Trigonometry / Trigonometric identities
Trigonometric identities
All 7 lessons, in order.
The unit at a glance
- What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
An equation is a question: for which angles do the two sides come out equal?
- The reciprocal and quotient identities
Every trig function can be built from two: sine and cosine.
- The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle
Picture a dog on a leash 1 meter long, tied to a post.
- Even and odd: what a negative angle does
Picture a tree at the edge of a still lake.
- Simplifying an expression step by step
Picture a jar of coins from four countries.
- Proving an identity by working on one side
Someone hands you a handful of coins, three quarters and five nickels, and says it is one dollar.
- The usual mistakes in a proof
Picture a friend who tells you every outfit looks great, even the shirt with a ketchup stain.
Rules (7)
- What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined. One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.
- The reciprocal and quotient identities
Reciprocal identities: csc t = , sec t = , cot t = ; flipped back, sin t = , cos t = , tan t = .
Quotient identities: tan t = and cot t = .
Each holds at every angle where both sides are defined. tan t and sec t are undefined (have no value) where cos t = 0: t = + kπ, which is 90° + k · 180°. csc t and cot t are undefined where sin t = 0: t = kπ, which is k · 180°. Here k is any integer: …, −2, −1, 0, 1, 2, … - The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle
t + t = 1 for every angle t.
1 + t = t for every angle t with cos t ≠ 0.
1 + t = t for every angle t with sin t ≠ 0. - Even and odd: what a negative angle does
cos(−t) = cos t and sin(−t) = −sin t for every angle t, and so tan(−t) = −tan t wherever cos t ≠ 0. These are identities. A function f is an even function when f(−t) = f(t), and an odd function when f(−t) = −f(t), for every t where f has a value: cosine is even; sine and tangent are odd.
- Simplifying an expression step by step
Simplify by replacing an expression, one step at a time, with a shorter one that has the same value. Each step is a named identity (reciprocal identity, quotient identity, Pythagorean identity, or the even function and odd function rules for a negative angle) or an algebra move that keeps the value (common bottom, multiply across, flip and multiply, factor, cancel a shared factor). The result equals the original at every angle where the original is defined.
- Proving an identity by working on one side
To prove an identity in this course, work on one side. Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by + or −) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here. - The usual mistakes in a proof
A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim. The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.
Recipes (7)
- What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
- Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.
- Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.
- Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.
- Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.
- If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.
- If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.
- The reciprocal and quotient identities
- Say what the question asks: which angle goes in, and which function's value must come out.
- Pick the identity: a flip of sine, cosine or tangent is a reciprocal identity; sine and cosine divided one by the other is a quotient identity.
- Write the function as a fraction in sin t and cos t: csc t = , sec t = , tan t = , cot t = .
- Look at the bottom. If it is 0 at your angle, the function is undefined there, and you are done.
- Otherwise put in the numbers from the point (cos t, sin t) and divide: multiply by the flip, cancel, and rationalize any square root left in the bottom.
- Check: multiply the answer by its partner at the same angle (sin with csc, cos with sec, tan with cot). The product must be 1. An answer of 0 is the one exception: its partner is undefined there, so check instead that the top of your fraction is 0 and the bottom is not.
- The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle
- Write the parent identity: t + t = 1.
- Choose what to divide by: t to reach tangent and secant, t to reach cotangent and cosecant.
- Set cos t (or sin t) equal to 0 to find the angles to throw out: cos t = 0 at 90° and 270°, sin t = 0 at 0° and 180°, and at every angle ending at those same points.
- Divide every term on both sides by the chosen amount, the 1 included.
- Split the left side into one fraction per term.
- Rename each fraction: a term over itself is 1, and each of the others is a quotient identity or a reciprocal identity, squared.
- Test the result at one angle where it should hold, such as 30° or 60°.
- Even and odd: what a negative angle does
- Look at the angle: a minus sign in front of it means the same size of turn in the other direction.
- Name the function in front of the angle.
- Cosine or secant: drop the minus, because they are even. cos(−t) becomes cos t.
- Sine, cosecant, tangent or cotangent: move the minus out in front of the function, because they are odd. sin(−t) becomes −sin t.
- If the function is squared or cubed, rewrite inside the parentheses first and apply the power after.
- Finish the work at the positive angle, then combine the signs: a minus times a minus is a plus.
- Check: add 360° to the negative angle (as many times as needed) and read the point at the new angle.
- Simplifying an expression step by step
- Say what the question asks: a shorter expression with the same value wherever the original is defined.
- Rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc in sine and cosine, and write quotient identity or reciprocal identity beside the line.
- If an angle is negative, swap cos(−t) for cos t (cosine is an even function) and sin(−t) for −sin t (sine is an odd function).
- Tidy the fractions: multiply straight across, flip and multiply to divide, and put added fractions over one bottom before adding the tops.
- Look for a Pythagorean pattern, such as t + t, 1 − t or 1 + t, swap it for its partner, and name the Pythagorean identity.
- Factor the top and the bottom, then cancel every factor they share.
- If a quotient or reciprocal is left, such as or , you may rename it tan t or csc t.
- Check: work out the start and your answer at one angle, such as 30° or 60°. They must give the same number.
- Proving an identity by working on one side
- Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
- Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.
- Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.
- Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.
- Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.
- Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.
- The usual mistakes in a proof
- Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.
- Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.
- Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.
- Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.
- Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.
- Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.
Traps (7)
- What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.
- The reciprocal and quotient identities
Matching by first letter. Secant starts with s like sine, so it is tempting to write sec t = . It is the other way round: secant is the flip of cosine, and cosecant is the flip of sine. Use the memory device each pair has one co (sine with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent), then test with a number: sec 0° must be = 1, while = has no value.
- The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle
Keeping only the positive square root. A Pythagorean identity gives the size of the missing value, not its sign. With sin t = and t in quadrant II, t = 1 − = , so cos t is or −; in quadrant II the point sits left of the y-axis, so cos t = −. After every square root, write both signs and let the quadrant choose.
- Even and odd: what a negative angle does
The most common slip is pulling the minus out of cosine: writing cos(−t) = −cos t. Only the odd functions (sine, cosecant, tangent, cotangent) carry the minus out in front. Cosine and secant are even and drop it, because the mirror across the x-axis never moves the x. Say cos keeps, sin flips before you write the next line.
- Simplifying an expression step by step
Canceling a term instead of a factor. You may cross out only a piece that multiplies the entire top and the entire bottom. In the cos t on top is added to sin t, so it does not cancel; the fraction splits into + = 1 + tan t. When the piece is in every term on top, factor first and then cancel: = = 1 + sin t.
- Proving an identity by working on one side
The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning t − t = 1 into t = 1 + t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.
- The usual mistakes in a proof
The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.
Lesson 1 of 7
What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 0
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
An equation is a question: for which angles do the two sides come out equal? Usually only some angles work. An identity is a different kind of claim. It says two calculations give the same number for every angle you put in, as long as both make sense at that angle. Think of clocks. A clock stopped at 3:00 matches the real time twice a day. That is like an equation. Two working clocks set to the same time match at every moment. That is like an identity. Now notice what one glance can tell you. If you glance once and the clocks disagree, they are not always the same. If you glance once and they agree, you may have caught the stopped clock at its lucky moment.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Sine and cosine on the unit circle, Special angle values, Full turns, Dividing by zero, Adding fractions with the same bottom, Multiplying fractions, What t means, Difference of squares and dividing out, Solving a one-step equation
- Sine and cosine on the unit circle. The point at angle t on the unit circle is (cos t, sin t): cosine is the x coordinate and sine is the y coordinate. At 90° the point is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1.
- Special angle values. sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1; sin 30° = and cos 30° = ; sin 45° = cos 45° = ; sin 60° = and cos 60° = . The point at 180° is (−1, 0), at 225° it is (−, −), and at 270° it is (0, −1).
- Full turns. Adding or taking away 360° lands on the same point of the unit circle: 450° = 90° + 360° lands where 90° does, and −90° = 270° − 360° lands where 270° does.
- Dividing by zero. A fraction whose bottom is 0 has no value. has no answer because no number times 0 is 6; has no single answer because every number times 0 is 0.
- Adding fractions with the same bottom. Add the tops and keep the bottom: + = , and + = = .
- Multiplying fractions. Multiply the tops and multiply the bottoms: · = , and · = = , because · = 2.
- What t means. t means (sin t: find sin t, then square it. At 30°, 30° = ( = and 30° = ( = . It does not mean the sine of .
