Quarry School

The usual mistakes in a proof — quick review

In plain words

Picture a friend who tells you every outfit looks great, even the shirt with a ketchup stain.

Rule

A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim. The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.

Step

  1. Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.

  2. Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.

  3. Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.

  4. Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.

  5. Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.

  6. Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.

Strategy

  1. Read the first line. A proof by this course's method starts with one side of the claim alone. An argument that starts from the whole claim is a proof only if every step can be walked back.

  2. Go line by line. Each line should come from the one above by rewriting one side with a named identity or an algebra move.

  3. Mark every step that squares, multiplies or divides both sides.

  4. For a squaring step, test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.

  5. For a dividing step, find every angle where the divisor is 0 and plug each one back in to confirm it; also check whether the Pythagorean identity makes the divisor 0 at every angle.

  6. If a test angle gives two different values, the claim is false and no proof can exist. If the claim survives, write a fresh proof from one side.

Question

Someone wants to show that sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1 is an identity and writes:
Line 1: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1
Line 2: sin2t1−cost = 1 + cos t (add cos t to both sides)
Line 3: sin2t = (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) (multiply both sides by 1 − cos t)
Line 4: sin2t = 1 − cos2t (multiply out)
Line 5: sin2t + cos2t = 1 (add cos2t to both sides), which is true.
They stop there. Say what the five lines show when read from top to bottom, what has to be checked before they count as a proof, and then write a proof that starts from one side.

Answer

Read from top to bottom, the five lines show only that if the claim is true, then sin2t + cos2t = 1.
To count as a proof they need a check that every step can be walked back. Here each one can, at every angle where the claim's sides are defined, because 1 − cos t is not 0 at those angles. With that check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof.
A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1−cos2t1−cost − cos t = (1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost − cos t = 1 + cos t − cos t = 1.

Trap

The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.

Term

identity

Definition

An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.

Term

reciprocal identity

Definition

An identity writing one function as 1 divided by another: csc t = 1sint, sec t = 1cost, cot t = 1tant. Each pair multiplies to 1.

Term

quotient identity

Definition

An identity writing tangent and cotangent as one function divided by another: tan t = sintcost and cot t = costsint. A quotient is the answer to a division.

Term

Pythagorean identity

Definition

One of three identities built from x2 + y2 = 1 on the unit circle: sin2t + cos2t = 1, and the two forms you get by dividing it by cos2t or by sin2t.

Term

conjugate

Definition

The same two pieces with the sign between them switched: the conjugate of 1 + sin t is 1 − sin t. Multiplying the pair gives a difference of squares, 1 − sin2t.