Quarry School

The usual mistakes in a proof

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: The Pythagorean identityLeans on: What sin²t meansLeans on: Difference of squaresLeans on: Squaring a negativeLeans on: A square root is never negativeLeans on: Dividing by a fractionLeans on: Multiplying fractionsLeans on: Canceling a common factorLeans on: Points on the unit circleLeans on: One test angle
Level 1 · FoundationsAbout 36 min read2 new terms
How this was estimated

Programmatic estimate. Rung levels, worked steps, prerequisites, terms and sentence length contribute to this level. It describes the lesson, not your ability.

Reading counts the whole lesson, including folded explanations, at 180 words a minute. Practice allows two minutes per item. These are planning assumptions; take the time you need.

AI estimate unavailable.

Path to here

Open the unit’s lesson list to follow the lesson order.

    Quick review (2 minutes)

    In plain words

    Picture a friend who tells you every outfit looks great, even the shirt with a ketchup stain.

    Rule

    A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim. The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
    An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.

    Step

    1. Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.

    2. Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.

    3. Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.

    4. Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.

    5. Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.

    6. Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.

    Strategy

    1. Read the first line. A proof by this course's method starts with one side of the claim alone. An argument that starts from the whole claim is a proof only if every step can be walked back.

    2. Go line by line. Each line should come from the one above by rewriting one side with a named identity or an algebra move.

    3. Mark every step that squares, multiplies or divides both sides.

    4. For a squaring step, test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.

    5. For a dividing step, find every angle where the divisor is 0 and plug each one back in to confirm it; also check whether the Pythagorean identity makes the divisor 0 at every angle.

    6. If a test angle gives two different values, the claim is false and no proof can exist. If the claim survives, write a fresh proof from one side.

    Question

    Someone wants to show that sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1 is an identity and writes:
    Line 1: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1
    Line 2: sin2t1−cost = 1 + cos t (add cos t to both sides)
    Line 3: sin2t = (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) (multiply both sides by 1 − cos t)
    Line 4: sin2t = 1 − cos2t (multiply out)
    Line 5: sin2t + cos2t = 1 (add cos2t to both sides), which is true.
    They stop there. Say what the five lines show when read from top to bottom, what has to be checked before they count as a proof, and then write a proof that starts from one side.

    Answer

    Read from top to bottom, the five lines show only that if the claim is true, then sin2t + cos2t = 1.
    To count as a proof they need a check that every step can be walked back. Here each one can, at every angle where the claim's sides are defined, because 1 − cos t is not 0 at those angles. With that check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof.
    A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1−cos2t1−cost − cos t = (1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost − cos t = 1 + cos t − cos t = 1.

    Trap

    The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.

    Term

    identity

    Definition

    An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.

    Term

    reciprocal identity

    Definition

    An identity writing one function as 1 divided by another: csc t = 1sint, sec t = 1cost, cot t = 1tant. Each pair multiplies to 1.

    Term

    quotient identity

    Definition

    An identity writing tangent and cotangent as one function divided by another: tan t = sintcost and cot t = costsint. A quotient is the answer to a division.

    Term

    Pythagorean identity

    Definition

    One of three identities built from x2 + y2 = 1 on the unit circle: sin2t + cos2t = 1, and the two forms you get by dividing it by cos2t or by sin2t.

    Term

    conjugate

    Definition

    The same two pieces with the sign between them switched: the conjugate of 1 + sin t is 1 − sin t. Multiplying the pair gives a difference of squares, 1 − sin2t.

    1 In plain words

    Picture a friend who tells you every outfit looks great, even the shirt with a ketchup stain. Their praise tells you nothing, because they would say it no matter what. Some moves in a proof behave like that friend: they can take a false line and hand back a true one. Call such a move a one-way step, because you can walk forward through it but cannot count on walking back. After a one-way step, a true line proves nothing about the line before it. This lesson shows the three usual mistakes: starting from the claim and working both sides as if you were solving an equation, squaring both sides, and dividing by something that can be zero. For each one you will see it fool you, then the safe move to make instead.

    2 Picture it

    Mistake 1, working both sides from the claim: a proof only if every step walks back.

    Mistake 2, squaring both sides: 3 ≠ −3, yet 32 = (−3)2.

    Mistake 3, dividing by what can be 0: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0, yet 3 ≠ 5.

    Safe: start from one side, rewrite it, end at the other.

    Memory device: one side, no squares, no zeros.