- Difference of squares and dividing out. − = (a − b)(a + b) for any two numbers: − = 25 − 9 = 16 and (5 − 3)(5 + 3) = 2 · 8 = 16. A piece on both the top and the bottom divides out only when it is not 0: = 5 + 3 = 8.
- Solving a one-step equation. Do the same thing to both sides: in x + 3 = 7, take 3 from each side to get x = 4. Check by plugging in: 4 + 3 = 7.
3 Why
An identity is a promise about every angle. A promise about every case is broken by one case that fails: if a single angle makes the two sides different numbers, the claim is false. A case that works shows only that the promise held there. There are infinitely many angles, so you can never test them all one at a time. To show a claim is an identity you need a reason that covers every angle at once, such as an algebra rule that holds for all numbers. An angle where a side would divide by zero is left out: there is no number there to compare.
4 The rule
An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined.
One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.
The same idea, five ways
this is an identity, so the two sides are equal at every angle where both make sense. When the three-bar sign ≡ is used, read A ≡ B as A is identically equal to B.
An identity is an equation that is true at every angle where both of its sides are defined. An equation that is true at only some angles, also called a conditional equation, is not an identity.
- Left side = right side at every t where both sides are defined
- A ≡ B: some writers use three bars in place of = to mean equal for every value
- t − t = (sin t − cos t)(sin t + cos t), for every t
- = 1 for every t in {t | cos t ≠ 0}
- Graph words: the graphs of the two sides lie exactly on top of each other
Two working clocks set to the same time agree at every moment, like an identity. A stopped clock agrees with them only twice a day, like an equation that is true at only some angles.
The same idea, other ways
Draw each side as its own curve. For an identity the two curves lie exactly on top of each other: at every angle where both are defined they are at the same height. For an equation that is not an identity, the curves are apart at some angle where both are defined. They may still meet at other angles, and the angles where they meet are the ones that make the equation true. The curve y = sin t meets the flat line y = only twice in one turn, at 30° and 150°, so sin t = is an equation, not an identity.
A friend says a vending machine always gives the right change. You buy one snack and the change is right. Is your friend proved right? No: the next purchase could still go wrong. But if one purchase gives the wrong change, the claim that it always works is broken, however many purchases went fine before. A claimed trig identity is an always about every angle where both of its sides are defined. One angle where the sides differ breaks it. Each angle that works is like one purchase that went fine: good to see, but no guarantee.
Look at = x. At x = 0: = 0, and the right side is 0, so they agree. At x = 1: = 1, and the right side is 1, so they agree again. At x = 2: = 4, but the right side is 2, so they differ. Two yeses, then one no, and the no wins: = x is true at 0 and 1 but false at 2, so it is an equation, not an identity.
The claim says: at every allowed angle (every angle where both sides have a value), the left side equals the right side. The opposite of every angle works is at least one angle fails. So a single failing angle is exactly what it takes to make the claim false. To make it true by testing, you would have to check every angle, and there are infinitely many: 1°, 1.5°, 1.25°, and endlessly more between any two. No list of tests can finish, so a proof has to be a reason that covers all angles at once, like an algebra rule that works for every number.
One no is enough; a hundred yeses are not. Test angles are the tool for breaking a false claim. A reason that covers every angle is the tool for confirming a true one.
One no is enough.
A hundred yeses are not.
A test angle can break a claim.
Only a reason can confirm it.
| Claim | At 0° | At 90° | At 30° | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| sin t + cos t = 1 | 1 = 1 | 1 = 1 | Not an identity | |
| sin t · cos t = 0 | 0 = 0 | 0 = 0 | Not an identity | |
| 1 = 1 | Identity: the difference of squares rule works for all numbers | |||
| 1 = 1 | : undefined, left out | 1 = 1 | Identity where cos t ≠ 0 |
5 How
- Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.
- Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.
- Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.
- Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.
- If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.
- If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.
Testing a claimed identity
- Write the left side and the right side apart, so you work on each on its own.
- List the angles to leave out: those that make some bottom 0.
- Choose an allowed test angle with exact values; 30° and 60° are the safest.
- Work out each side exactly and compare the two numbers.
- Different numbers: the claim is not an identity, and you have a counterexample. Same numbers: no verdict; test again or look for a reason that covers every allowed angle.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Is sin t + cos t = 1 an identity?
Decide whether sin t + cos t = 1 is an identity. If it is not, give an angle that shows it.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: does the sine of an angle plus its cosine come to 1 at every angle, or only at some angles?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides are defined, so one angle where the sides differ settles the question.
- Look for angles to leave out. Neither side has a fraction, so no angle is left out.Here only a bottom equal to 0 could make a side undefined. Every angle lands on a point of the unit circle, so sin t and cos t always have values.
- Test . Left side: . Right side: 1. They agree.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), so cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0.
- Test . Left side: . Right side: 1. They agree again.The point at 90° is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1. Two agreements still prove nothing: infinitely many angles are unchecked, and at both of these angles one of the two numbers being added was 0.
- Test , where neither sine nor cosine is 0. Left side: .sin 30° = and cos 30° = . The two fractions have the same bottom, 2, so add the tops and keep the 2.
- Compare with the right side, 1. The fraction equals 1 only if its top equals its bottom: , that is, . But is the number that times itself gives 3, and , so is not 1. The sides differ. In decimals, , rounded.A fraction equals 1 exactly when its top and bottom are the same number. Both sides are defined at 30° and give different numbers, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Conclude: is not an identity. It is an equation that is true at some angles, such as and , and false at others, such as .One angle where both sides are defined and differ breaks a promise about every angle, however many angles agreed before it.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is ≈ 1.366 and the right side is 1.
- It holds at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, so it is an equation, not an identity.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 6
Rung 1: an identity and an equation with plain numbers
Which of these claims is an identity: that 4x − x always equals 3x, or that 2x + 7 always equals 1?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: for each claim, is it true for every number x, or only for some numbers?That is exactly the difference between an identity and an equation.
- Test at : left , right . Test it at : left , right . Both tests agree.Agreements are encouraging, but they cover two numbers out of infinitely many, so they prove nothing yet.
- Give a reason that covers every x: 4x means four copies of x, and taking one copy away leaves three copies, which is 3x. So is an identity.The reason never uses which number x is, so it works for all of them at once.
- Test at : left , right 1. They differ.One number where the sides differ shows the claim is not true for every x, so 2x + 7 = 1 is not an identity.
- Find where is true: take 7 from both sides, , then divide both sides by 2, . Plug it back in: .Taking the same amount from both sides, and dividing both sides by the same number, keeps them equal. This step finds the one number that makes the equation true, and plugging it back in shows that it works.
- 4x − x = 3x is an identity.
- 2x + 7 = 1 is an equation, true only at x = −3.
Rung 2 of 6
Rung 2: an identity with angles left out
Is = 1 an identity? Which angles are left out?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: at every angle where the fraction has a value, does the cosine divided by itself come out to 1?An identity only has to hold where both sides are defined.
- Find the angles where the bottom is 0, that is, where . Cosine is the x coordinate on the unit circle, and x is 0 on the vertical axis: in one turn, at and at .This finds the angles where the left side would divide by zero, so we can leave them out.
- Plug them back in: and , so at both angles the left side is , which has no value.The points there are (0, 1) and (0, −1). So 90°, 270°, and every angle that lands on the same points after full turns, such as 450° and −90°, are left out. Gotcha: they are not counterexamples, because there is nothing there to compare.
- At every other angle, cos t is a number that is not 0, and such a number divided by itself is 1.1 times the number gives the number back, so the number divided by itself is 1. This reason works for every allowed angle at once.
- Conclude: is an identity, with , and the angles a full turn from them left out.It holds at every angle where both sides are defined, which is what identity means.
- Yes, it is an identity.
- Left out: 90°, 270°, and every angle that lands on the same point after full turns, such as 450° and −90°.
Rung 3 of 6
Rung 3: one test angle breaks a claim
Is sin(2t) = 2 sin t an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the sine of a doubled angle always twice the sine of the angle?If one angle gives different values on the two sides, the answer is no.
- Look for angles to leave out: there are no fractions, so none.Sine has a value at every angle, since every angle lands on a point of the unit circle.
- Test . Left: . Right: . They agree.This settles nothing: one agreement never proves a promise about every angle.
