Quarry School

Evaluate and solve from tables and graphs

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Evaluate versus solveLeans on: Squaring a negative
Level 2 · BuildingAbout 16 min read9 new terms
How this was estimated

Programmatic estimate. Rung levels, worked steps, prerequisites, terms and sentence length contribute to this level. It describes the lesson, not your ability.

Reading counts the whole lesson, including folded explanations, at 180 words a minute. Practice allows two minutes per item. These are planning assumptions; take the time you need.

AI estimate unavailable.

Path to here

Open the unit’s lesson list to follow the lesson order.

    Quick review (2 minutes)

    In plain words

    Think of a train timetable.

    Rule

    Evaluate g(3): input 3 is given; read its output. Solve g(n) = 6: output 6 is given; find every input paired with it. A point (x, y) on a function graph means y = f(x).

    Step

    1. Translate the question into either given input, find output, or given output, find inputs.

    2. In a table, stay in the same column when moving between its input and output rows.

    3. On a graph, locate the given input on the horizontal axis or the given output on the vertical axis.

    4. For evaluation, move vertically to the graph and read the height. For solving, search across the given height and read every horizontal position.

    5. Check each answer against its original column or point. Do not invent values between isolated data points.

    Question

    A city shuttle makes seven stops on its morning loop, numbered s = 1 through s = 7. The function P gives the number of passengers on board, P(s), just after the shuttle pulls away from stop s. The table lists every value of P:

    s (stop number): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
    P(s) (passengers): 8, 14, 21, 14, 11, 14, 9

    (a) Evaluate P(5) and say what it means.
    (b) Solve P(s) = 14 and say what it means.
    (c) Solve P(s) = 17.

    Answer

    (a) P(5) = 11: just after the shuttle leaves stop 5, 11 passengers are on board. (b) s = 2, s = 4 or s = 6: the shuttle carries 14 passengers just after leaving each of stops 2, 4 and 6. (c) No solution: 17 is not an output anywhere in the table, and P has no inputs between the listed stop numbers.

    Trap

    Reading only the first matching output when solving. Scan the whole table or the whole horizontal level of the graph before writing the solution set.

    Strategy

    1. Translate the question into either given input, find output, or given output, find inputs.

    2. In a table, stay in the same column when moving between its input and output rows.

    3. On a graph, locate the given input on the horizontal axis or the given output on the vertical axis.

    4. For evaluation, move vertically to the graph and read the height. For solving, search across the given height and read every horizontal position.

    5. Check each answer against its original column or point. Do not invent values between isolated data points.

    Term

    Relation

    Definition

    A set of ordered pairs that connects inputs with outputs. It can have conflicting outputs and need not be a function.

    Term

    Ordered pair

    Definition

    Two values written in a fixed order. Here the first is an input and the second is its paired output.

    Term

    Set

    Definition

    A collection of distinct members. Braces list them, and repeating a member does not create a new member.

    Term

    Function

    Definition

    A relation assigning exactly one output to every input in its domain.

    Term

    Input

    Definition

    A value chosen for a function. The definition decides which values are allowed.

    Term

    Output

    Definition

    The result a function assigns to a particular input.

    Term

    Domain

    Definition

    The set of all inputs accepted by the defined relation or function.

    Term

    Range

    Definition

    The set of all outputs actually produced by the defined relation or function.

    Term

    Function notation

    Definition

    Writing an output as f(x), with the rule name outside and the input inside parentheses.

    Term

    Equation

    Definition

    A statement that two expressions are equal, shown with an equals sign.

    Term

    Formula

    Definition

    A mathematical instruction connecting quantities, often written as an equation.

    Term

    Evaluate

    Definition

    Find the output at a given input by applying the rule or reading its representation.

    Term

    Solve

    Definition

    Find every allowed input that satisfies a stated equation or produces a specified output.

    Term

    Graph

    Definition

    A picture of ordered pairs at their coordinate locations. A graph of a function contains every pair (x, f(x)) for its allowed inputs.

    Term

    Coordinate

    Definition

    One number in a point's ordered address.