    Reminder

    Reminder: The Pythagorean identity, What sin2t means, Difference of squares, Squaring a negative, A square root is never negative, Dividing by a fraction, Multiplying fractions, Canceling a common factor, Points on the unit circle, One test angle
    • The Pythagorean identity. sin2t + cos2t = 1 at every angle, so sin2t = 1 − cos2t; at t = 30°, 14 + 34 = 1.
    • What sin2t means. sin2t means (sin t)2: sin230° = (12)2 = 14.
    • Difference of squares. a2 − b2 = (a − b)(a + b), so 1 − cos2t = (1 − cos t)(1 + cos t); with numbers, 1 − 32 = (1 − 3)(1 + 3) = −8.
    • Squaring a negative. A negative times a negative is positive: (−3)2 = (−3) · (−3) = 9, the same as 32 = 9.
    • A square root is never negative. a means the number, 0 or more, whose square is a: 9 = 3, not −3, even though (−3)2 = 9.
    • Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 34 ÷ 12 = 34 × 21 = 64 = 32.
    • Multiplying fractions. Tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms: 22 · 22 = 24 = 12, since 2 · 2 = 2.
    • Canceling a common factor. A factor in both the top and the bottom of one fraction cancels: 3·53 = 5, allowed because the bottom 3 is not 0.
    • Points on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): at 180° it is (−1, 0), so cos 180° = −1 and sin 180° = 0; at 90° it is (0, 1).
    • One test angle. One angle where the two sides differ shows a claim is not an identity: sin t = cos t holds at 45° but fails at 0°, where sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.

    3 Why

    A proof has to lead from facts you already trust to the claim. An argument that starts from the claim and works both sides runs the other way: it shows that the claim leads to something true. False claims do that too: from the false 3 = −3, squaring gives the true 9 = 9. So such an argument proves the claim only once every step has been shown to walk back, from the true line to the claim, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring cannot be walked back when the two sides may differ in sign, because a number and its negative have the same square. Dividing by zero has no answer, so it cannot undo a multiplication by zero: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0, yet 3 ≠ 5. Rewriting one side never starts from the claim, so it has nothing to walk back.

    4 The rule

    A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim.

    The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
    An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    A one-way step: a move you cannot count on walking back.

    Write it

    A one-way step is a move that can turn a false line into a true one, so a true line after it tells you nothing about the line before it.

    In math
    • 3 ≠ −3, yet 32 = (−3)2 = 9
    • 3 ≠ 5, yet 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 = 0
    • A = B gives A2 = B2, but A2 = B2 gives only A = B or A = −B
    Like

    Rounding prices to the nearest dollar: a 2.80 price and a 3.20 price both become 3 dollars, so a receipt that says 3 dollars cannot tell you which price it was.

    See it
    3−32−294function
    Each number and its negative land on the same square.

    The same idea, other ways

    As a story

    If it rained last night, the street is wet. You step outside and the street is wet. Did it rain? Maybe, or maybe a sprinkler ran. A wet street fits rain without proving it. Working both sides argues the same way: if the claim is true, then 1 = 1; 1 = 1 is true; so the claim is true? A true ending fits the claim without proving it.

    With small numbers

    Start from a claim you know is false, 3 = −3. Square both sides: 9 = 9, which is true. Start from another false claim, 3 = 5. Multiply both sides by 0: 0 = 0, true again. Both times a false start reached a true finish, so a true finish, by itself, says nothing about the start.

    As a picture

    On the graph of y = x2, the height above 3 and the height above −3 are both 9. Two starts, one finish. Standing at height 9, you cannot tell which start you came from. A one-way step does that to a proof: the finish stops telling you where you began.

    no square ever lands below 0(−3, 9)(3, 9)(0, 0)−33−49
    The curve is at the same height above a number and above its negative.
    Rule of thumb

    Ask of every step: could I walk it back and land exactly where I was? Squaring: not unless you know the two sides have the same sign, since 9 could have come from 3 or from −3. Dividing by something that is 0: no, the step has no answer to walk back from. Rewriting one side with an identity: nothing needs walking back, because every line equals the one before it.

    Why one side is safe

    Each line of a proof from one side swaps an expression for another that equals it at every angle where both are defined, by an identity already shown. A chain of equal things, left side = A = B = right side, makes the left side equal the right side wherever every line is defined. The chain never starts from the claim, so no step has to be walked back.

    The moveWhy it tempts youWhy it failsDo this instead
    Starting from the claim and working both sidesIt is how you solve an equation.It shows only where the claim leads, and a false claim can also reach a true line such as 1 = 1. It is a proof only if every step can be walked back.Start from one side and turn it into the other.
    Squaring both sidesIt removes a square root and keeps equal sides equal.3 and −3 have the same square, 9, so a true squared line cannot tell the signs apart.Do not take a true squared line as proof of the claim. To judge the claim, test an angle where one side could be negative.
    Dividing both sides by an expression that can be 0It clears away a factor that both sides share.Dividing by 0 has no answer: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 = 5 is false.Rewrite one side; cancel a factor from the top and bottom of one fraction, which keeps the value wherever that fraction is defined, since its bottom is not 0 there.

    Part 1: Mistake 1: working both sides

    Working both sides means writing the whole claim, left side = right side, as your first line, then doing the same thing to both sides until something true appears. Equations taught you that habit, so it feels right. Picture a detective who decides the butler did it, then shows that a guilty butler would fit the clues. The gardener might fit them too. The detective has shown the story is possible, not that it is true. A proof has to start from what you already trust. The method of this course starts from one side of the claim, which you then turn into the other side. An argument on both sides counts as a proof only after every step has been checked to run backwards, from the true line to the claim.