- Test . Left: . Right: .On the left, double the angle first, inside the parentheses, then take the sine. On the right, take the sine first, then double. Gotcha: sin is not a number multiplying 2t, so the 2 cannot be moved out front.
- Compare: (rounded) and 1 are different numbers.Both sides are defined at 30° and differ, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is and the right side is 1.
Rung 4 of 6
Rung 4: four agreements, still false
Is sin t · cos t = 0 an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the sine of an angle times its cosine always 0?One angle where the product is not 0 will settle it.
- Test the four angles on the axes. At : . At : . At : . At : . All four agree with the right side, 0.At these angles the point sits on an axis, at (1, 0), (0, 1), (−1, 0) and (0, −1), so one coordinate is 0, and anything times 0 is 0.
- Notice why they agreed: at each of those angles one of the two numbers being multiplied was 0. That comes from the angles we picked, not from a reason that covers every angle.Gotcha: an agreement caused by a zero says nothing about the angles where neither sine nor cosine is 0.
- Test : .Multiply tops and multiply bottoms: 1 · = and 2 · 2 = 4.
- Compare: (rounded), which is not 0.A fraction is 0 only when its top is 0, and is not 0. Both sides are defined at 30°, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is and the right side is 0.
Rung 5 of 6
Rung 5: a true identity and its reason
Is (sin t + cos t = 1 + 2 sin t cos t an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the square of always the same number as 1 plus twice the product sin t cos t?An identity must hold at every allowed angle; there are no fractions here, so every angle is allowed.
- Test : left ; right . They agree.sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1; add first, then square, since the square sits outside the parentheses.
- Test t = 30°, left side: .Add the two fractions over the bottom 2, square top and bottom, and expand (1 + as + 2 · 1 · + (. Then split into + .
- Right side at : . The two sides agree.Multiply the tops, 2 · 1 · = 2, and the bottoms, 2 · 2 = 4, then reduce by 2.
- Agreement still proves nothing, so look for a reason. Write a for sin t and b for cos t. The left side is , and the refresher's says at every angle. So the left side is , the right side.The expansion of a square is true for any two numbers a and b, and the point (cos t, sin t) sits on the unit circle at every angle, so both facts hold at every angle at once: it is an identity.
Rung 6 of 6
Rung 6: a true identity with angles left out
Is = sin t + cos t an identity? Which angles are left out?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: wherever the fraction on the left has a value, does it always equal ?An identity only has to hold where both sides are defined.
- Find the angles where the bottom is 0: means , a point of the unit circle whose x and y are equal. In one turn that happens at and at .This finds the angles where the left side would divide by zero, so we can leave them out. At 45° both coordinates are ; at 225°, halfway around the circle from 45°, both are −.
- Plug them back in: at ; at .Both bottoms are 0, so 45°, 225°, and every angle that lands on those points after full turns are left out. Gotcha: they are not counterexamples, even though the right side has a value there; a counterexample needs both sides defined.
- Test an allowed angle, : left ; right . They agree.The point at 180° is (−1, 0), so sin 180° = 0 and cos 180° = −1. Agreement is good news, but still not a proof.
- Find a reason. The difference of squares rule, , is true for any two numbers a and b, and at every angle sin t and cos t are two numbers. So the top, t, equals at every angle, and the left side is .Two things that are equal at every angle can be swapped for each other, so the top can be replaced by the product.
- Divide out the piece , which sits on both the top and the bottom: , the right side.At every allowed angle that piece is a number that is not 0, and such a number divided by itself is 1, as with = 1 in rung 2. This reason covers every allowed angle at once, so the claim is an identity.
- Yes, it is an identity.
- Left out: 45°, 225°, and every angle that lands on the same point after full turns.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: one no is enough; a hundred yeses are not. A test angle can break a claim. Only a reason that covers every allowed angle can confirm one.
- Pick 30° or 60° as test angles: there sine and cosine are different, and neither is 0 or 1. At 0°, 90°, 180° and 270° one of them is 0, and a 0 can hide a difference: sin t · cos t = 0 agrees at all four and is still false.
- Be careful with 45°: sine and cosine are equal there, so a false claim that trades one for the other, such as sin t = cos t, passes the test. At 30° it fails, since is not .
- Before you compare, make sure both sides are defined at your test angle. If a bottom is 0 there, the angle is left out; pick another.
- If two decimals differ only in the last digit, suspect rounding, not a counterexample. For example, 2 · = is true, yet with rounded decimals 2 · 0.8660 = 1.7320 while ≈ 1.7321. Redo the test with exact values before you call a claim false.
- A graph that shows the two sides on top of each other is strong evidence, not proof: it shows many angles, never every angle.
- Why identities matter: the two sides are equal at every allowed angle, so you may swap one for the other anywhere. The rest of this unit uses that swap to rewrite things in simpler forms and to prove that two sides are the same.
7 The trap
Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
What does an identity claim that an ordinary equation does not?
- It claims the two sides are equal at every angle where both are defined, like two working clocks set to the same time.
- An ordinary equation usually holds only at some angles, like a stopped clock that is right twice a day.
When you check a claim with cos t in the bottom of a fraction, why do you leave out 90°?
The claim sin t = cos t is true at 45°. Is it an identity?
- No. The sides match at 45° only because sine and cosine are both there.
- At 30° the left side is but the right side is ≈ 0.866, so 30° is a counterexample.
A claim comes out true at ten different angles. Does that prove it is an identity?
Lesson 2 of 7
The reciprocal and quotient identities
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 1
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
1 In plain words
Every trig function can be built from two: sine and cosine. Picture an arcade sign that says 4 tokens for 1 dollar. A second sign could say 1 token costs of a dollar. Both signs give the same deal; the second is the first turned upside down. Turning a fraction upside down gives its reciprocal. Cosecant is sine turned upside down, secant is cosine turned upside down, and cotangent is tangent turned upside down. Tangent is a quotient, the result of a division: sine divided by cosine. Each of these facts, written as an equation, is a reciprocal identity or a quotient identity. One catch: whatever sits in the bottom of a fraction must not be 0.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: The point on the unit circle, What an identity is, Dividing by a fraction, Dividing by zero, Signs in multiplying and dividing, Reducing a fraction, Rationalizing a denominator, Radians and degrees, Squaring a fraction
- The point on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): first coordinate cosine, second coordinate sine, and + = 1. At 90° the point is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1.
- What an identity is. An identity is true at every angle where both sides are defined. One angle where it fails proves it false; one angle where it works proves nothing.
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 1 ÷ = 1 × = .
- Dividing by zero. Dividing by 0 has no answer: 6 ÷ 0 would need a number that gives 6 when multiplied by 0, and none does. A fraction with 0 in the bottom is undefined; a 0 on top is fine, = 0.
- Signs in multiplying and dividing. Same signs give a positive, different signs give a negative: ÷ (−) = × (−4) = −2, and (−3) × (−2) = 6.
- Reducing a fraction. Divide the top and the bottom by the same number: = after dividing both by 5.
- Rationalizing a denominator. Multiply the top and the bottom by the root in the bottom: = = .
- Radians and degrees. 180° = π, so 90° = , 270° = and 30° = .
- Squaring a fraction. Square the top and the bottom: ( = .
3 Why
On the unit circle all six trig functions are read from one point (x, y) at angle t: cos t = x, sin t = y, tan t = , csc t = , sec t = and cot t = . Write cos t in place of x and sin t in place of y, and the identities in the rule appear. Also is turned upside down, so cot t = . Each new function is undefined where its bottom is 0, because dividing by 0 has no answer.
4 The rule
Reciprocal identities: ; flipped back, .
Quotient identities: and .Each holds at every angle where both sides are defined. tan t and sec t are undefined (have no value) where : , which is . csc t and cot t are undefined where : , which is . Here k is any integer: …, , 0, 1, 2, …
The same idea, five ways
Cosecant is one over sine. Secant is one over cosine. Cotangent is one over tangent. Tangent is sine over cosine, and cotangent is cosine over sine. Read csc t out loud as cosecant of t (koh-SEE-kant), sec t as secant of t (SEE-kant), and cot t as cotangent of t (koh-TAN-jent).
At every angle t where the bottom is not zero, the cosecant of t equals 1 divided by the sine of t, the secant of t equals 1 divided by the cosine of t, the cotangent of t equals 1 divided by the tangent of t, the tangent of t equals the sine of t divided by the cosine of t, and the cotangent of t equals the cosine of t divided by the sine of t.
