t =
sec t =
csc t =
Worked example
Proving tan t · csc t = sec t
Prove that tan t · csc t = sec t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two functions; the right side has one.
- Quotient identity tan t = and reciprocal identity csc t = .
- Multiply fractions: top times top (sin t · 1 = sin t), bottom times bottom (cos t · sin t).
- sin t is a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom, so it cancels and leaves 1 on top.
- Reciprocal identity read backward: = sec t. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: each reciprocal pair has exactly one co. Cosine goes with secant, sine goes with cosecant, tangent goes with cotangent.
- When you are stuck anywhere in a proof, this strategy is the safe first move.
Part 2: Strategy 2: Pythagorean substitution
A Pythagorean identity works like a currency exchange booth with a rate that never changes. 1 − t is always worth exactly t, so at any step you may hand over one and take the other. The signal is a 1 standing beside a square, or t standing beside t. Trade the pair for a single square, or trade a single square for the pair when the target needs it.
- Base: t + t = 1, so 1 − t = t and 1 − t = t.
- Tangent form: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t.
- Cotangent form: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t.
- Signal: a 1 beside a squared function, or t beside t.
- Allowed: these rearrangements are fine, because the Pythagorean identities are already proved, so every form of them is a known fact.
Worked example
Proving (t − 1)·t = t
Prove that (t − 1)·t = t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has a 1 beside a square and a product; the right side is one square.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 + t = t rearranged gives t − 1 = t.
- Quotient identity squared: t = ( = · = .
- t sits on the whole bottom and multiplies the whole top, so it cancels. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Look for the 1. Wherever a 1 stands beside a squared function, a Pythagorean swap is nearby.
- If the target has only sine, trade t for 1 − t; if it has only cosine, trade t for 1 − t.
Part 3: Strategy 3: factoring
Factoring is packing. If every item on a table carries the same sticker, you can put the sticker on the box once and list what is inside. In sin t·t + t, both terms carry a factor sin t, so you write sin t once in front of parentheses. Inside the parentheses a Pythagorean pattern often appears, and the whole group turns into 1. A square minus a square packs the same way, into two parentheses.
- Common factor: a·b + a·c = a(b + c). Example: sin t·t + sin t·t = sin t(t + t).
- Difference of squares: − = (a − b)(a + b). Example: 1 − t = (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t).
- Hidden factors: t = sin t · t, and t = (t.
- Then: look inside the parentheses for a Pythagorean pattern, and cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.
Worked example
Proving sin t·t + t = sin t
Prove that sin t·t + t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two terms and higher powers; the right side is one function.
- t means sin t · sin t · sin t, which is sin t · t. Writing it this way shows the common factor.
- Both terms carry the factor sin t, so pull it out: a·b + a·c = a(b + c).
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
- Multiplying by 1 changes nothing. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Check a factoring by multiplying it back out; you must get the line you started with.
- A fourth power is the square of a square, so t − t is a difference of squares in disguise.
Part 4: Strategy 4: multiplying by a conjugate
Two expressions with the same two terms and the opposite sign between them, such as 1 + cos t and 1 − cos t, are called a conjugate pair. Think of a key and its lock. Apart, each one is awkward. Multiplied together, the middle pieces cancel and leave a square minus a square, 1 − t, which the Pythagorean identity turns into one tidy term, t. So when a bottom reads 1 + cos t, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate, 1 − cos t. Doing the same to the top and the bottom multiplies by 1, so the value does not change.
- Say it: the conjugate of 1 plus cos t is 1 minus cos t.
- Write it: the conjugate of a two-term expression is the same two terms with the sign between them flipped.
- Math: a + b and a − b are conjugates, and (a + b)(a − b) = − .
- Like: a key and its lock; apart each is awkward, together they open into one tidy term.
- Useful pairs: (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) = t, (1 + sin t)(1 − sin t) = t, (sec t + 1)(sec t − 1) = t, (csc t + 1)(csc t − 1) = t.