    • What it looks like: the first line is the whole claim, and later lines change both sides at once.
    • Why it proves nothing by itself: reaching a true line shows only that the claim leads there, and false claims can lead to true lines too. The true line proves the claim only if the steps can be reversed.
    • What would repair it: a check that every step can be walked back, so that the true line leads to the claim. An angle where a step cannot be walked back is then checked on its own.
    • Safe move: start from one side alone and write one chain, left side = ... = right side.
    • Allowed on scratch paper: trying both sides to find an idea. In this course the proof you then write down starts from one side.
    =[[1 + tant|sec t]]cos t + sin tdo the same thing to both sides
    A balance scale pictures an equation you are told is true.

    Worked example

    From working both sides to a proof

    Someone wants to show that 1+tantsect = cos t + sin t is an identity. They multiply both sides by sec t to get 1 + tan t = (cos t + sin t) · sec t, rewrite the right side as cost+sintcost = 1 + tan t, and stop because the two sides match. Say what this argument shows as written and what it leaves out, then write a proof that starts from one side.

    Show the steps and the answer

    1+tantsect

    = (1 + tan t) · cos t

    = cos t + tan t · cos t

    = cos t + sin t

    1. Say what the question asks: what the argument shows as written, what it leaves out, and a chain that starts at one side and ends at the other.A proof is judged by its steps, not only by whether the last line looks right.
    2. Look at the first move: it multiplies both sides of the claim by sec t, and the work ends at 1+tant=1+tant.That starts from the claim, so the matching lines show only that the claim leads to a true line. The move can be undone by dividing by sec t, which is never 0, but the argument does not say so, and saying so is what would make it a proof.
    3. Start the proof from the left side alone: 1+tantsect.It is the more complicated side; a fraction with sec t in the bottom has room to be rewritten.
    4. Use the reciprocal identity sect=1cost: the left side is (1+tant)÷1cost.A fraction bar means divide, and swapping sec t for 1cost does not change the value.
    5. Divide by 1cost by multiplying by its flip: =(1+tant)·cost.Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by that fraction turned upside down, and 1cost turned over is cos t.
    6. Distribute cos t: =cost+tant·cost.Multiplying a sum by cos t multiplies each of its two terms by cos t.
    7. Use the quotient identity tant=sintcost: tant·cost=sintcost·cost=sint, so the line is cost+sint.The cos t on top cancels the cos t in the bottom of that one fraction; wherever tan t makes sense, cos t is not 0.
    8. The chain now ends at cost+sint, the right side.Every line equals the one before it, so the first line equals the last.
    Answer
    • As written it shows only that the claim leads to the true line 1 + tan t = 1 + tan t. It leaves out the walk back: multiplying both sides by sec t can be undone by dividing by sec t, which is never 0, and the argument has to say so to be a proof.
    • A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: 1+tantsect = (1 + tan t) · cos t = cos t + tan t · cos t = cos t + sin t.
    Double-check At t = 60°: tan 60° = 3 and sec 60° = 2, so the left side is 1+32, and the right side is cos 60° + sin 60° = 12 + 32 = 1+32. At t = 0°: the left side is 1+01 = 1 and the right side is 1 + 0 = 1. Both angles match.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: My work on both sides ended at a true line, and each step looks as if it could be undone, so I do not need to check.
    Looking is not checking. A step can be undone only where it loses nothing: a squaring can hide a minus sign, and a multiplication or a division by an expression fails wherever that expression is 0. Until every step has been checked at every angle of the claim, the work shows only where the claim leads.
    ✓ Instead: Check every step and say so, or write one chain that starts from one side, reusing the identities your scratch work found.

    Tips and tricks

    • If your first line already has an equals sign with the other side on it, stop: you are working both sides, and every step would need a walk-back check.
    • Scratch work on both sides can show you which identities to use; reuse them in a chain from one side.

    Part 2: Mistake 2: squaring both sides

    Squaring is like printing a color photo in black and white. A red shirt and a green shirt can come out the same gray, and from the gray print you cannot tell which color it was. Squaring does that to signs: 3 and −3 both become 9. So when a squared line is true, the line before it may still be wrong by a minus sign. Square roots are where this tempts you, because squaring both sides makes the root disappear. A true squared line proves the unsquared claim only where both sides are known to have the same sign, so do not lean on it: test an angle where one side could be negative.

    • What it looks like: a step that turns A = B into A2 = B2.
    • Why it fails: A2 = B2 is true when A = B and also when A = −B, so the squared line cannot tell which.
    • With numbers: 3 ≠ −3, yet 32 = 9 and (−3)2 = 9.
    • Where it hides: claims with a square root, such as cos t = 1−sin2t, which fails at 180°.
    • Safe move: do not take a true squared line as proof of the claim; test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.
    • When it can be walked back: only where both sides are known to have the same sign, for example both 0 or more.
    −111function
    At 180° the left side of cos t = 1−sin2t is −1 and the right side is 1, two different numbers with the…

    Worked example

    A square root claim that squaring seems to prove

    Someone says cos t = 1−sin2t is an identity, because squaring both sides gives cos2t = 1 − sin2t, which is the Pythagorean identity. Is the claim an identity?