- csc t = , for sin t ≠ 0
- sec t = , for cos t ≠ 0
- cot t = , where tan t is defined and tan t ≠ 0
- tan t = , for cos t ≠ 0
- cot t = , for sin t ≠ 0
- sin t · csc t = 1, cos t · sec t = 1, tan t · cot t = 1
- Unit circle point (x, y): tan t = , csc t = , sec t = , cot t =
- Where tan t and sec t exist: {t | cos t ≠ 0}; where csc t and cot t exist: {t | sin t ≠ 0}
- Graph words: tan t and sec t break apart where the graph of cos t crosses 0; csc t and cot t break apart where the graph of sin t crosses 0
An arcade sign that says 4 tokens per dollar and one that says dollar per token describe one deal, flipped: that is a reciprocal. A ramp's steepness, its climb divided by its run, is a quotient, the way tangent is sine divided by cosine.
csc t =
sec t =
cot t =
cot t =
a bottom of 0 means undefined
The same idea, other ways
Stand at the point on the unit circle. Its x, how far it sits right of center (negative means left), is cos t. Its y, how far it sits above center (negative means below), is sin t. Secant is 1 over the x, cosecant is 1 over the y, tangent is the y over the x, and cotangent is the x over the y. When the point is straight up, at 90°, its x is 0, so the two functions with x in the bottom, tangent and secant, are undefined there.
A farm stand sells 3 pounds of apples for 1 dollar. The same price can be written as dollar per pound. Same deal, fraction flipped: know one and you know the other. A reciprocal identity says exactly this about angles: know sin t and you know csc t, the same number flipped. Now imagine free apples, 0 dollars a pound, and ask how many pounds 1 dollar buys. No number answers that. In the same way, flipping 0 has no answer, which is why every flip breaks where the number being flipped is 0.
Two short rules carry the whole lesson. First, each pair has one co: sine goes with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent. Second, the bottom decides where it breaks: tangent and secant have cosine in the bottom, so they are undefined where cosine is 0 (90° and 270° in one turn, and every angle a multiple of 180° away from them); cosecant and cotangent have sine in the bottom, so they are undefined where sine is 0 (0° and 180° in one turn, and every angle a multiple of 180° away from them).
sine and cosecant
cosine and secant
tangent and cotangent
one co in every pair
cos t in the bottom: tan t, sec t
sin t in the bottom: csc t, cot t
On the unit circle, sin t is the point's y, and csc t is defined as . Multiply them: y · = = 1 whenever y is not 0. Two numbers whose product is 1 are reciprocals, so sine and cosecant are reciprocals. The same steps work for cos t = x and sec t = , and for tan t = and cot t = , whose product is = 1. And since y is sin t and x is cos t, tan t = is the same as .
At 60° the point is (, ). So sec 60° = 1 ÷ = 2 and csc 60° = 1 ÷ = = . Tangent is ÷ = , and cotangent is ÷ = = . Each pair multiplies to 1: · 2 = 1 and · = = 1.
| Identity | Bottom | The right side has no value when | Those angles in degrees | Those angles in radians |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| csc t = | sin t | sin t = 0 | ||
| sec t = | cos t | cos t = 0 | ||
| cos t | cos t = 0 | |||
| cot t = | sin t | sin t = 0 | ||
| cot t = | tan t | tan t = 0, or tan t has no value | every multiple of 90°: …, 0°, 90°, 180°, 270°, … |
Part 1: Cosecant: the flip of sine
Sine is the height of the point on the unit circle. Cosecant is that height turned upside down: 1 divided by it. A height of gives a cosecant of 2, and a height of gives 3. Think of a cake cut so each slice is of it: flip and you learn the cake makes 8 slices. Because sine sits in the bottom, cosecant is undefined wherever the height is 0, where the point lies straight right or straight left of center, at 0°, 180° and 360°.
- Formula: csc t = ; flipped back, sin t =
- On the unit circle: csc t = , the flip of the point's height
- Undefined where sin t = 0: t = kπ, that is …, −180°, 0°, 180°, 360°, …
- Sign: always the same as the sign of sin t
- Size: csc t ≤ −1 or csc t ≥ 1; it is never strictly between −1 and 1
Worked example
Cosecant at 30° and at 180°
The point at 30° on the unit circle is (, ), and the point at 180° is (−1, 0). Find csc 30° and csc 180°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: two inputs, and ; for each, find the output of cosecant, or show there is none.Naming the inputs and the output first tells you to use csc t = twice.
- and .Sine is the second coordinate of each point.
- .Reciprocal identity; dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip, and the flip of is 2.
- , so is undefined.The bottom is 0, and no number times 0 gives 1, so dividing by 0 has no answer.
- csc 30° = 2
- csc 180° is undefined
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Cosecant copies sine at the top and bottom of the circle: where sine is 1 (at 90°) cosecant is 1, and where sine is −1 (at 270°) cosecant is −1.
Part 2: Secant: the flip of cosine
Cosine is how far the point on the unit circle sits to the right of center; a negative cosine means it sits to the left. Secant is that number turned upside down: 1 divided by it. A cosine of gives a secant of 2. Think of a car that covers mile each minute: flipped, that is 2 minutes for each mile. Because cosine sits in the bottom, secant is undefined wherever the point is straight up or straight down from center, at 90° and 270°, where cosine is 0.
- Formula: sec t = ; flipped back, cos t =
- On the unit circle: sec t = , the flip of the point's x
- Undefined where cos t = 0: t = + kπ, that is …, −90°, 90°, 270°, 450°, …
- Sign: always the same as the sign of cos t
- Size: sec t ≤ −1 or sec t ≥ 1; it is never strictly between −1 and 1
Worked example
Secant at 45°, and where secant breaks
The point at 45° on the unit circle is (, ). Find sec 45°. Then find every angle t from 0° to 360° where sec t is undefined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: first an output, the secant at the input ; then every input from to that has no output.Two jobs: evaluate at one angle, then hunt for the trouble spots.
- .Reciprocal identity; cos 45° is the first coordinate, ; dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip.
- .Rationalize: multiply top and bottom by , since · = 2; then the 2s cancel.
- Set the bottom equal to 0: .This finds the angles that would put 0 in the bottom of , so we can throw them out.
- cos t is the point's x, and only where the point is straight up or straight down: and .Going once around from 0° to 360°, the circle crosses the vertical axis at exactly these two places.
- Plug them back in: gives , and gives . Neither has a value.Seeing the 0 in each bottom confirms these two angles are the trouble spots.
- sec 45° =
- sec t is undefined at t = 90° and t = 270°
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Secant equals cosine only where cosine is 1 or −1: at 0°, at 180° and at the angles that land on those points after full turns. At every other angle where secant has a value, the flip pushes secant farther from 0 than cosine.
Part 3: Tangent: sine divided by cosine
Draw the line from the center of the unit circle out to the point. Tangent says how steep that line is: how far it climbs for each 1 it runs sideways. The climb is sine and the run is cosine, so tangent is sine divided by cosine. A ramp that climbs 1 foot over a 12 foot run has steepness . When the line stands straight up or straight down, at 90° and 270°, the run is 0; a wall has no steepness number, so tangent is undefined there.
- Formula: tan t =
- On the unit circle: tan t = , the climb over the run
- Undefined where cos t = 0: t = + kπ, that is …, −90°, 90°, 270°, 450°, …
- Equal to 0 where sin t = 0: t = kπ, that is …, −180°, 0°, 180°, 360°, …
- Sign: positive where sine and cosine share a sign, negative where their signs differ
Worked example
Tangent at 120°
The point at 120° on the unit circle is (−, ). Find tan 120°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is ; find the output of tangent.Tangent is a quotient, so both sine and cosine at 120° are needed.
- and .The point is (cos t, sin t): first coordinate cosine, second sine.
- .Quotient identity. The bottom is −, not 0, so the value exists.
- .Multiply by the flip of −, which is −2; a positive times a negative is negative; the 2s cancel.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Sign test: tangent is positive where the point's two coordinates share a sign (upper right, lower left) and negative where they differ (upper left, lower right).
Part 4: Cotangent: the flip of tangent, or cosine over sine
Cotangent is tangent turned upside down: the run of the line from the center divided by its climb. Read the ramp the other way: 12 feet of run for each foot of climb is a cotangent of 12. On the unit circle that is cosine divided by sine. The two formulas agree at almost every angle, with one catch. At 90° the point is straight up: tangent is undefined there, yet cosine over sine is = 0. So cot 90° = 0, and cosine over sine is the safe formula. Cotangent is undefined only where sine is 0, at 0°, 180° and 360°.
