Quarry School

Using the identities: rewrite and prove

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Common denominatorsLeans on: Difference of squaresLeans on: Nonzero cancellationLeans on: Root signs
Level 2 · BuildingAbout 13 min read13 new terms
How this was estimated

Programmatic estimate. Rung levels, worked steps, prerequisites, terms and sentence length contribute to this level. It describes the lesson, not your ability.

Reading counts the whole lesson, including folded explanations, at 180 words a minute. Practice allows two minutes per item. These are planning assumptions; take the time you need.

AI estimate unavailable.

Path to here

Open the unit’s lesson list to follow the lesson order.

    Quick review (2 minutes)

    In plain words

    You can pay the same amount with a $5 bill or five $1 bills.

    Rule

    For an acute angle, cos θ = 1−sin2θ and tan θ = sinθ1−sin2θ. An identity holds on its common domain. Use sin θ ≠ 0 when dividing by sin θ and cos θ ≠ 0 when dividing by cos θ.

    Step

    1. State the allowed inputs before rewriting: tan and sec need cos θ ≠ 0; cot and csc need sin θ ≠ 0. A displayed fraction also needs its denominator nonzero.

    2. Pick the messier side, usually the one with more terms or fractions.

    3. Rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc using sin θ and cos θ.

    4. Combine fractions over a common denominator, or multiply out brackets.

    5. Replace 1 − sin2θ with cos2θ, 1 − cos2θ with sin2θ, and sin2θ + cos2θ with 1.

    6. Cancel common factors only when those factors are nonzero. Stop at the other side; preserve the original allowed inputs.

    Question

    Prove sec θ − cos θ = sin θ tan θ for cos θ ≠ 0. In words, rewrite the left expression until it becomes the right expression.

    Answer

    The left side turns into sin θ tan θ, the right side, so the identity holds wherever both sides are defined.

    Trap

    Testing one angle and calling the identity proved. One angle can agree by coincidence; a proof needs algebra that works for every θ. Use a test angle only to check your algebra afterward.

    Strategy

    1. Translate the question: rewriting changes the ingredients; proving establishes equality.

    2. Record all original nonzero denominators.

    3. Choose one side and rewrite all functions with sine and cosine.

    4. Combine fractions or expand brackets with a reason.

    5. Use the Pythagorean identity and cancel only nonzero factors.

    6. End at the requested expression and retain the domain restrictions.

    Term

    Acute angle

    Definition

    An angle greater than 0° and less than 90°, narrower than a square corner.

    Term

    Reciprocal

    Definition

    The flip of a nonzero number: 1 divided by it. A number times its reciprocal is 1. Zero has no reciprocal.

    Term

    Identity

    Definition

    An equation that is true for every value of the variable where both sides are defined.

    Term

    Pythagorean identity

    Definition

    sin2θ + cos2θ = 1. Dividing by nonzero cos2θ gives tan2θ + 1 = sec2θ; dividing by nonzero sin2θ gives cot2θ + 1 = csc2θ.

    Term

    sin2θ

    Definition

    Shorthand for (sin θ)2: find the sine, then square it. It does not mean sin(θ2).

    Term

    LHS

    Definition

    Abbreviation for left side: the expression to the left of the equals sign.

    Term

    Prove (verify) an identity

    Definition

    Show that two expressions agree for every allowed angle by justified algebra. Transforming one side into the other is the beginner strategy used here.

    Term

    Undefined

    Definition

    No value exists, because the formula would divide by zero.

    Term

    Domain

    Definition

    All the inputs a function accepts. sin and cos accept every angle; tan and sec skip angles on the y-axis; cot and csc skip angles on the x-axis.

    Term

    RHS

    Definition

    Abbreviation for right side: the expression to the right of the equals sign.

    Term

    Function

    Definition

    A rule giving exactly one output for each allowed input. Trigonometric functions take angle inputs and produce numerical ratios.

    Term

    Difference of squares

    Definition

    The product (a + b)(a − b) equals a2 − b2 because its middle products cancel.

    Term

    Factor

    Definition

    A number or expression multiplied by another to make a product. A common factor multiplies the whole numerator and denominator.

    1 In plain words

    You can pay the same amount with a $5 bill or five $1 bills. An identity makes a similar trade: you replace an expression with an equal expression wherever both are defined. A domain is the collection of allowed inputs. A common domain consists of inputs allowed by both expressions. Rewriting asks you to express one function using only another. Proving an identity, also called verifying it, asks you to show why two expressions agree for every allowed angle. You start with a side you understand, rewrite it through equal expressions and arrive at the other side. The left side, or LHS, is before the equals sign. The right side, or RHS, is after it.