    Show the steps and the answer
    x = cos θy = sin θ(−1, 0)
    At 180° the point is (−1, 0), so cos 180° = −1 is negative, and a square root never is.
    1. Say what the question asks: is cos t equal to 1−sin2t at every angle where both sides make sense?That is what being an identity means. Here both sides make sense at every angle: sin2t is never more than 1, so 1 − sin2t is never below 0 and its square root exists.
    2. Flag the step that squares both sides.Squaring gives a number and its negative the same result, so a true squared line cannot show the unsquared claim is true.
    3. Look for an angle where the two sides could disagree in sign. The right side is a square root, so it is never negative; pick an angle where cos t is negative, such as 180°.A negative number can never equal a number that is 0 or more.
    4. Left side at 180°: cos180°=−1.The point on the unit circle at 180° is (−1, 0), and cos t is its x coordinate.
    5. Right side at 180°: 1−sin2180°=1−02=1=1.sin 180° = 0 is the y coordinate of (−1, 0), and 1 = 1 because the square root is the answer that is not negative.
    6. Compare: −1≠1, so the claim fails at 180°.One angle where both sides make sense and differ is enough to show a claim is not an identity.
    7. Name what the true squared line does say: cos t is either 1−sin2t or −1−sin2t, and at 180° it is the second.A2 = B2 holds when A = B and also when A = −B; squaring threw away which one.
    Answer
    • No, it is not an identity: at t = 180°, cos t = −1 but 1−sin2t = 1.
    • The squaring step hid the minus sign.
    Double-check Try another angle where cos t is negative, t = 120°: cos 120° = −12, and sin 120° = 32 gives 1−34 = 14 = 12, since 12 · 12 = 14. Again −12 ≠ 12. At 60°, by contrast, both sides are 12, so testing only angles in the first quadrant would have missed the mistake.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: cos2t = cos t at every angle.
    A square root is never negative, but cos t can be: at 180°, (−1)2 = 1 = 1, not −1.
    ✓ Instead: cos2t equals cos t only at angles where cos t ≥ 0; at angles where cos t < 0 it equals −cos t.

    Tips and tricks

    • When a claim has a square root on one side, find an angle where the other side is negative and test there first.
    • A true squared line tells you the two sides are equal or opposite, never which one.

    Part 3: Mistake 3: dividing by an expression that can be zero

    Sharing 6 cookies among 3 friends gives each friend 2. Sharing them among 0 friends has no answer: nobody is there to receive them. Dividing by zero never has an answer. The trouble in a proof is that zero can wear a disguise. An expression such as sin t, cos t or 1 − cos t equals 0 at some angles, and sin2t + cos2t − 1 equals 0 at every angle. Dividing both sides by such an expression divides by zero at those angles, and that can turn a true line into a false one.

    • What it looks like: a step that turns E · A = E · B into A = B by dividing both sides by E.
    • Why it fails: where E = 0, the line E · A = E · B reads 0 = 0, which is true for any A and B, so it gives no reason for A = B.
    • With numbers: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 = 5 is false.
    • Where zero hides, from 0° to 360°: sin t = 0 at 0°, 180° and 360°; cos t = 0 at 90° and 270°; 1 − cos t = 0 at 0° and 360°, since 1 − cos 0° = 1 − 1 = 0; sin2t + cos2t − 1 = 0 at every angle.
    • The same trap from the other end: multiplying both sides by an expression that can be 0 makes the line true at those angles whatever came before.
    • Allowed: canceling a factor shared by the top and bottom of one fraction, because that bottom is already not 0 wherever the fraction makes sense.
    6 ÷ 3 = 26 ÷ 2 = 36 ÷ 1 = 66 ÷ 0 = ?0 groups: nowhere to put them, so no answer
    Six shared among 3, 2 and 1 groups gives 2, 3 and 6, but among 0 groups there is no answer.

    Worked example

    A zero in disguise

    Someone writes: the line (sin2t + cos2t − 1) · sin t = (sin2t + cos2t − 1) · cos t is true for every t, so dividing both sides by sin2t + cos2t − 1 shows that sin t = cos t for every t. Find the mistake.

    Show the steps and the answer
    x = cos θy = sin θP
    At 30° the two legs have different lengths, sin 30° = 12 and cos 30° = 32, so sin t = cos t fails there.
    1. Say what the question asks: find the step where true lines turn into a false one.sin t = cos t cannot hold at every angle: at t = 0°, sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.
    2. Work out the bracket: sin2t+cos2t−1=1−1=0, at every t.The Pythagorean identity says sin2t + cos2t = 1 at every angle.
    3. Read the first line again with the bracket replaced: 0·sint=0·cost, that is 0=0.Zero times any number is 0. The line is true, but it says nothing about sin t or cos t.
    4. So the step that divides both sides by sin2t+cos2t−1 divides by 0, at every angle.The bracket equals 0 everywhere, and dividing by 0 has no answer.
    5. Conclude: the division is the mistake; the true first line cannot be divided down to sint=cost.A multiplication by 0 cannot be undone: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 ≠ 5.
    Answer
    • The mistake is dividing by sin2t + cos2t − 1, which equals 0 at every angle.
    • The first line only says 0 = 0, and sin t = cos t is false: at t = 0°, 0 ≠ 1.
    Double-check At t = 30°: the bracket is 14 + 34 − 1 = 1 − 1 = 0, the zero in disguise, while sin 30° = 12 and cos 30° = 32 are different, so the ending is false at 30° as well.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Dividing both sides by cos t is safe, because cos t is not 0 at most angles.
    At 90° and 270°, cos t = 0, so the step divides by zero there and proves nothing about those angles.
    ✓ Instead: Rewrite one side, and cancel only a factor in the top and bottom of one fraction. A division of both sides holds only at the angles where the divisor is not 0, and every other angle then needs its own check.