- Formula: cot t = , and cot t = wherever tan t is defined and not 0
- On the unit circle: cot t = , the run over the climb
- Undefined where sin t = 0: t = kπ, that is …, −180°, 0°, 180°, 360°, …
- Equal to 0 where cos t = 0: t = + kπ, that is …, −90°, 90°, 270°, …
- Sign: the same as the sign of tan t, wherever both have a value
Worked example
Cotangent at 135° and at 90°
The point at 135° on the unit circle is (−, ), and the point at 90° is (0, 1). Find cot 135° and cot 90°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: two inputs, and ; for each, find the output of cotangent.Naming the inputs first warns you that 90° is a multiple of 90°, where cosine over sine is the formula to use.
- .Quotient identity: cotangent is cosine over sine, and sin 135° = is not 0.
- .A number divided by itself is 1, and the minus sign stays.
- .The point at 90° is (0, 1), so the top is 0 and the bottom is 1. A 0 on top is fine; only a 0 in the bottom is trouble.
- cot 135° = −1
- cot 90° = 0
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Where one of tangent and cotangent is 0, the other is undefined: at 0° tangent is 0 and cotangent is undefined; at 90° tangent is undefined and cotangent is 0.
5 How
- Say what the question asks: which angle goes in, and which function's value must come out.
- Pick the identity: a flip of sine, cosine or tangent is a reciprocal identity; sine and cosine divided one by the other is a quotient identity.
- Write the function as a fraction in sin t and cos t: csc t = , sec t = , tan t = , cot t = .
- Look at the bottom. If it is 0 at your angle, the function is undefined there, and you are done.
- Otherwise put in the numbers from the point (cos t, sin t) and divide: multiply by the flip, cancel, and rationalize any square root left in the bottom.
- Check: multiply the answer by its partner at the same angle (sin with csc, cos with sec, tan with cot). The product must be 1. An answer of 0 is the one exception: its partner is undefined there, so check instead that the top of your fraction is 0 and the bottom is not.
Finding csc, sec, tan or cot at one angle
- Name the input angle and the function whose value you want.
- Get the point (cos t, sin t) for that angle from the unit circle, or read it from the question.
- Rewrite the function in sine and cosine with its reciprocal identity or quotient identity.
- Check the bottom: if it is 0 at this angle, the function is undefined there, and you are done.
- Otherwise divide: multiply by the flip of the bottom, cancel, and rationalize any square root left in the bottom.
- Check: multiply the answer by its partner function at the same angle; the product must be 1. If the answer is 0, its partner is undefined there, so check instead that the top of your fraction is 0 and the bottom is not.
6 Worked example
Worked example
All four values at 150°
The point on the unit circle at 150° is (−, ). Find tan 150°, csc 150°, sec 150° and cot 150° exactly.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is the angle , and four outputs are wanted, the values of tan, csc, sec and cot there.Naming the input and the outputs first tells you which identities to reach for.
- Read the point: and . Neither is 0.The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t). With no 0 in either possible bottom, all four values exist.
- .Quotient identity: tangent is sine over cosine. Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip; a positive times a negative is negative; then the 2s cancel.
- , so .Rationalize: multiplying top and bottom by keeps the value and clears the root from the bottom, since · = 3.
- .Reciprocal identity: cosecant is the flip of sine, and the flip of is 2.
- .Reciprocal identity: secant is the flip of cosine. The flip of − is −, and multiplying top and bottom by rationalizes it.
- .Quotient identity: cotangent is cosine over sine. Multiply by the flip of , which is 2, and the 2s cancel.
- csc 150° = 2
- sec 150° = −
- cot 150° = −
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
A flip of 1
The point at 90° on the unit circle is (0, 1). Find csc 90°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is ; find the output of cosecant.Cosecant is the flip of sine, so the only number needed is sin 90°.
- .Sine is the second coordinate of the point (0, 1).
- .Reciprocal identity; the bottom is 1, not 0, and 1 divided by 1 is 1.
Rung 2 of 7
A flip of a fraction
At some angle t, sin t = . Find csc t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the sine at some angle is given; find the cosecant at the same angle.The angle itself is never needed: csc t = uses only sin t.
- .Reciprocal identity.
- .Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip, and the flip of is .
Rung 3 of 7
Flipping back
At some angle t, sec t = −. Find cos t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: this time the secant is given; find the cosine at the same angle.The question runs the reciprocal identity in the other direction.
- .Reciprocals work both ways: if secant is the flip of cosine, then cosine is the flip of secant.
- .Multiply by the flip. The flip of − is −; flipping never changes the sign.
Rung 4 of 7
All four from a point
The point (, ) lies on the unit circle at some angle t. Find csc t, sec t, tan t and cot t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the point is given; find four outputs at its angle.The angle itself is never needed, only its cosine and sine, and the point gives both.
- Check the point: .Every point on the unit circle has + = 1, so this confirms the point really lies on it.
- and . Neither is 0.The point is (cos t, sin t), and bottoms that are not 0 mean all four values exist.
- and .Reciprocal identities: cosecant flips sine and secant flips cosine; dividing 1 by a fraction gives its flip.
- .Quotient identity, sine over cosine: multiply by the flip, then divide top and bottom by 5.
- .Quotient identity, cosine over sine: the same steps the other way up, then divide top and bottom by 5.
- csc t =
- sec t =
- cot t =
Rung 5 of 7
A square root in the bottom
The point at 30° on the unit circle is (, ). Find sec 30° exactly.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is ; find the output of secant as an exact number.Exact means fractions and roots, not a rounded decimal.
- .Reciprocal identity; cos 30° is the first coordinate, , which is not 0.
- .Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip.
- .Rationalize: multiplying top and bottom by keeps the value and turns the bottom into 3.
Rung 6 of 7
An angle where two have no value
The point at 270° on the unit circle is (0, −1). Find tan 270°, sec 270°, csc 270° and cot 270°, or say which ones are undefined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is ; for each of four functions, find the output or show there is none.At angles on the axes some bottoms are 0, so each function must be tested on its own.
- and .Read the point (0, −1): first coordinate cosine, second sine.
- , so is undefined.Quotient identity; the bottom is 0, and dividing by 0 has no answer.
- , so is undefined.Reciprocal identity with the same bottom, cos 270° = 0.
- .Reciprocal identity; the bottom is −1, not 0, and 1 divided by −1 is −1.
- .Quotient identity; a 0 on top is allowed, and 0 divided by any number that is not 0 is 0.
- tan 270° is undefined
- sec 270° is undefined
- csc 270° = −1
- cot 270° = 0
Rung 7 of 7
Radians, negatives and roots together
The point at t = on the unit circle is (−, −). Find csc t, sec t, tan t and cot t exactly.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is ; find four outputs there.Naming the input and the outputs tells you to use all four identities.
- .Since π = 180°, = 30°. Seeing 210° helps you picture the point down and to the left.
- and . Neither is 0.The point is (cos t, sin t), so all four values exist.
- .Reciprocal identity; the flip of − is −2.
- .Reciprocal identity; flip, then rationalize by multiplying top and bottom by .
- .Quotient identity; a negative times a negative is positive; cancel the 2s; rationalize.
- .Quotient identity, cosine over sine; negative times negative is positive, and the 2s cancel.
- csc = −2
- sec = −
- cot =
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: each pair has one co. Sine goes with cosecant, cosine goes with secant, tangent goes with cotangent.
- Check every answer by multiplying it by its partner at the same angle: the product must be 1. For example sin 30° · csc 30° = · 2 = 1. An answer of 0 is the one exception: cot 90° = = 0 is right, but its partner tan 90° is undefined, so there is no product to take.
- A function and its partner always share a sign, because flipping a fraction never changes its sign: if cos t is negative, sec t is negative too.
- Sine and cosine never go below −1 or above 1, so their flips never land strictly between −1 and 1: always csc t ≤ −1 or csc t ≥ 1, and the same for sec t. A secant of signals a mistake.
- Picture the trouble spots: tangent and secant break where the point is straight up or straight down (x = 0, at 90° and 270°); cosecant and cotangent break where it is straight right or straight left (y = 0, at 0° and 180°).