    Explain it like I am five

    Proving an identity, an equation true for every allowed angle, is like showing 4 quarters and 100 pennies are the same dollar: trade for equal pieces until one side matches the other. LHS is the left-hand side of the equals sign, RHS the right-hand side. A one-side chain rewrites only one side, LHS = step = step = RHS, with a reason at each step.

    Prove (1 − cos θ)(1 + cos θ) = sin2θ. Start on the LHS, the busier side. Multiply out, each part times each part: 1 + cos θ − cos θ − cos2θ = 1 − cos2θ, since the middle terms cancel (the difference of squares: (a − b)(a + b) = a2 − b2). Subtracting cos2θ from both sides of sin2θ + cos2θ = 1 gives 1 − cos2θ = sin2θ. So LHS = sin2θ = RHS.

    Check at 30°: (1 − 32)(1 + 32) = 1 − 34 = 14, and sin230° = (12)2 = 14. The check catches slips; the chain is the proof, since each step holds for every angle.

    2 Picture it

    sin2θ+cos2θ=1

    1−sin2θ=cos2θ

    1−cos2θ=sin2θ

    Reminder

    Reminder: Common denominators, Difference of squares, Nonzero cancellation, Root signs
    • Common denominators. 23 + 14 = 812 + 312 = 1112; multiply top and bottom to make equal bottoms.
    • Difference of squares. (1 + u)(1 − u) = 1 − u2 because the +u and −u terms cancel.
    • Nonzero cancellation. a×ba = b requires a ≠ 0. 7×37 = 3, while division by 0 has no value.
    • Root signs. x2 = 2125 gives x = ±215; an acute angle makes cosine positive.

    3 Why

    A one-side chain displays the reason for every equality, so a reader can follow it without assuming the desired conclusion. Working on both sides can also be valid if every step is reversible on the stated domain. But dividing by something that might be zero can discard cases, and reducing a claimed equation to a true statement does not prove it unless you justify reversing every step. Sine and cosine give all six functions a shared language. Then the Pythagorean identity replaces complicated squares with 1, or replaces 1 minus one square with the other.

    4 The rule

    For an acute angle, cosθ=1−sin2θ and tanθ=sinθ1−sin2θ.

    An identity holds on its common domain. Use sinθ≠0 when dividing by sinθ and cosθ≠0 when dividing by cosθ.

    The same idea, five ways

    Say it

    Say prove the identity: show that the two expressions agree for every allowed input.

    Write it

    A proof rewrites equal expressions on the original common domain.

    In math
    • LHS = expression = expression = RHS
    • cos θ ≠ 0 for tan θ and sec θ
    • sin θ ≠ 0 for cot θ and csc θ
    Like

    Exchange one payment for another of equal value, keeping track of each exchange.

    See it

    Start with LHS

    Rewrite with known equalities

    Arrive at RHS

    The same idea, other ways

    As exchanging money

    Five dollar bills and one five-dollar bill look different but have the same value. Rewrite an expression without changing its value, and give the reason for each exchange.

    sin2θ+cos2θ=1

    1−cos2θ=sin2θ

    As a chain of evidence

    LHS = expression = expression = RHS is a path whose links all have reasons. A matching final expression proves equality for every input on the stated domain.

    sec θ cos θ

    =1cosθcosθ

    = 1, with cos θ ≠ 0

    As a common language

    Replace sec with 1 over cosine, csc with 1 over sine, tangent with sine over cosine and cotangent with cosine over sine. Now all fractions use only two ingredients.

    tanθ=sinθcosθ

    cot θ = cosθsinθ

    sec θ = 1cosθ

    csc θ = 1sinθ

    Part 1: Rewrite using only one function

    The words in terms of mean use this ingredient and no other trig function. If sine is the ingredient, use the Pythagorean identity to replace cosine. An acute angle selects the positive root.

    • Rule: for 0° < θ < 90°, cos θ = 1−sin2θ.
    • Rule: for that same acute angle, tan θ = sinθ1−sin2θ.
    • Rule: for a general angle, solving a square gives both root signs until angle information selects one.

    cos2θ=1−sin2θ

    cos θ = 1−sin2θ, acute θ

    tanθ=sinθ1−sin2θ

    Worked example

    Use a fresh acute sine value

    θ is acute and sin θ = 25. Find cos θ and tan θ. In words, rebuild the missing cosine from the identity, then divide sine by cosine.