    Term

    x-coordinate

    Definition

    The first number of a plotted pair, showing horizontal location and usually the input.

    Term

    Horizontal axis

    Definition

    The left-right reference line on a graph, conventionally the input or x-axis.

    Term

    Vertical axis

    Definition

    The up-down reference line on a graph, conventionally the output or y-axis.

    Term

    Square root

    Definition

    The nonnegative number whose square equals the given nonnegative input.

    Term

    Infinity

    Definition

    Unending extent, written ∞. It is not a final real-number endpoint.

    Term

    Origin

    Definition

    The point (0, 0), where the horizontal and vertical axes meet.

    Term

    Nonnegative

    Definition

    Zero or positive; written x ≥ 0.

    1 In plain words

    Think of a train timetable. If you know the train, you look across to find its arrival time. If you know the arrival time, you search for every train arriving then. A function table works the same way. You can start with an input and find its output, or start with an output and find all matching inputs. A graph is another picture of those same pairs. Its horizontal position shows the input, and its vertical position shows the output. Read the question first so you know which direction to search. You do not need a formula when the table or graph supplies the answer.

    2 Picture it

    input noutput g(n)1826374658↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
    n: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5; g(n): 8, 6, 7, 6, 8, read at n = 3, solved for g(n) = 6.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Evaluate versus solve, Squaring a negative
    • Evaluate versus solve. In g(3), 3 is the given input. In g(n) = 6, 6 is the given output. These are different starting points.
    • Squaring a negative. Keep parentheses: (−2)2 = 4. The expression −22 means −4.

    3 Why

    Each column of an input and output table keeps a pair together. Moving down a column therefore preserves the connection between the two values. On a graph, a point's two coordinates preserve that same connection: (3, 7) says input 3 gives output 7. Fixing an input selects one output because the relation is a function. Fixing an output can select several inputs because different inputs may share an output.

    4 The rule

    Evaluate g(3): input 3 is given; read its output.

    Solve g(n)=6: output 6 is given; find every input paired with it. A point (x, y) on a function graph means y=f(x).

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    g of three is seven. g of n equals six asks which n values work.

    Write it

    Evaluation begins with an input. Solving begins with an output and collects all matching inputs.

    In math
    • g(3) = 7
    • (3, 7)
    • g(n) = 6 gives n = 2 or n = 4
    • Points (2, 6) and (4, 6) share height 6.
    Like

    A train name finds its arrival time; an arrival time can match several trains.

    See it
    input noutput g(n)1826374658↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
    The same picture again: n: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5; g(n): 8, 6, 7, 6, 8, read at n = 3, solved for g(n) = 6.

    The same idea, other ways

    As a timetable

    Given a train name, look for one arrival time. Given an arrival time, collect every train name next to it. Evaluation and solving reverse the search.

    As paired coordinates

    The table column with input 3 and output 7 becomes the graph point (3, 7). You can read that same pair from either direction.

    3ginputoutput7
    Evaluation follows the input to its paired output.

    Part 1: Table lookup in both directions

    A table can work like a contact list. The input can be a name, and you look beside that name for the attached information. This table gives a pet label as input and memory span in hours as output. Call its rule M. Find Gold in the input row to evaluate M(Gold). Search backward from an hour value to find its pet label. The short table labels are Pup for puppy, Dog for adult dog, Gold for goldfish, and Beta for beta fish. Cat is unchanged.

    • M has the listed pet labels as its domain and the listed hour values as its range.
    • M(Gold) = 2160 hours in this table. Gold is the goldfish label.
    • A table can define the entire function or show selected values. Read the statement before assuming missing inputs are allowed.
    • Reason: A function associates an input with an output; it does not require the input to be a number or the rule to be a formula. The paired entries already tell you the rule for the listed labels. Looking up an unlisted label would need more information. Changing the direction of the search does not change any pair, so checking an answer means reading its column in the other direction.
    input petoutput hoursPup0.008Dog0.083Cat16Gold2160Beta3600↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
    pet: Pup, Dog, Cat, Gold, Beta; hours: 0.008, 0.083, 16, 2160, 3600.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Function notation
    • Function notation. M(Cat) means use Cat as the input to M. It does not mean multiplication.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    M of Gold equals two thousand one hundred sixty hours.