- Shortcut: when two fractions share a bottom, dividing them leaves the tops: ÷ = = , because the two 2s cancel after the flip.
- Most calculators have no csc, sec or cot key. For csc or sec, find sin or cos first, then press 1 ÷ that value. For cot, divide cos by sin: 1 ÷ tan gives the same number wherever tan has a value other than 0, but it fails at an angle such as 90°, where tan 90° is undefined and cot 90° = 0. The key marked is not cosecant: it turns a number back into an angle, a different job.
7 The trap
Matching by first letter. Secant starts with s like sine, so it is tempting to write sec t = . It is the other way round: secant is the flip of cosine, and cosecant is the flip of sine. Use the memory device each pair has one co (sine with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent), then test with a number: sec 0° must be = 1, while = has no value.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Is secant the reciprocal of sine or of cosine?
- Cosine: sec t = .
- Remember each pair has one co: sine with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent.
How do you write cot t using only sin t and cos t?
- cot t = . This is a quotient identity.
- Cotangent is tangent turned upside down. Since tan t = , the top and bottom trade places.
At which angles are tan t and sec t undefined, and why?
- Where cos t = 0: t = + kπ, which is 90° + k · 180°, for any integer k.
- Both have cos t in the bottom (tan t = and sec t = ), and dividing by 0 has no answer.
If sin 45° = , what is csc 45°?
- csc 45° = = 1 ÷ = , because dividing by a fraction means multiplying by its flip.
- Rationalize to clear the root from the bottom: × = = .
- Check: × = = 1.
Lesson 3 of 7
The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle
Open this lessonLeans on 1Comes back in 0
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
Picture a dog on a leash 1 meter long, tied to a post. With the leash tight, the dog stays on a circle. You can describe its spot with two walks from the post: so far east, then so far north (a walk west or south counts as negative). The two walks and the leash form a right triangle, so (east + (north = . On the unit circle the east walk is cos t and the north walk is sin t, so t + t = 1 for every angle t. This is the first Pythagorean identity. Divide it by t, or by t, and two more appear: one for tangent and secant, one for cotangent and cosecant.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: What an identity is, The point on the unit circle, Reciprocal and quotient identities, What t means, Squaring a fraction or a negative, Subtracting a fraction from 1, Square roots come in pairs, Square root of a fraction, Dividing both sides of an equation, Splitting a fraction whose top is a sum, Dividing by a fraction, Undoing a division, Signs by quadrant, Reference angle
- What an identity is. An identity is true at every angle where both sides are defined; one test angle can show a claim false but never prove it true. sin t = holds at 30° but fails at 0°, so it is an equation, not an identity.
- The point on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t), and every point on the unit circle obeys + = 1: at 90° the point is (0, 1), and + = 1.
- Reciprocal and quotient identities. From the previous lesson: tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t = .
- What t means. t is (sin t, the value of sine, squared: if sin t = , then t = .
- Squaring a fraction or a negative. Square the top and the bottom, and the minus sign disappears: (− = .
- Subtracting a fraction from 1. Write 1 over the same bottom first: 1 − = − = .
- Square roots come in pairs. = has two answers, and −, because both square to . The sign √ by itself means only the one that is 0 or more.
- Square root of a fraction. Take the root of the top and of the bottom: the square root of is , and the square root of is .
- Dividing both sides of an equation. Divide every term on both sides by the same amount, as long as it is not 0: 4x + 8 = 12 becomes x + 2 = 3.
- Splitting a fraction whose top is a sum. = + : = + = 2 + 3 = 5, the same as = 5.
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 1 ÷ = , and ÷ = × = .
- Undoing a division. Multiply both sides by the bottom: tan t = gives sin t = tan t × cos t, the way 3 = gives 6 = 3 × 2.
- Signs by quadrant. All Students Take Calculus: quadrant I all positive, II sine, III tangent, IV cosine (each with its reciprocal). At 120°, in quadrant II, sin is positive and cos is negative.
- Reference angle. The angle back to the x-axis gives each value's size: for 120° it is 180° − 120° = 60°, so sin 120° has the same size as sin 60°, .
3 Why
Every point on the unit circle is 1 unit from the center, so by the Pythagorean theorem every point (x, y) on it obeys + = 1. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t). Put cos t for x and sin t for y: t + t = 1. Nothing about t was special, so this holds for every angle, which makes it an identity. Dividing both sides of a true equation by the same nonzero amount keeps it true, so dividing by t or by t gives the other two forms, each true wherever the amount you divided by is not 0.
4 The rule
for every angle t.
for every angle t with . for every angle t with .
The same idea, five ways
sine squared t plus cosine squared t equals one.
For every angle t, the square of sin t plus the square of cos t is exactly 1.
- + = 1 at the point (cos t, sin t)
- 1 + t = t, where cos t ≠ 0
- 1 + t = t, where sin t ≠ 0
A dog on a leash 1 meter long: however it runs, (meters east + (meters north = , because the leash never changes length.
The same idea, other ways
Draw the unit circle and the point P at angle t. Drop a line from P straight to the x-axis. That makes a right triangle. The flat leg is as long as the size of cos t, the upright leg is as long as the size of sin t, and the slanted side is the radius, 1. The Pythagorean theorem on that triangle gives t + t = 1. In quadrants II, III and IV a leg points the negative way, but squaring removes the minus sign, so the result is the same.
A dog is tied to a post with a leash 1 meter long and runs around with the leash tight. At each moment you say where it is with two numbers: meters east of the post (negative if it is west) and meters north (negative if it is south). Both numbers keep changing, but the leash does not. So (east + (north = at every moment. Call the leash's angle t: then east is cos t and north is sin t.
At 0°: cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0, and + = 1. At 30°: ( + ( = + = 1. At 45°: ( + ( = + = 1. At 120°: (− + ( = + = 1. The two squares always share out exactly 1: when one grows, the other shrinks by the same amount.
Every point (x, y) on the unit circle obeys + = 1, because it sits 1 unit from the center. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): that is what cosine and sine mean on the unit circle. Put cos t in for x and sin t in for y, and the circle's equation becomes t + t = 1. The other two forms follow by dividing every term by t or by t, which is allowed wherever that amount is not 0.
Memorize one, rebuild two. The parent is t + t = 1. Divide every term by t for the tangent and secant identity, and by t for the cotangent and cosecant identity. Co goes with co. The square that stands alone, t or t, is the big one: it equals 1 plus a square, so it is never below 1.
÷ t: 1 + t = t
÷ t: 1 + t = t
co goes with co
| Identity | How you get it | Holds wherever | Rearranged | Quick check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| + = 1 at the point (cos t, sin t) | every angle t | at 0°: + = 1 | ||
| 1 + t = t | divide the first row by t | cos t ≠ 0 (not 90°, 270°, ...) | t = t − 1 | at 0°: 1 + = |
| 1 + t = t | divide the first row by t | sin t ≠ 0 (not 0°, 180°, ...) | t = t − 1 | at 90°: 1 + = |
Part 1: t + t = 1: the parent
This is the identity the other two grow from. The point on the unit circle at angle t has an east-west reading, cos t, and a north-south reading, sin t. Those readings are the legs of a right triangle whose slanted side, the hypotenuse, is the radius, 1. The Pythagorean theorem says le + le = hypotenus, so t + t = 1. A west or south reading is negative, but a square is never negative, so the rule works in all four quadrants.
- Formula: t + t = 1
- Where it comes from: the point (cos t, sin t) on the circle + = 1
- Holds for: every angle t, because sine and cosine exist at every angle
- Rearranged: t = 1 − t and t = 1 − t
- Size limit: neither square is ever more than 1, because the other square is never negative
- Quick check at 0°: sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1, so + = 1
Worked example
Check the parent identity at 120°
Check that t + t = 1 at t = 120°, using exact values.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find and , square each one, add, and see whether the total is 1.Checking an identity at one angle means working out the left side and comparing it with the right side.
- Find the values: is in quadrant II with reference angle , so and .The reference angle gives the size of each value; in quadrant II the point is above the x-axis (sine positive) and left of the y-axis (cosine negative).
- Square each value: and .Square the top and the bottom: ( = 3 and = 4. A negative times a negative is positive.
- Add: .The bottoms match, so add the tops: 3 + 1 = 4, and four fourths make one whole.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- The rearranged forms say the same fact: t = 1 − t and t = 1 − t.
- A quick reality check: sin t = is impossible, since ( = is already more than 1 and the other square cannot be negative.