    Tips and tricks

    • Before dividing by an expression, plug in 0°, 90°, 180° and 270°, where sine or cosine is 0, and see whether it becomes 0.
    • If the Pythagorean identity turns an expression into 1 − 1, it is a zero in disguise at every angle.

    5 How

    1. Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.
    2. Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.
    3. Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.
    4. Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.
    5. Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.
    6. Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.

    Checking a proof for the three mistakes

    1
    Does the first line hold the whole claim, left side = right side?
    YesThe argument starts from the claim, so a true last line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Check each step, or start again from one side alone.
    NoGo on.
    ↓
    2
    Does any step square both sides?
    YesA true squared line can come from a false claim. Test an angle where one side could be negative, such as 180°.
    NoGo on.
    ↓
    3
    Does any step divide or multiply both sides by an expression?
    YesFind where that expression is 0. At those angles the step passes through 0 and cannot be walked back; if it is 0 at every angle, the step proves nothing.
    NoGo on.
    ↓
    4
    Does a step cancel a factor from the top and bottom of one fraction?
    YesThat is allowed: the bottom is already not 0 wherever the fraction makes sense.
    NoGo on.
    ↓
    5
    Does every line equal the one above it by a known identity, ending at the other side?
    YesThe proof is sound.
    NoFind the first line that does not follow and repair that step.
    1. Read the first line. A proof by this course's method starts with one side of the claim alone. An argument that starts from the whole claim is a proof only if every step can be walked back.
    2. Go line by line. Each line should come from the one above by rewriting one side with a named identity or an algebra move.
    3. Mark every step that squares, multiplies or divides both sides.
    4. For a squaring step, test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.
    5. For a dividing step, find every angle where the divisor is 0 and plug each one back in to confirm it; also check whether the Pythagorean identity makes the divisor 0 at every angle.
    6. If a test angle gives two different values, the claim is false and no proof can exist. If the claim survives, write a fresh proof from one side.

    6 Worked example

    Worked example

    Repairing an argument that works both sides

    Someone wants to show that sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1 is an identity and writes:
    Line 1: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1
    Line 2: sin2t1−cost = 1 + cos t (add cos t to both sides)
    Line 3: sin2t = (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) (multiply both sides by 1 − cos t)
    Line 4: sin2t = 1 − cos2t (multiply out)
    Line 5: sin2t + cos2t = 1 (add cos2t to both sides), which is true.
    They stop there. Say what the five lines show when read from top to bottom, what has to be checked before they count as a proof, and then write a proof that starts from one side.

    Show the steps and the answer

    sin2t1−cost−cost

    =1−cos2t1−cost−cost

    =(1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost−cost

    =1+cost−cost

    = 1

    1. Say what the question asks: what the five lines show as written, what they still need, and a proof from one side.A proof is judged by how its lines are built, not only by whether the last line is true.
    2. Read Line 1: it is the whole claim, left side = right side.The argument starts from the claim, the very thing to be shown, so the lines under it show where the claim leads.
    3. Read Lines 2, 3 and 5: each does the same thing to both sides (adds cos t, multiplies by 1−cost, adds cos2t).Doing the same thing to both sides is how you solve an equation. Each such step says: if the line above is true, the line below is true.
    4. Say what the lines show from top to bottom: if the claim is true, then sin2t+cos2t=1. A true last line does not by itself make the first line true.False starts can reach true finishes too: squaring the false 3 = −3 gives the true 9 = 9.
    5. Check whether every step can be walked back, from Line 5 up to Line 1: subtracting cos2t undoes Line 5, Line 4 only rewrites the right side of Line 3, dividing by 1−cost undoes Line 3, and subtracting cos t undoes Line 2.Dividing by 1 − cos t is allowed here because 1 − cos t is the bottom of the claim's left side, so it is not 0 at any angle where the claim's sides are defined. With this check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof; without it they are not.
    6. Now the method that needs no such check. Start from the left side alone: sin2t1−cost−cost.It is the more complicated side; the right side, 1, has nothing to rewrite.
    7. Replace sin2t with 1−cos2t: =1−cos2t1−cost−cost.The Pythagorean identity sin2t + cos2t = 1 gives sin2t = 1 − cos2t, so the value stays the same.
    8. Factor the top as a difference of squares: =(1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost−cost.1 − cos2t has the shape a2 − b2 with a = 1 and b = cos t, and a2 − b2 = (a − b)(a + b).
    9. Cancel the factor 1−cost from the top and the bottom: =1+cost−cost.Wherever the left side makes sense, its bottom 1 − cos t is not 0, so dividing top and bottom by it keeps the value. This is canceling inside one fraction, not dividing both sides.
    10. Combine: 1+cost−cost=1, which is the right side.cos t − cos t = 0, and every line equals the one before it, so the left side equals the right side.
    Answer
    • Read from top to bottom, the five lines show only that if the claim is true, then sin2t + cos2t = 1.
    • To count as a proof they need a check that every step can be walked back. Here each one can, at every angle where the claim's sides are defined, because 1 − cos t is not 0 at those angles. With that check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof.
    • A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1−cos2t1−cost − cos t = (1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost − cos t = 1 + cos t − cos t = 1.
    Double-check Test two angles. At t = 90°: sin 90° = 1 and cos 90° = 0, so the left side is 11−0 − 0 = 1. At t = 60°: sin260° = 34 and 1 − cos 60° = 12, so 34 ÷ 12 = 32 and 32 − 12 = 1. Both equal the right side, 1, as an identity must; the tests can only catch a false claim, and the chain from one side is the proof.

    Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

    Try each rung before you open its steps.

    Rung 1 of 6

    Rung 1: a false start and a true finish

    What is wrong with this argument: 4 = −4, so squaring both sides gives 16 = 16, which is true, so 4 = −4.

    Show the steps and the answer
    4−416function
    Two arrows end at 16, so from 16 alone you cannot tell whether the start was 4 or −4.
    1. Say what the question asks: find the step that lets a false start look proved.4 = −4 is false, so some step of the argument must be unsound.
    2. Check the start: 4 and −4 sit on opposite sides of 0 on the number line, so 4=−4 is false.Two numbers are equal only when they are the same point on the line.
    3. Square each side: 42=4·4=16 and (−4)2=(−4)·(−4)=16.A negative times a negative is positive.
    4. The squared line 16=16 is true although the start was false. So the unsound step is the last one, which reads the true 16=16 as proof of 4=−4.Squaring sends a number and its negative to the same result, so a true squared line cannot be walked back to the line before it.
    Answer
    The last step, which walks back through the squaring. Squaring took the false 4 = −4 to the true 16 = 16, and 4 and −4 have the same square, so the true finish proves nothing about the start.
    Double-check Try to walk back from 16 = 16 by taking the square root of each side: 16 = 4 on both sides, which gives 4 = 4, not 4 = −4, so the minus sign is lost for good.

    Rung 2 of 6

    Rung 2: dividing by zero, with numbers

    What is wrong with this argument: 7 · 0 = 2 · 0 is true, so dividing both sides by 0 gives 7 = 2.

    Show the steps and the answer
    12 ÷ 3 = 412 ÷ 2 = 612 ÷ 1 = 1212 ÷ 0 = ?0 groups: nowhere to put them, so no answer
    Twelve shared among 3, 2 and 1 groups gives 4, 6 and 12, but among 0 groups there is no answer at all.
    1. Say what the question asks: find the step that turned a true line into the false 7=2.7 and 2 are different numbers, so 7 = 2 is false.
    2. Check the first line: 7·0=0 and 2·0=0, so it reads 0=0, which is true.Zero times any number is 0.
    3. Look at the next step: it divides both sides by 0.Dividing by 0 has no answer, the way sharing among 0 groups cannot be done.
    4. So the division is the mistake.The first line stays true with any two numbers in place of 7 and 2, so it cannot single out 7 = 2.
    Answer
    • Dividing both sides by 0.
    • The line 7 · 0 = 2 · 0 is true for every pair of numbers, so it gives no reason for 7 = 2.
    Double-check Swap in other numbers: 100 · 0 = 1 · 0 is also true, yet 100 ≠ 1, so a line of the form A · 0 = B · 0 holds for every A and B and cannot lead to A = B.

    Rung 3 of 6

    Rung 3: squaring hides a minus sign

    Someone claims that cos t and −cos t are the same number at every angle, because their squares, cos2t and (−cos t)2, are the same number at every angle. Is the claim right?

    Show the steps and the answer
    x = cos θy = sin θ(1, 0)
    At 0° the point is (1, 0), so cos 0° = 1 while −cos 0° = −1.
    1. Say what the question asks: is cos t equal to −cost at every angle?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides make sense, and here both sides make sense at every angle.
    2. Flag the squaring step: (−cost)2=cos2t is true, but it says nothing about cos t and −cost themselves.A negative times a negative is positive, so squaring wipes out the minus sign: two numbers with the same square can still be opposites.
    3. Test t=0°: cos0°=1, so the left side is 1 and the right side is −1.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), and cos t is its x coordinate.
    4. Compare: 1≠−1, so the claim fails at 0°.One angle where both sides make sense and differ is enough to show a claim is not an identity.
    Answer
    • No: at t = 0°, cos t = 1 but −cos t = −1, so cos t = −cos t is not an identity.
    • Squaring made a false claim look true.
    Double-check Test a second angle, t = 180°: cos 180° = −1, so the left side is −1 and the right side is 1, and again they differ.