    Write it

    The goldfish input label Gold has an output of 2160 hours.

    In math
    • M(Gold) = 2160
    • (Gold, 2160)
    • M(pet) = 3600 gives pet = Beta
    Like

    Look up a name in a contact list, then read the entry attached to that name.

    See it
    input petoutput hoursPup0.008Dog0.083Cat16Gold2160Beta3600↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
    The same picture again: pet: Pup, Dog, Cat, Gold, Beta; hours: 0.008, 0.083, 16, 2160, 3600.

    Worked example

    Read a label, then reverse the search

    OpenStax problem

    Find M(Gold), the memory span paired with the goldfish label Gold. Then solve M(pet) = 3600, meaning find every pet label paired with 3600 hours.

    What it asks. Find the number attached to Gold, then the pet label attached to 3600 hours.

    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Read down from Gold for evaluation and up from 3600 for solving.

    input petoutput hoursPup0.008Dog0.083Cat16Gold2160Beta3600↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
    The same picture a third time: pet: Pup, Dog, Cat, Gold, Beta; hours: 0.008, 0.083, 16, 2160, 3600.
    1. Plan. Read down from Gold for evaluation and up from 3600 for solving.
    2. Gold is the table label for goldfish.
    3. The hour value 3600 is in the last output cell.
    1. Locate Gold in the input row and read 2160 directly below it.The output in that column is M(Gold), the memory span for goldfish.
    2. Locate 3600 in the output row and read Beta directly above it.Solving reverses the lookup, and no other output cell holds 3600.
    Answer
    • M(Gold) = 2160 hours.
    • M(pet) = 3600 gives pet = Beta, the beta fish label.
    Double-check The Gold column contains 2160 hours. The Beta column contains 3600 hours. Read the same two columns in reverse to confirm each answer.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: M(Hamster) = 16 because a hamster seems similar to a cat.
    Hamster is not a listed input, and a resemblance supplies no function value.
    ✓ Instead: The table does not give M(Hamster).

    Tips and tricks

    • Keep the output unit: pet label goes in, hours come out.
    • If a pet label is not listed, the table gives no value for it.
    • As a contact list: A person's name can locate a phone number without an arithmetic formula. A pet label can locate its hour value the same way.
    • As arrows: Each label points to its paired number. To solve for an output, trace every arrow ending at that number back to its label.

    Part 2: Graph reading in both directions

    Think of a building directory on a map. Start with an input address along the horizontal axis, move straight up or down until you reach the curve, then read its height as the output. Starting with an output reverses the search: hold that height and look across for every point at that level. The curve s(x) = x2 includes the points between the marked samples because its formula defines them too. Separate table dots alone do not tell you to draw a connecting curve.

    • The graph of a function is its collection of input and output points (x, f(x)).
    • For the curve s(x) = x2, each input is squared to find its height.
    • Evaluate by choosing x first. Solve by choosing y first. A height below this square curve has no matching point.
    • Reason: All points directly above one horizontal position have the same input. That makes a vertical search useful when the input is given. All points at the same height have the same output. That makes a horizontal search useful when the output is given. Joining separate data dots would claim answers for new inputs. Only a curve or rule gives permission to include those extra points.
    (2, 4)(−3, 9)(3, 9)−4−2244812
    y=x2.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Coordinates
    • Coordinates. In (−3, 9), go 3 left and 9 up. The order is horizontal first, vertical second.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    s of two equals four. s of x equals nine asks which x values reach nine.

    Write it

    The curve height gives an output; the horizontal addresses at a given height give its input solutions.

    In math
    • s(2) = 4
    • (2, 4)
    • s(x) = 9 gives x = −3 or x = 3
    Like

    An address finds one shelf height; a shelf height may occur at several addresses.

    See it
    (2, 4)(−3, 9)(3, 9)−4−2244812
    The same picture again: y = x2.