Part 2: 1 + t = t: divide by t
Take the parent triangle and enlarge it, like zooming a photo, until the cos t side is exactly 1 long. To do that you divide every side by cos t. The sin t side becomes , which is tan t, and the slanted side becomes , which is sec t. A zoomed right triangle is still a right triangle, so + t = t. No zoom can turn a side of length 0 into a side of length 1, so this identity fails where cos t = 0.
- Formula: 1 + t = t
- Made by: dividing every term of t + t = 1 by t
- Holds for: every angle with cos t ≠ 0, so not at 90° (), 270° () or any angle ending at the top or bottom of the circle
- Rearranged: t = t − 1 and t − t = 1
- Size: t is 1 plus a square, so it is never less than 1
- Quick check at 0°: tan 0° = 0 and sec 0° = 1, so 1 + =
Worked example
Tangent to secant
tan t = and t is in quadrant I. Find sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the tangent; find the secant of the same angle. Tangent and secant sit together in .Pick the identity that holds the value you have and the one you want.
- Put in the known value: , so .t means (tan t; square the top and the bottom: = 9 and = 16.
- Add: , so .Write 1 as to share the bottom; 16 + 9 = 25.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: both square to . = 25 and = 16, and a negative squared is positive.
- Choose the sign: has the same sign as cos t, and cos t is positive in quadrant I. So .The quadrant, not the identity, decides the sign.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device, co goes with co: tangent and secant have no co, so they share an identity.
- Check at 0°: tan 0° = 0 and sec 0° = 1, so the identity reads 1 + 0 = 1.
Part 3: 1 + t = t: divide by t
Same trick, other leg. Enlarge the parent triangle until the sin t side is exactly 1 long: divide every side by sin t. The cos t side becomes , which is cot t, and the slanted side becomes , which is csc t. The Pythagorean theorem on the zoomed triangle gives t + = t, usually written 1 + t = t. This one fails where sin t = 0, at 0°, 180° and every angle ending on the x-axis.
- Formula: 1 + t = t
- Made by: dividing every term of t + t = 1 by t
- Holds for: every angle with sin t ≠ 0, so not at 0°, 180° (π) or any angle ending on the x-axis
- Rearranged: t = t − 1 and t − t = 1
- Size: t is 1 plus a square, so it is never less than 1
- Quick check at 90°: cot 90° = 0 and csc 90° = 1, so 1 + =
Worked example
Divide by t: the cotangent and cosecant identity
Divide t + t = 1 by t to get an identity that uses cotangent and cosecant, and say for which angles it holds.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: rewrite the parent identity with cotangent, cosecant and numbers only, and list the angles to leave out.Cotangent and cosecant both have sin t on the bottom, so dividing by t is the move that reaches them.
- Find the angles to leave out by setting . On the unit circle only at (1, 0) and , that is at and , and at every angle ending there (any multiple of ). Plug one in: , so .This finds the angles where dividing by t would mean dividing by 0, so we throw them out before dividing.
- For every other angle, divide both sides by : .Dividing both sides of a true equation by the same nonzero amount keeps it true; the 1 on the right is divided too.
- Split the left side: .A fraction whose top is a sum splits into one fraction per term over the same bottom.
- Rename each piece: , and .A nonzero amount over itself is 1; cot t = is the quotient identity; csc t = is the reciprocal identity; squaring a fraction squares its top and its bottom.
- Put the pieces together: .Each piece was renamed and nothing else changed.
- 1 + t = t
- It holds for every angle t with sin t ≠ 0: every angle except 0°, 180° and the other angles that end on the x-axis (any multiple of 180°, or any multiple of π in radians).
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device, co goes with co: cotangent and cosecant both start with co, so they share an identity.
- Check at 90°: cot 90° = = 0 and csc 90° = = 1, so the identity reads 1 + 0 = 1.
5 How
- Write the parent identity: t + t = 1.
- Choose what to divide by: t to reach tangent and secant, t to reach cotangent and cosecant.
- Set cos t (or sin t) equal to 0 to find the angles to throw out: cos t = 0 at 90° and 270°, sin t = 0 at 0° and 180°, and at every angle ending at those same points.
- Divide every term on both sides by the chosen amount, the 1 included.
- Split the left side into one fraction per term.
- Rename each fraction: a term over itself is 1, and each of the others is a quotient identity or a reciprocal identity, squared.
- Test the result at one angle where it should hold, such as 30° or 60°.
Finding one trigonometric value from another
- Say what you know, what you want, and which quadrant t is in.
- Pick the Pythagorean identity that holds both functions: sine with cosine, tangent with secant, cotangent with cosecant.
- Put the known value in and square it: top, bottom and sign.
- Get the unknown square alone by adding or subtracting the same amount on both sides.
- Take the square root and write both answers, the positive one and the negative one.
- Let the quadrant choose the sign, then put the values back into the identity to check.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Divide by t: the tangent and secant identity
Start from t + t = 1. Divide by t to get an identity that uses tangent and secant, and say for which angles it holds.
Show the steps and the answer
÷ t, every term, the 1 too
t + 1 = t
not where cos t = 0: 90°, 270°, ...
- Say what it asks: turn the sine and cosine identity into one written with tangent, secant and numbers only, and list the angles the new identity must leave out.Tangent and secant both have cos t on the bottom, which is why dividing by t is the move that reaches them.
- Write the starting identity: .It holds for every angle, from the point (cos t, sin t) on the unit circle.
- Find the angles to leave out by setting . On the unit circle only at the top point (0, 1) and the bottom point , that is at and , and at every angle that ends at those points ( plus any multiple of ). Plug one in: , so .We are about to divide by t, and dividing by 0 has no answer. This step finds the angles where the division is impossible, so we can throw them out first.
- For every other angle, divide both sides by : .Dividing both sides of a true equation by the same nonzero amount keeps it true. The 1 on the right gets divided too.
- Split the left side: .A fraction whose top is a sum splits into one fraction per term over the same bottom: adding fractions with a common denominator, run backwards.
- Rename the first fraction: .Squaring a fraction squares its top and its bottom, and tan t = is the quotient identity.
- Rename the second fraction: .Any amount other than 0 divided by itself is 1, and step 3 made sure t is not 0.
- Rename the right side: . = 1, so is the square of , and sec t = is the reciprocal identity.
- Put the pieces together: , usually written .Adding in either order gives the same sum.
- 1 + t = t
- It holds for every angle t with cos t ≠ 0: every angle except 90°, 270° and the other angles that end at the top or bottom of the circle (90° plus any multiple of 180°, or plus any multiple of π in radians).
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
Check the parent at 45°
Check that t + t = 1 at t = 45°.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find and , square each one, add, and see whether the total is 1.Checking at one angle means working out the left side and comparing it with 1.
- Read the values: and .At 45° the point sits exactly halfway between the two axes, so its two readings are equal; these are the special values for 45°.
- Square each one: .Square the top and the bottom: ( = 2 and = 4; then reduces to .
- Add: .Two halves make one whole.
Rung 2 of 7
Sine from cosine in quadrant I
cos t = and t is in quadrant I. Find sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the cosine; find the sine of the same angle. Sine and cosine sit together in .Choose the identity that holds both the value you have and the one you want.
- Put in the known value: , so .t means (cos t; square the top and the bottom: = 400 and = 841.
- Get alone: .Subtracting from both sides keeps the equation true, and writing 1 as gives a common bottom. This finds the size of the square, so a root can come next.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: and .Two numbers square to , one positive and one negative; the root of 441 is 21, since 21 · 21 = 441, and the root of 841 is 29.
- Choose the sign: in quadrant I every value is positive, so .The quadrant, not the identity, decides the sign.
Rung 3 of 7
The sign comes from the quadrant
sin t = and t is in quadrant II. Find cos t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the sine; find the cosine of the same angle, with the sign quadrant II allows.Sine and cosine sit together in t + t = 1.
- Put in the known value: , so .Square the top and the bottom: = 25 and = 169.
- Get alone: .Subtract from both sides, writing 1 as to share the bottom; 169 − 25 = 144.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: both square to . = 144 and = 169, and a negative squared is positive.
- Choose the sign: in quadrant II the point is left of the y-axis, so its x reading, cos t, is negative. .All Students Take Calculus: in quadrant II only sine (with its reciprocal) is positive.