    Rung 4 of 6

    Rung 4: a square root claim with secant

    Someone claims sec t = 1+tan2t is an identity, because squaring both sides gives sec2t = 1 + tan2t, a Pythagorean identity. Is it an identity?

    Show the steps and the answer

    sec 180° = 1−1 = −1

    tan180°=0−1=0

    1+02=1=1

    −1≠1

    1. Say what the question asks: is sec t equal to 1+tan2t at every angle where both sides make sense?Both sides need cos t ≠ 0, since sec t = 1cost and tan t = sintcost, so the test angle must avoid 90° and 270°.
    2. Flag the squaring step.A true squared line can come from a false claim.
    3. The right side is a square root, so it is never negative. Look where sec t is negative: sect=1cost has the sign of cos t, so pick 180°, where cost=−1.1 divided by a negative number is negative.
    4. Left side at 180°: sec180°=1cos180°=1−1=−1.This is the reciprocal identity, with cos 180° = −1, the x coordinate of (−1, 0).
    5. Right side at 180°: tan180°=sin180°cos180°=0−1=0, so 1+02=1=1.This is the quotient identity, and 0 divided by any number that is not 0 is 0.
    6. Compare: −1≠1, so the claim fails at 180°.Both sides make sense at 180° and differ there.
    Answer
    • No: at t = 180°, sec t = −1 but 1+tan2t = 1.
    • The squared line is an identity; the claim is not.
    Double-check At t = 120°: cos 120° = −12, so sec 120° = −2; tan 120° = 32 ÷ (−12) = −3, so tan2120° = (−3)2 = 3 and 1+3 = 4 = 2. Again −2 ≠ 2.

    Rung 5 of 6

    Rung 5: a sound proof that only looks risky

    Someone proves 31−sint = 3+3sintcos2t like this:
    31−sint = 31−sint · 1+sint1+sint = 3+3sint1−sin2t = 3+3sintcos2t.
    Does the proof make any of the three mistakes?

    Show the steps and the answer

    Allowed: multiply one fraction by 1+sint1+sint, a form of 1

    Not allowed: multiply both sides of the claim

    1. Say what the question asks: check the proof for working both sides, squaring both sides, and dividing by an expression that can be 0.If none of the three appears and every line is a true rewrite, the proof is sound.
    2. Look at the first line: it is the left side alone, not the whole claim.So the proof works on one side; the right side appears only at the end.
    3. Look at the second line: it multiplies the top and the bottom of that one fraction by 1+sint, the conjugate of 1−sint.1+sint1+sint is 1 wherever 1 + sin t is not 0, and multiplying by 1 changes how the side looks, not its value. The other side of the claim is never touched.
    4. Check where 1+sint is 0 in one turn: only at 270°, since 1+sin270°=1+(−1)=0. There cos270°=0, so the right side's bottom is 0 and that angle is not part of the claim.The claim only covers angles where both sides make sense, so no angle that counts is lost.
    5. Check the third line: the top is 3(1+sint)=3+3sint, and the bottom is (1−sint)(1+sint)=1−sin2t.Distribute the 3 over the sum; the bottom is a difference of squares, (a − b)(a + b) = a2 − b2 with a = 1 and b = sin t.
    6. Check the last line: 1−sin2t is replaced by cos2t.The Pythagorean identity sin2t + cos2t = 1 gives cos2t = 1 − sin2t.
    7. Nothing squared both sides and nothing divided both sides; every line equals the one before it.So none of the three mistakes appears.
    Answer
    • No mistake: the proof is sound.
    • It starts from one side, and the conjugate step multiplies one fraction by a form of 1, not both sides of the claim.
    Double-check At t = 30°: the left side is 3 ÷ (1 − 12) = 3 ÷ 12 = 6. The right side is (3 + 32) ÷ 34, where 3 + 32 = 62 + 32 = 92, so it is 92 × 43 = 366 = 6. The two sides match.

    Rung 6 of 6

    Rung 6, genuinely hard: a zero hiding at one angle

    At t = 45°, sin t = cos t. Someone starts there and writes:
    Line 1: sin t = cos t
    Line 2: sin2t = sin t cos t (multiply both sides by sin t)
    Line 3: sin2t − cos2t = sin t cos t − cos2t (subtract cos2t from both sides)
    Line 4: (sin t − cos t)(sin t + cos t) = cos t (sin t − cos t) (factor each side)
    Line 5: sin t + cos t = cos t (divide both sides by sin t − cos t)
    Line 6: sin t = 0 (subtract cos t from both sides)
    But sin 45° = 22, not 0. Which step is wrong?