    Worked example

    A square curve gives one output and two inputs

    For the graph s(x) = x2, evaluate s(2), meaning read the height at input 2. Then solve s(x) = 9, meaning find every input at height 9.

    What it asks. Read one output at input 2, then all inputs at output height 9.

    (2, 4)(−3, 9)(3, 9)−4−2244812
    Height 9 meets the square curve twice, so collect both inputs.
    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Move vertically from x = 2 to the curve. Then follow the horizontal dashed level at height 9 to both contacts.

    1. Plan. Move vertically from x = 2 to the curve. Then follow the horizontal dashed level at height 9 to both contacts.
    2. The point (2, 4) carries input 2 and output 4.
    3. Both points (−3, 9) and (3, 9) have height 9.
    1. Start at 2 on the horizontal axis and move up to the point (2, 4). Read s(2)=4.The point's vertical coordinate is the output for its horizontal coordinate.
    2. Start at height 9 on the vertical axis and look across to both curve points (−3,9) and (3, 9).Both points have the requested output 9.
    3. Read their horizontal coordinates and write x=−3 or x=3.Solving asks for the inputs, rather than the common height.
    Answer
    • s(2) = 4.
    • For s(x) = 9:
    • x=−3.
    • x = 3.
    Double-check Use the rule independently of the picture: 22 = 4, (−3)2 = 9, and 32 = 9.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: s(x) = 9 has the answer 9.
    9 is the output already given; the question asks which inputs reach it.
    ✓ Instead: Read the horizontal coordinates: x = −3 or x = 3.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write input or output beside the given value before touching the graph.
    • A few marked points on a curve are samples. Separate data dots without a curve do not authorize joining them.
    • As a map address: For s(2), go to horizontal position 2 and read the curve's height 4. The address (2, 4) contains the answer.
    • As a level shelf: For s(x) = 9, slide a level shelf across height 9. It touches this curve at horizontal positions −3 and 3.

    Part 3: Domain and range from a graph

    Imagine shining a lamp straight down onto a curve. Its shadow on the horizontal axis shows every input position the graph covers: the domain. Now shine the lamp from the side. The shadow on the vertical axis shows every output height it reaches: the range. Domain is read left to right. Range is read bottom to top. The drawn window shows a portion of an unending curve, so use its continuing direction together with the rule to decide whether a shadow continues forever.

    • Domain: the graph’s horizontal input coverage. Read its shadow on the x-axis.
    • Range: the graph’s vertical output coverage. Read its shadow on the y-axis.
    • For x, both shadows start at the included zero and continue in the positive direction.
    • For x2, the bowl reaches left and right forever, so domain is all real numbers. Its heights are zero or positive, so range is [0, ∞).
    (0, 0)(4, 2)(9, 3)domainrange246810−11234
    y=x.

    Reminder

    Reminder: Interval endpoints
    • Interval endpoints. [0, ∞) includes zero. The parenthesis at infinity means there is no last point.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Domain is left to right. Range is bottom to top.

    Write it

    Inputs make the horizontal shadow; outputs make the vertical shadow.

    In math
    • For y = x: domain [0, ∞), range [0, ∞).
    • For y = x2: domain (−∞, ∞), range [0, ∞).
    Like

    Two lamps cast two different shadows of the same curve.

    See it
    (0, 0)(4, 2)(9, 3)domainrange246810−11234
    The same picture again: y = x.

    Worked example

    Read the square-root graph’s two shadows

    Use the graph y = x to find its domain and range.

    What it asks. Find every input position and every output height covered by the graph.

    (0, 0)(4, 2)(9, 3)domainrange246810−11234
    The same picture a third time: y = x.
    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Project the graph onto the x-axis for domain and onto the y-axis for range. Read included endpoints separately.