- Why it is allowed: multiplying the top and the bottom by the conjugate is multiplying by 1, at every angle where the conjugate is not 0.
Reminder
Reminder: Difference of squares
- Difference of squares.
Worked example
Clearing the bottom 1 + cos t
Prove that = (1 − cos t)·t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads (1 − cos t)·t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Its bottom, 1 + cos t, is a two-term sum: the signal for a conjugate. Starting from the right side also works; the check does that.
- 1 − cos t is the conjugate of 1 + cos t. is 1 wherever 1 − cos t is not 0, so the value does not change.
- Multiply fractions: top times top, bottom times bottom.
- Difference of squares: (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) = − t = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- A fraction is its top times 1 over its bottom, and = ( = t by the reciprocal identity. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Put the conjugate on the bottom that has two terms; that is the bottom you want to turn into one term.
- To write a conjugate, copy both terms and flip only the sign between them: the conjugate of sec t − 1 is sec t + 1.
- At t = 0°, 1 − cos t = 0, so multiplying by does not work there. The right side contains csc 0°, which is undefined, so the identity makes no claim at 0° anyway.
5 How
- Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
- Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.
- Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.
- Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.
- Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.
- Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.
Proving an identity on one side
- Choose the more complicated side and copy it alone; the other side is the target.
- Clear negative angles: cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t; sine and tangent are odd functions, so sin(−t) = −sin t and tan(−t) = −tan t.
- Rewrite tan t, cot t, sec t and csc t in sine and cosine.
- Combine fractions over a common denominator, or split one fraction into two when the target is a sum.
- Swap with a Pythagorean identity wherever a 1 stands beside a square.
- Factor (a common factor, or a difference of squares), then cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.
- If a bottom is 1 plus or minus sin t or cos t, or sec t or csc t plus or minus 1, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate.
- Compare with the target after every line, and stop when they match exactly.
6 Worked example
Worked example
From (csc t − sin t)·tan t to cos t
Prove that (csc t − sin t)·tan t = cos t is an identity. In plain words: start with one side and rewrite it, using only facts you already know, until it reads exactly as the other side.
Show the steps and the answer
(csc t − sin t)·tan t
= ( − sin t)· sine and cosine
= · common bottom
= · Pythagorean
= cos t cancel sin t and one cos t
- Choose the left side, , and leave cos t alone as the target.The left side has three functions, a subtraction and a product; the right side is one function. The more complicated side gives you moves to make.
- Sine and cosine: the reciprocal identity csc t = and the quotient identity tan t = .
- To subtract, sin t needs the bottom sin t: multiply it by , which is 1, to get .
- The two fractions now share the bottom sin t, so subtract the tops.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1 rearranged gives 1 − t = t.
- Multiply fractions: top times top, bottom times bottom.
- t is cos t · cos t. The factors sin t and cos t each sit on the whole top and the whole bottom, so they cancel, and one cos t is left.
- The last line, cos t, is exactly the right side, so the proof is done.Every line equals the line before it by a fact you can name, so the first line equals the last.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
One swap, one cancel
Prove that cos t · tan t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two functions; the right side has one.
- Quotient identity: tan t = .
- Multiplying a fraction by cos t multiplies its top by cos t.
- cos t is a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom, so it cancels. This is the right side.
Rung 2 of 7
One Pythagorean swap
Prove that (1 − t)·csc t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has a 1 beside a square and a second function; the right side is one function.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- Reciprocal identity csc t = , then multiply the top by t.
- t is sin t · sin t; one sin t cancels with the bottom. This is the right side.
Rung 3 of 7
Dividing by a reciprocal
Prove that + = 1. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 1.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two fractions and four functions; the right side is the number 1.
- A fraction bar means divide, and the reciprocal identities give csc t = and sec t = .
- Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip: the flip of is sin t, and the flip of is cos t.
- sin t · sin t is written t, and cos t · cos t is written t.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1. This is the right side.