    Show the steps and the answer
    x = cos θy = sin θP
    At 45° the two legs are equal, so sin t − cos t = 0 there: the zero divided away in the step to Line 5.
    1. Say what the question asks: every line came from the one above, so find the first line that is false at 45°; the step into it is the mistake.A sound step never leads from a true line to a false one.
    2. Line 1 at 45°: sin45°=cos45°=22, so it is true.The point at 45° on the unit circle is (22, 22): its two coordinates are equal.
    3. Line 2: sin245°=22·22=24=12, and sin45°cos45° is the same product, 12, so it is true.Tops times tops and bottoms times bottoms, with 2 · 2 = 2.
    4. Line 3: cos245°=12 as well, so the left side is 12−12=0 and the right side is 12−12=0, so it is true.Subtracting the same number from two equal numbers keeps them equal.
    5. Line 4: the left side is Line 3's left side factored as a difference of squares, and the right side is Line 3's right side with the common factor cos t pulled out, so both sides still equal 0 and it is true.Factoring rewrites an expression without changing its value.
    6. Line 5 at 45°: the left side is 22+22=222=2, and the right side is 22, so it is false.Two halves of 2 make a whole 2, which is twice the right side.
    7. So the step from Line 4 to Line 5 is the mistake: it divides both sides by sint−cost, and at 45° that is 22−22=0.Line 1 said sin t = cos t, so sin t − cos t was 0 from the start: a zero in disguise.
    Answer
    • The step from Line 4 to Line 5: it divides both sides by sin t − cos t, which is 0 at 45°.
    • Lines 1 to 4 are true at 45°; Line 5 is the first false one.
    Double-check Write Line 4 at 45° with its zero showing: 0 · 2 = 22 · 0, that is 0 = 0. Dividing 0 = 0 by 0 is the move from rung 2, where 7 · 0 = 2 · 0 was divided down to 7 = 2.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: I started from the claim and ended at 1 = 1, so the claim is proved.
    1 = 1 is true no matter where you started. The false claim 3 = −3 also reaches a true line, 9 = 9, after squaring.
    ✓ Instead: Start from one side and change it, step by step, into the other side; or show that every step you took can be walked back at every angle of the claim.
    ✗ Not this: Squaring both sides keeps them equal, so it is a safe step.
    It keeps equal sides equal, but it also makes unequal sides equal: 3 ≠ −3, yet 32 = (−3)2. A true squared line cannot tell you which happened.
    ✓ Instead: A true squared line does not prove the unsquared claim unless both sides are known to have the same sign. To judge a claim with a square root, test an angle where one side could be negative.
    ✗ Not this: Canceling 1 − cos t in (1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost divides by an expression that can be 0, so it is not allowed.
    The factor sits in the bottom of that fraction, so at every angle where the fraction makes sense it is already not 0. Dividing the top and bottom by the same number that is not 0 keeps the value.
    ✓ Instead: Cancel a factor shared by the top and bottom of one fraction; do not divide both sides of the claim by an expression at an angle where it is 0.
    ✗ Not this: Multiplying by a conjugate multiplies both sides, so it breaks the one-side rule.
    Multiplying the top and bottom of one fraction by the same expression multiplies that side by 1, and the other side is never touched.
    ✓ Instead: Multiply one fraction's top and bottom by the conjugate; the two sides of the claim are left as they are.
    ✗ Not this: So doing the same thing to both sides is always wrong, even when solving an equation.
    Solving starts from an equation you are told is true and looks for the angles that make it so; doing the same thing to both sides is the right tool there.
    ✓ Instead: Both sides when solving an equation; one side when proving an identity.

    Tips and tricks

    • Memory device for the safe habit: one side, no squares, no zeros. Start from one side, do not square both sides, do not divide by an expression that can be 0.
    • Read the first line of any proof. If it already shows both sides of the claim joined by an equals sign, the argument is working both sides, and every step then needs a walk-back check.
    • To catch a squaring mistake, test an angle outside the first quadrant, such as 120°, 180° or 210°: inside the first quadrant every sine and cosine is positive, so sign errors hide.
    • Before you divide, find every angle where the expression is 0: set it equal to 0 and solve. Start with 0°, 90°, 180° and 270°, where sine or cosine is 0, but do not stop there: sin t − cos t is 0 at 45° and 225°. If the Pythagorean identity turns it into 1 − 1, it is 0 at every angle.
    • Scratch work on both sides is fine for finding the idea. The proof you write down starts from one side and reuses the identities you found.
    • A test angle can show a claim is false, never that it is true: a match at 60° is a good sign, and a proof needs an argument that covers every angle, such as the chain from one side.

    7 The trap

    The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.

    Flash cards

    Say the answer out loud, then flip.

    What is a one-way step in a proof?
    A move that can turn a false line into a true one, like a friend who praises every outfit. A true line after it proves nothing about the line before it.
    Why is squaring both sides a one-way step?
    A number and its negative have the same square, so a false line can come out true: the false 5 = −5 squares to the true 25 = 25.
    Why can a proof not divide both sides by an expression at an angle where it is 0?
    Dividing by 0 has no answer. And a line with 0 multiplied into both sides says nothing about the rest: 2·0 = 7·0 is true, yet 2 ≠ 7.
    An argument starts from the claim, works both sides and reaches a true line. Why is that not yet a proof, and what does this course do instead?
    • It shows only that the claim leads to a true line, and a false claim can be carried to a true line the same way. It would be a proof only if every step were checked to run backwards.
    • This course writes the more complicated side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it is exactly the other side.