    1. Plan. Project the graph onto the x-axis for domain and onto the y-axis for range. Read included endpoints separately.
    2. Domain is read left to right.
    3. Range is read bottom to top.
    1. Read left to right: the graph starts at input 0 and continues right forever.Domain collects the horizontal input positions covered by the curve.
    2. Write domain [0,∞).The starting point (0, 0) includes input 0, and the curve has no last input.
    3. Read bottom to top: the lowest height is 0, and the graph continues upward forever.Range collects the vertical output heights the curve reaches.
    4. Write range [0,∞).Output 0 is included, and no upper height is the last output.
    Answer
    • Domain: [0, ∞).
    • Range: [0, ∞).
    Double-check Check the rule: negative inputs have no real square root, and a root output is nonnegative. Any output y ≥ 0 is reached by input y2.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: The square graph stays above the x-axis, so its domain is [0, ∞).
    Above the axis describes output heights. The bowl still has points at negative horizontal inputs, such as (−2, 4).
    ✓ Instead: For x2, domain is (−∞, ∞); range is [0, ∞).

    Tips and tricks

    • Memory cue: D before R, I before O, x before y. Domain is input x; range is output y.
    • Check whether a finite endpoint is included before choosing its bracket.
    • With shadows: Drop the graph’s points onto the x-axis for domain. Move them sideways onto the y-axis for range.
    • With a point address: The point (4, 2) contributes input 4 to the domain and output 2 to the range. Collect every graph point’s first or second coordinate.

    5 How

    1. Translate the question into either given input, find output, or given output, find inputs.
    2. In a table, stay in the same column when moving between its input and output rows.
    3. On a graph, locate the given input on the horizontal axis or the given output on the vertical axis.
    4. For evaluation, move vertically to the graph and read the height. For solving, search across the given height and read every horizontal position.
    5. Check each answer against its original column or point. Do not invent values between isolated data points.

    Read a table or graph in the requested direction

    1
    Is an input given, as in g(3)?
    YesEvaluate: keep that input and find its paired output.
    NoAn output is given, so solve by finding every input producing it.
    ↓
    2
    Is the information a table?
    YesRead down from the input to evaluate; read up from every matching output to solve.
    NoOn a graph, move vertically from the input to the curve to evaluate. For solving, search across the given output height.
    ↓
    3
    Does the given input or output have a listed column or graph contact?
    YesRead the paired coordinate. For solving, keep every matching input.
    NoFor a complete function, there is no matching value there. For a sample table, a missing value needs more information.
    1. Translate the question into either given input, find output, or given output, find inputs.
    2. In a table, stay in the same column when moving between its input and output rows.
    3. On a graph, locate the given input on the horizontal axis or the given output on the vertical axis.
    4. For evaluation, move vertically to the graph and read the height. For solving, search across the given height and read every horizontal position.
    5. Check each answer against its original column or point. Do not invent values between isolated data points.

    6 Worked example

    Worked example

    Evaluate and solve from a shuttle's passenger table

    A city shuttle makes seven stops on its morning loop, numbered s = 1 through s = 7. The function P gives the number of passengers on board, P(s), just after the shuttle pulls away from stop s. The table lists every value of P:

    s (stop number): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
    P(s) (passengers): 8, 14, 21, 14, 11, 14, 9

    (a) Evaluate P(5) and say what it means.
    (b) Solve P(s) = 14 and say what it means.
    (c) Solve P(s) = 17.