Rung 4 of 7
Two fractions over a common denominator
Prove that + = 2t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 2t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two fractions to combine; the right side is one term.
- Common denominator: multiply the top and the bottom of each fraction by the other fraction's bottom, which is multiplying by 1.
- Same bottom, so add the tops.
- Top: sin t − sin t = 0 and 1 + 1 = 2 (gotcha: the sines cancel, so the top is not 2 + 2sin t). Bottom: difference of squares, (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t) = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- sec t = , so t = ( = . This is the right side.
Rung 5 of 7
Negative angles first
Prove that (1 + (−t))·cos(−t) = sec t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has negative angles, a square and a product; the right side is one function.
- Tangent is an odd function, so tan(−t) = −tan t; cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t.
- A negative squared is positive: (−tan t = t. Gotcha: it is not −t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 + t = t.
- Reciprocal identity squared: t = . Then one factor cos t cancels from the top and the bottom.
- Reciprocal identity read backward: = sec t. This is the right side.
Rung 6 of 7
A difference of squares in disguise
Prove that t − t = 1 − 2t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 1 − 2t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Fourth powers are more complicated than the right side's single square.
- A fourth power is the square of a square: t = t · t = (t, and the same for sine.
- Difference of squares − = (a − b)(a + b), with a = t and b = t.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
- The target has only sine, so trade t for 1 − t (Pythagorean identity).
- One t taken away, then another: − t − t = −2t. This is the right side.
Rung 7 of 7
Rung 7 (genuinely hard): a conjugate, then a square
Prove that = (sec t + tan t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads (sec t + tan t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Its bottom, 1 − sin t, is one of the conjugate pairs. The right side would also work as a start; the check does it.
- Multiply the top and the bottom by the conjugate 1 + sin t; that is multiplying by 1 wherever 1 + sin t is not 0.
- Top: (1 + sin t)(1 + sin t) = (1 + sin t. Bottom: difference of squares, (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t) = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- A square over a square is the square of the fraction: ( = · = , read from right to left.
- Split the fraction: a sum on top over one bottom is two fractions with that bottom (adding fractions, read backward).
- Reciprocal identity = sec t and quotient identity = tan t. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: mess to match. Start with the mess, change only the mess, and stop when it matches the other side.
- Pick the side with more: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
- Write each step on its own line beginning with =, and name the identity beside it. If you cannot name the reason for a step, the step is suspect.
- Keep the target in view. If it has only sine, trade t for 1 − t; if it has sec t, aim for .
- You are done only when the line reads exactly as the other side: is not yet sec t until you write that last step.
- Check at 30° or 60°, not at 45°: at 45° sine and cosine are equal, so a mix-up between them goes unnoticed. Avoid 0° and 90° too, where some functions are 0 or undefined.
- Stuck? Rewrite everything in sine and cosine. Still stuck? Start over from the other side; a proof may start from either side, as long as you change only that side.
7 The trap
The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning t − t = 1 into t = 1 + t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
To prove tan t · cos t = sin t, which side do you start on, and why?
- The left side, tan t · cos t: it has two functions, and the right side has one.
- Its pieces point to the next step: write tan t as , then cancel cos t to reach sin t, the target.
The proofs in this lesson never move a term across the equals sign of the claim. Why?
- Moving it starts from the claim, which is not known yet. That shows only where the claim leads, and it counts as a proof only if every step can be run backwards, which then has to be checked.
- Copying one side alone and rewriting it until it reads exactly as the other side needs no such check.
When do you stop rewriting, and why does that finish the proof?
- Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side.
- Every step used a fact you already know, so the value never changed, like trading five nickels for a quarter. If A = B and B = C, then A = C, so the side you began with equals the other side.
You plug a test angle into both sides of a claim and get the same number. Does that prove the identity?
- No. One angle is not every angle: sin t = cos t holds at 45° but fails at 0°, where sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.
- The test angle catches slips; a proof needs an argument that covers every angle, such as a chain of known steps on one side.