    Show the steps and the answer
    θ√2125
    The acute triangle gives a second route to the two ratios.
    1. cos2θ=1−425=2125.Subtract the squared sine from 1, written as 2525.
    2. cosθ=215.An acute cosine is positive; the principal root gives this value.
    3. tanθ=25÷215=221=22121.Use the quotient identity, cancel the shared bottom and rationalize.
    Answer
    • cosθ=215
    • tanθ=22121
    Double-check The squared sine and cosine are 425 and 2125, whose sum is 1.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Use only the positive square root for every angle.
    The identity fixes the square, not the sign; general angles need sign information.
    ✓ Instead: Use the positive root for an acute angle, and otherwise keep ± until the sign is established.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write the acute-angle condition next to the positive root.

    Part 2: Prove (verify) an identity

    Prove means show why the statement holds for every input where its original expressions have values. A chain from one side to the other makes each reason visible. You do not need to guess the angle.

    • Rule: rewrite using already established identities.
    • Rule: every cancelled denominator factor must be nonzero.
    • Strategy: a one-side chain is convenient; reversible two-side reasoning can also be valid when justified.

    sec θ cos θ

    =1cosθcosθ

    = 1, cos θ ≠ 0

    Worked example

    A one-flip proof

    Prove sec θ cos θ = 1 where cos θ ≠ 0. In words, show that cosine multiplied by its reciprocal gives 1.

    Show the steps and the answer

    cos θ ≠ 0

    1cosθ×cosθ=1

    1. secθcosθ=1cosθ×cosθ.The reciprocal identity is valid for cos θ ≠ 0.
    2. cosθcosθ=1.The same nonzero number divided by itself equals 1.
    Answer
    sec θ cos θ = 1 for cos θ ≠ 0.
    Double-check At 405°, sec θ = 2 and cos θ = 22, so their product is 1.

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: An undefined original side becomes defined after simplification.
    Simplification preserves values on the original domain, not outside it.
    ✓ Instead: Retain the original nonzero conditions.

    Tips and tricks

    • Write LHS at the start and RHS at the end of the chain.

    5 How

    1. State the allowed inputs before rewriting: tan and sec need cos θ ≠ 0; cot and csc need sin θ ≠ 0. A displayed fraction also needs its denominator nonzero.
    2. Pick the messier side, usually the one with more terms or fractions.
    3. Rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc using sin θ and cos θ.
    4. Combine fractions over a common denominator, or multiply out brackets.
    5. Replace 1 − sin2θ with cos2θ, 1 − cos2θ with sin2θ, and sin2θ + cos2θ with 1.
    6. Cancel common factors only when those factors are nonzero. Stop at the other side; preserve the original allowed inputs.

    Rewrite or prove without changing the domain

    1
    Does the question ask for one function in terms of another?
    YesIsolate that function with the identities; choose the root sign from the stated angle information.
    NoBuild a one-side proof chain.
    ↓
    2
    Does a denominator contain sine or cosine?
    YesRecord its nonzero requirement before proceeding.
    NoKeep checking any later introduced denominator.
    ↓
    3
    Do the fractions have different bottoms?
    YesUse their product as a common denominator when both are nonzero.
    NoCombine the tops.
    ↓
    4
    Do you see sin2θ + cos2θ, 1 − sin2θ or 1 − cos2θ?
    YesReplace with 1, cos2θ or sin2θ respectively.
    NoTry factoring or rewriting the remaining functions.
    1. Translate the question: rewriting changes the ingredients; proving establishes equality.
    2. Record all original nonzero denominators.
    3. Choose one side and rewrite all functions with sine and cosine.
    4. Combine fractions or expand brackets with a reason.
    5. Use the Pythagorean identity and cancel only nonzero factors.
    6. End at the requested expression and retain the domain restrictions.

    6 Worked example

    Worked example

    Prove sec θ − cos θ = sin θ tan θ

    Prove sec θ − cos θ = sin θ tan θ for cos θ ≠ 0. In words, rewrite the left expression until it becomes the right expression.

    Show the steps and the answer

    cos θ ≠ 0

    1−cos2θcosθ

    sin2θcosθ=sinθtanθ

    1. Work where cosθ≠0.Both sec θ and tan θ divide by cosine; this records the original domain before any cancellation.
    2. LHS =secθ−cosθ=1cosθ−cosθ.The left side has more pieces, so start there. Reciprocal identity: sec θ = 1cosθ.
    3. =1cosθ−cos2θcosθ=1−cos2θcosθ.cos θ ≠ 0 lets you multiply cosine by cosθcosθ, which equals 1. Match the bottoms, then subtract the tops.
    4. =sin2θcosθ.Pythagorean identity: 1 − cos2θ = sin2θ.
    5. =sinθ×sinθcosθ=sinθtanθ= RHS.Split sin2θ into sin θ × sin θ, and sinθcosθ = tan θ.
    Answer
    The left side turns into sin θ tan θ, the right side, so the identity holds wherever both sides are defined.
    Double-check At θ = 420°, the special-triangle work gives cos θ = 12, sec θ = 2, sin θ = 32 and tan θ = 3. Each side is 32. This numerical check catches errors; the algebra chain proves the identity.

    Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

    Try each rung before you open its steps.

    Rung 1 of 3

    Rearrange the identity

    Prove 1 − cos2θ = sin2θ. In words, isolate the sine square in the known identity.

    Show the steps and the answer

    sin2θ+cos2θ=1

    1−cos2θ=sin2θ

    1. sin2θ+cos2θ=1.This is the established Pythagorean identity.
    2. sin2θ=1−cos2θ.Subtract cos2θ from both sides of a known true equation.
    3. 1−cos2θ=sin2θ.Equality can be read in either order.
    Answer
    The identity holds for every real θ.
    Double-check At 405°, the two sides both equal 12.

    Rung 2 of 3

    One reciprocal and a cancellation

    Prove sec θ cos θ = 1 for cos θ ≠ 0. In words, replace secant with its definition.

    Show the steps and the answer

    cos θ ≠ 0

    cosθcosθ=1

    1. LHS =1cosθ×cosθ.Secant is reciprocal cosine on this domain.
    2. =cosθcosθ=1= RHS.The denominator and cancelled factor are nonzero.
    Answer
    The identity holds when cos θ ≠ 0.
    Double-check At 420°, 2 × 12 = 1.

    Rung 3 of 3

    Proving a difference of two tan fractions equals 2 csc θ

    Prove the identity tanθ1−cosθ − tanθ1+cosθ = 2 csc θ. Begin by stating the values of θ for which the identity is claimed, and give a reason for every cancellation you make.

    Show the steps and the answer
    1. State the allowed inputs. tanθ needs cosθ≠0. The denominators 1−cosθ and 1+cosθ must be nonzero, so cosθ≠1 and cosθ≠−1. Since sin2θ=1−cos2θ,cosθ=±1 exactly when sinθ=0, so this condition is sinθ≠0. cscθ also needs sinθ≠0. The identity is therefore claimed for all θ with sinθ≠0 and cosθ≠0, that is, θ is not a multiple of 90°.An identity holds only on its common domain. Every tan, every csc and every displayed denominator adds a condition, and these conditions are what make the later cancellation legal.
    2. Work on the left side, tanθ1−cosθ−tanθ1+cosθ, and aim for 2cscθ.The left side has two fractions and two tan terms, while the right side is a single term, so the left side is the messier side.
    3. Rewrite tanθ as sinθcosθ in both terms: tanθ1−cosθ=sinθcosθ·11−cosθ=sinθcosθ(1−cosθ), and in the same way tanθ1+cosθ=sinθcosθ(1+cosθ).Once the expression contains only sin θ and cos θ, the Pythagorean identity can act on it. Dividing sinθcosθ by 1 − cos θ multiplies the two denominators together.
    4. Use the common denominator cosθ(1−cosθ)(1+cosθ). Multiply the top and bottom of the first fraction by 1+cosθ, and the top and bottom of the second by 1−cosθ. The numerator becomes sinθ(1+cosθ)−sinθ(1−cosθ)=sinθ+sinθcosθ−sinθ+sinθcosθ=2sinθcosθ.Two fractions can be subtracted only over a shared denominator. Both denominators already contain cos θ and differ only in the factors 1 − cos θ and 1 + cos θ, which are nonzero on the domain.
    5. Multiply out the denominator: (1−cosθ)(1+cosθ)=1−cos2θ, so the left side is 2sinθcosθcosθ(1−cos2θ). Replace 1−cos2θ with sin2θ to get 2sinθcosθcosθsin2θ.(1 − cos θ)(1 + cos θ) is a difference of squares, and sin2θ + cos2θ = 1 rearranges to 1 − cos2θ = sin2θ.
    6. Write the denominator as sinθ·sinθcosθ and cancel the common factor sinθcosθ: 2sinθcosθsinθ·sinθcosθ=2sinθ.On the stated domain sin θ ≠ 0 and cos θ ≠ 0, so sin θ cos θ ≠ 0, and dividing the top and bottom by it is allowed.
    7. Rewrite 2sinθ=2·1sinθ=2cscθ. This is the right side, so stop. Conclude that the identity holds for all θ with sinθ≠0 and cosθ≠0.csc θ = 1sinθ. Keep the original allowed inputs: 2 csc θ on its own is also defined where cos θ = 0, but the left side is not defined there.
    Answer
    tanθ1−cosθ − tanθ1+cosθ = 2sinθcosθcosθsin2θ = 2sinθ = 2 csc θ. The identity is true for every θ with sin θ ≠ 0 and cos θ ≠ 0, that is, θ not a multiple of 90°.
    Double-check At θ = 60°, sin 60° = 32, cos 60° = 12 and tan 60° = 3. Left side: 3 ÷ 12 − 3 ÷ 32 = 23 − 233 = 433. Right side: 2 csc 60° = 2 · 23 = 43 = 433. The two sides match. At θ = 120°, cos 120° = −12 and tan 120° = −3. Left side: −3 ÷ 32 − (−3) ÷ 12 = −233 + 23 = 433, which equals 2 csc 120° = 433, so the identity also holds beyond acute angles. At θ = 90°, the right side is 2 csc 90° = 2, but tan 90° is undefined, so the left side is undefined. This confirms that cos θ ≠ 0 must stay in the domain.