    input stop number, soutput passengers on board, P(s)1821432141451161479
    A table of 7 values of passengers on board, P(s), for stop number, s from 1 to 7.
    Show the steps and the answer
    input stop number, soutput passengers on board, P(s)1821432141451161479↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
    Table of P for the shuttle loop.
    1. Translate part (a). In P(5) the number inside the parentheses is the input. This is 'given input, find output': the stop number s=5 is given and the passenger count is wanted.In function notation the value inside the parentheses is always the input, and P(5) names the output paired with it.
    2. Find 5 in the s row of the table. Stay in that same column, move down to the P(s) row and read the entry, which is 11. So P(5)=11.Each column of the table is one input-output pair. The output for s = 5 is the entry directly below it, not an entry from a neighboring column.
    3. Interpret: P(5)=11 means that just after the shuttle pulls away from stop 5, 11 passengers are on board.The input is a stop number and the output is a number of passengers, so the meaning names the stop and the count in the words of the problem.
    4. Translate part (b). In P(s)=14 the number 14 is a value of P. This is 'given output, find inputs': the passenger count 14 is given and every stop number s with that count is wanted.The equation sets the output P(s) equal to 14 and leaves the input s unknown. It is not P(14), which would treat 14 as an input, and there is no stop 14.
    5. Scan the entire P(s) row: 8, 14, 21, 14, 11, 14, 9. The value 14 appears three times. Move up each of those three columns to the s row to get s=2,s=4 and s=6.Solving means finding every input paired with the given output. A function can give the same output for different inputs, so the search cannot stop at the first 14.
    6. Interpret: P(s)=14 when s=2,s=4 or s=6. The shuttle carries 14 passengers just after leaving stop 2, just after leaving stop 4 and just after leaving stop 6.Each solution is an input, which here is a stop number, and the equation says the output 14 occurs at each of those stops.
    7. Translate part (c). P(s)=17 is again 'given output, find inputs'. Scan the entire P(s) row: 8, 14, 21, 14, 11, 14, 9. No entry is 17.The table lists every value of P, so a stop is a solution only if 17 appears in its column.
    8. Do not estimate an input between s=2 (14 passengers) and s=3 (21 passengers), such as s=2.5. Conclude that P(s)=17 has no solution.P is defined only at the stop numbers 1 through 7. There is no stop between stop 2 and stop 3, so there is no input there and no output to read. A value invented between isolated data points is not data the table contains.
    Answer
    (a) P(5) = 11: just after the shuttle leaves stop 5, 11 passengers are on board. (b) s = 2, s = 4 or s = 6: the shuttle carries 14 passengers just after leaving each of stops 2, 4 and 6. (c) No solution: 17 is not an output anywhere in the table, and P has no inputs between the listed stop numbers.
    Double-check Return to each column. In column s = 5 the P(s) entry is 11, which matches P(5) = 11. In columns s = 2, s = 4 and s = 6 each entry is 14, so P(2) = P(4) = P(6) = 14. The other columns hold 8 (s = 1), 21 (s = 3), 11 (s = 5) and 9 (s = 7), and none of these is 14, so no solution of P(s) = 14 was missed. No column holds 17, which confirms that P(s) = 17 has no solution.

    Work to write

    1. P(5) = 11
    2. Just after the shuttle leaves stop 5, 11 passengers are on board.
    3. P(s) = 14 when s = 2, s = 4 or s = 6
    4. The shuttle carries 14 passengers just after leaving stops 2, 4 and 6.
    5. P(s) = 17 has no solution, because 17 is not an output in the table and there is no stop between the listed stops.

    Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

    Try each rung before you open its steps.

    Rung 1 of 4

    Evaluate one table input

    Evaluate g(1), meaning find the output under input 1 in the table.

    What it asks. Find the output in the column for input 1.

    input noutput g(n)1826374658
    n: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5; g(n): 8, 6, 7, 6, 8.
    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Locate input 1 and read directly down.

    input noutput g(n)1826374658↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
    One highlighted input identifies one paired output.
    1. Plan. Locate input 1 and read directly down.
    2. The first column begins with input 1.
    3. Its lower cell is 8.
    1. Find 1 in the input row and read the 8 below it.Evaluation follows one known input to its paired output.
    Answer
    g(1) = 8.
    Double-check The first column pairs 1 with 8, so the ordered pair is (1, 8).

    Rung 2 of 4

    Evaluate a graph input

    For the curve s(x) = x2, evaluate s(−2), meaning read the output height at input −2.

    What it asks. Read the square curve’s height at input −2.

    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Keep x = −2 while moving vertically to the curve, then read y.

    (−2, 4)−22−2246810
    Input −2 lies left of zero, but its output lies above zero.
    1. Plan. Keep x = −2 while moving vertically to the curve, then read y.
    2. −2 is left of the origin.
    3. The point there is (−2, 4).
    1. Start at −2 on the horizontal axis and move vertically to the curve at (−2,4).The input stays −2 during a vertical move.
    2. Read the height 4, so s(−2)=4.The vertical coordinate is the output.
    Answer
    s(−2)=4.
    Double-check The rule gives (−2)2 = (−2) × (−2) = 4, agreeing with the graph.

    Rung 3 of 4

    Two graph solutions, then no solutions

    On the curve s(x) = x2, solve s(x) = 4 and s(x) = −1. Each question gives an output height and asks for every input at that height.

    What it asks. Find every input at height 4, then every input at height −1.

    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Inspect each dashed horizontal level and read the x-coordinate of every curve contact.

    (−2, 4)(2, 4)−22−2246810
    Height 4 cuts the curve in two places.
    −22−2246810
    Height −1 never touches the curve.
    1. Plan. Inspect each dashed horizontal level and read the x-coordinate of every curve contact.
    2. Height 4 has two contacts.
    3. The square curve never goes below zero.
    1. At height 4, find curve points (−2,4) and (2, 4). Read x=−2 or x=2.Both points have output 4.
    2. At height −1, find no point on the curve. Write no real solution.A square is never negative, so this curve never reaches a height below zero.
    Answer
    • For s(x) = 4:
    • x=−2.
    • x = 2.
    • For s(x) = −1: no real solution.
    Double-check (−2)2 = 22 = 4. Every real square is zero or positive, which independently rules out output −1.

    Rung 4 of 4

    Solve on a shifted square graph

    Use the graph of u(x) = (x − 3)2. Evaluate u(4), then solve u(x) = 4 and u(x) = 0.

    What it asks. Read one given input and two given heights. The solution inputs need not be opposites.

    (4, 1)(1, 4)(5, 4)(3, 0)246246810
    The bowl is centered at input 3. Height 4 meets it at inputs 1 and 5, which are not opposites.
    Show the steps and the answer

    The plan. Use vertical lookup for u(4), then horizontal lookup for output heights 4 and 0.

    1. Plan. Use vertical lookup for u(4), then horizontal lookup for output heights 4 and 0.
    2. The graph’s bottom is at x = 3, rather than x = 0.
    3. At height 4, the contacts lie two units to either side of 3.
    1. At input 4, read the point (4, 1), so u(4)=1.Evaluation uses the point’s height as its output.
    2. Follow height 4 to (1, 4) and (5, 4), so x=1 or x=5.Solving collects every horizontal input address at the requested height.
    3. At height 0, the graph has only the point (3, 0), so x=3.The lowest point gives one contact at this height.
    Answer
    • u(4) = 1.
    • For u(x) = 4:
    • x = 1.
    • x = 5.
    • For u(x) = 0: x = 3.
    Double-check Use the formula to check: (4 − 3)2 = 1, (1 − 3)2 = 4, (5 − 3)2 = 4, and (3 − 3)2 = 0.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: g(3) = 6 because 6 appears somewhere in the table.
    A value elsewhere in the output row need not belong to input 3.
    ✓ Instead: Stay in the column under 3: g(3) = 7.
    ✗ Not this: A graph solution must always exist.
    Some requested heights never meet the graph.
    ✓ Instead: For s(x) = x2, output −1 has no real input.
    ✗ Not this: For u(x) = (x − 3)2, solving u(x) = 4 gives x = −2 or x = 2.
    The graph is centered at input 3. Those two proposed inputs give outputs 25 and 1.
    ✓ Instead: Height 4 meets the graph at x = 1 and x = 5: (1 − 3)2 = (5 − 3)2 = 4.

    Tips and tricks

    • Remember down to evaluate, up from every match to solve in an input row above an output row.
    • On a graph, evaluation fixes horizontal position; solving fixes height.

    7 The trap

    Reading only the first matching output when solving. Scan the whole table or the whole horizontal level of the graph before writing the solution set.

    Comes back in

    Problems marked OpenStax come from Precalculus 2e by Jay Abramson, published by OpenStax, under the CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 licence. Access for free at https://openstax.org/books/precalculus-2e/pages/1-introduction-to-functions.