    Work to write

    1. Domain: cos θ ≠ 0 (for tan θ) and sin θ ≠ 0 (for 1 − cos θ ≠ 0, 1 + cos θ ≠ 0 and csc θ), so θ is not a multiple of 90°
    2. LHS = sinθcosθ(1−cosθ) − sinθcosθ(1+cosθ)
    3. =sinθ(1+cosθ)−sinθ(1−cosθ)cosθ(1−cosθ)(1+cosθ)=2sinθcosθcosθ(1−cos2θ)
    4. = 2sinθcosθcosθsin2θ, using 1 − cos2θ = sin2θ
    5. = 2sinθ, cancelling sin θ cos θ ≠ 0
    6. = 2 csc θ = RHS, for all θ with sin θ ≠ 0 and cos θ ≠ 0

    Counterexamples

    What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

    ✗ Not this: Both sides agree at one angle, so the identity is proved.
    Different expressions can agree at one input: tan 45° = 1, while tan 30° = 33 ≠ 1. Agreement at 45° cannot prove tan θ = 1 for every allowed θ.
    ✓ Instead: Use an algebra chain for all allowed inputs; use one angle only to check.
    ✗ Not this: Cancelling cos θ makes sec θ cos θ = 1 valid even when cos θ = 0.
    The original secant is undefined when its denominator is zero. Cancellation cannot create new allowed inputs.
    ✓ Instead: State cos θ ≠ 0 and retain that restriction.
    ✗ Not this: Cancel sin θ from 1+sinθsinθ to get 1.
    The numerator is a sum, not a product with a common sine factor.
    ✓ Instead: For sin θ ≠ 0, split it into 1sinθ + 1 = csc θ + 1.

    Tips and tricks

    • Begin with the domain and a one-side chain. Put a reason beside every equality.
    • A product can lose a common factor; a sum must first be split or factored.
    • Try a permitted special angle after proving the identity. It can expose an arithmetic error.

    7 The trap

    Testing one angle and calling the identity proved. One angle can agree by coincidence; a proof needs algebra that works for every θ. Use a test angle only to check your algebra afterward.

    Keep in mind

    • LHS is everything left of the equals sign and RHS everything right of it: in tan θ · cos θ = sin θ, the LHS is tan θ · cos θ.
    • Cancel only factors (things multiplied), never terms (things added): sinθcosθcosθ = sin θ, but sinθ+cosθcosθ must be split into tan θ + 1.
    • "Respectively" means in the same order: sin2θ + cos2θ, 1 − sin2θ and 1 − cos2θ become 1, cos2θ and sin2θ, respectively.
    • One matching angle proves nothing: sin θ = cos θ holds at 45° but fails at 30°, so it is not an identity.

    Memory hook

    MSS: start on the Messy side, rewrite everything in Sine and cosine, Swap the squares (1 − cos2θ = sin2θ), and stop when it matches the other side.

    Flash cards

    Say the answer out loud, then flip.

    What do LHS and RHS mean?
    Left-hand side and right-hand side of the equals sign.
    What is a one-side proof chain?
    LHS = step = step = RHS: you rewrite only one side, with a reason for each step.
    What does "express cos θ in terms of sin θ" mean for an acute θ?
    Write cos θ using only sin θ: cos θ = 1−sin2θ.
    Simplify 1−sin2θcosθ, where cos θ ≠ 0.
    cos2θcosθ=cosθ
    Rewrite cot θ × sin θ in sine and cosine, then simplify (sin θ ≠ 0).
    cosθsinθ×sinθ=cosθ
    Both sides of an equation give the same number at 45°. Is it proved?
    No. One angle can match by luck. A proof needs an algebra chain that works for every allowed angle.

    Comes back in