Rung 4 of 7
A root that does not come out whole
cos t = − and t is in quadrant III. Find sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the cosine; find the sine of the same angle, with the sign quadrant III allows.Sine and cosine sit together in t + t = 1.
- Put in the known value: , so .Square the whole value, sign included: (−2 = 4 and = 9, and the minus sign is gone.
- Get alone: .Subtract from both sides, writing 1 as to share the bottom.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: .The root of a fraction is the root of the top over the root of the bottom, and the root of 9 is 3. No whole number squares to 5, so stays as it is.
- Choose the sign: in quadrant III the point is below the x-axis, so its y reading, sin t, is negative. .In quadrant III only tangent (with its reciprocal) is positive.
Rung 5 of 7
Tangent to secant in quadrant IV
tan t = − and t is in quadrant IV. Find sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the tangent; find the secant of the same angle. Tangent and secant sit together in .Co goes with co: the pair without co shares an identity.
- Put in the known value: , so .Square the top, the bottom and the sign: = 64 and = 225, and the minus sign is gone.
- Add: , so .Write 1 as to share the bottom; 225 + 64 = 289.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: and , so both square to .A positive number has a positive and a negative square root.
- Choose the sign: has the same sign as cos t, and cosine is positive in quadrant IV. So .In quadrant IV the point is right of the y-axis, so cos t > 0.
Rung 6 of 7
Cosecant to cotangent with the rearranged form
csc t = 2 and t is in quadrant II. Find cot t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you know the cosecant; find the cotangent of the same angle. Cotangent and cosecant sit together in .Co goes with co.
- Put in the known value: .t means (csc t, and = 4.
- Get alone: .Subtracting 1 from both sides keeps the equation true; this is the rearranged form t = t − 1.
- Take the square root: or . Plug back: and .No whole number squares to 3, so stays as it is.
- Choose the sign: , and in quadrant II cos t is negative while sin t is positive, so the fraction is negative. .A negative divided by a positive is negative.
Rung 7 of 7
One value, then three more
sin t = − and t is in quadrant III. Find cos t, tan t and sec t, then test them in 1 + t = t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: start from the sine, find the cosine with the parent identity, build tangent and secant from sine and cosine, and finally test the tangent and secant identity.Each new value is built from values already found, so the order matters.
- Find : , so . = 49 and = 625; subtract from both sides, writing 1 as .
- Take the root and pick the sign: or ; in quadrant III cosine is negative, so . Plug back: . = 576 and = 625; in quadrant III the point is left of the y-axis.
- Find .This is the quotient identity. Dividing by a fraction means multiplying by its flip, and a negative divided by a negative is positive.
- Find .This is the reciprocal identity; 1 divided by a fraction is that fraction flipped.
- Test . Left side: . Right side: . = 49, = 576 and = 625, so the two sides match.
- sec t = −
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Know t + t = 1 cold: it is the only one of the three to memorize. The other two rebuild in about ten seconds by dividing every term by t or by t, so understand them and rebuild them when needed.
- Memory device, co goes with co: cotangent pairs with cosecant, and tangent (no co) pairs with secant (no co).
- The square that stands alone is the big one: t = 1 + t and t = 1 + t, so neither is ever less than 1.
- Forgot where the 1 goes? Test an angle where something is 0: at 0°, tan 0° = 0 and sec 0° = 1, and 1 + 0 = 1 fits only 1 + t = t.
- Undoing a square gives two candidates whenever the square is not 0: = allows y = and y = −. Write both, then let the quadrant, or whatever else the problem says about the sign, choose.
- To check a value you found, put both values back into the identity you used, with exact fractions: for sine and cosine the two squares must add to exactly 1, for tangent and secant 1 + t must equal t, and for cotangent and cosecant 1 + t must equal t.
7 The trap
Keeping only the positive square root. A Pythagorean identity gives the size of the missing value, not its sign. With sin t = and t in quadrant II, t = 1 − = , so cos t is or −; in quadrant II the point sits left of the y-axis, so cos t = −. After every square root, write both signs and let the quadrant choose.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Why does the Pythagorean identity t + t = 1 hold for every angle t?
- The point for angle t on the unit circle is (cos t, sin t), and it always sits 1 unit from the center, like a dog at the end of a tight leash 1 meter long. The walk east, cos t, and the walk north, sin t, are the two short sides of a right triangle with the leash as the long side, so t + t = = 1.
- Squaring makes a walk west or south positive, so the equation holds in every quadrant.
Starting from t + t = 1, how do you reach the other two Pythagorean identities, and which angles does each one leave out?
- Divide every term, the 1 included, by t to get 1 + t = t. This leaves out every angle where cos t = 0, such as 90° and 270°.
- Divide every term, the 1 included, by t to get 1 + t = t. This leaves out every angle where sin t = 0, such as 0° and 180°.
- Those angles are thrown out because you cannot divide by 0.
If cos t = and t is in quadrant IV, what is sin t?
- From t + t = 1, t = 1 − = , so sin t is or −.
- In quadrant IV the point sits below the x-axis, a walk south, so sin t is negative.
What does each side of 1 + t = t equal at t = 30°?
- Each side equals 4.
- sin 30° = and cos 30° = , so cot 30° = ÷ = and csc 30° = 1 ÷ = 2.
- Left side: 1 + ( = 1 + 3 = 4. Right side: = 4.
From earlier
The reciprocal and quotient identities
Show answer
Remember each pair has one co: sine with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent.
The reciprocal and quotient identities
Show answer
Cotangent is tangent turned upside down. Since tan t = , the top and bottom trade places.
Lesson 4 of 7
Even and odd: what a negative angle does
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 0
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
Picture a tree at the edge of a still lake. Its reflection sits right under it: the same spot along the shore, but where the tree points up, the reflection points down. The unit circle has a lake too: the x-axis. Turn by an angle t, say 40°, from the positive x-axis and you reach a point above the axis. Turn by the same amount the other way, which is the negative angle −t, and you reach that point's reflection below the axis. A reflection keeps the left-right place and swaps up for down. Cosine is the left-right place (the x) and sine is the height (the y), so cosine stays the same and sine changes sign.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Negative angles, The point on the unit circle, Special-angle values, Quadrant and reference angle, Adding 360°, The quotient identity, The reciprocal identities, Signs in products and fractions, The opposite of a negative, Powers of a negative, Dividing by a fraction
- Negative angles. A minus sign on an angle turns the same amount the other way: 30° turns counterclockwise, −30° turns 30° clockwise.
- The point on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): the x is the cosine and the y is the sine. At 60° it is (, ).
- Special-angle values. sin 30° = and cos 30° = ; sin 45° = cos 45° = ; sin 60° = and cos 60° = ; sin 90° = 1 and cos 90° = 0.
- Quadrant and reference angle. 120° is in Quadrant II, 60° short of 180°, where x is negative, so cos 120° = −cos 60° = −. Likewise 210° is 30° past 180°, below the x-axis, so sin 210° = −sin 30° = −.
- Adding 360°. Adding a full turn ends on the same side: −60° + 360° = 300°, so −60° and 300° share one point on the circle.
- The quotient identity. tan t = , defined where cos t ≠ 0: tan 60° = ÷ = · 2 = .
- The reciprocal identities. sec t = , csc t = , cot t = = : csc 30° = 1 ÷ = 2.
- Signs in products and fractions. A minus times a plus is a minus and a minus times a minus is a plus: (−2)(3) = −6 and (−2)(−3) = 6. One minus in a fraction makes it negative: = −2.
- The opposite of a negative.
- Powers of a negative. (−a = and (−a = −: (−3 = 9, the same as , but (−2 = −8.
- Dividing by a fraction. Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip: 1 ÷ = 1 · 2 = 2, and ÷ = · = .
3 Why
The point for t is (cos t, sin t). Put a mirror on the x-axis. The starting side of every angle lies on the mirror, so it stays put, and the mirror turns counterclockwise into clockwise. So it carries the end of t onto the end of −t. It sends any point (x, y) to (x, −y), so the point for −t is (cos t, −sin t). By definition that same point is (cos(−t), sin(−t)). One point has one x and one y: cos(−t) = cos t and sin(−t) = −sin t. Tangent is sine over cosine, so only its top flips: tan(−t) = −tan t.
4 The rule
and for every angle t, and so wherever .
These are identities. A function f is an even function when , and an odd function when , for every t where f has a value: cosine is even; sine and tangent are odd.
The same idea, five ways
Cosine of negative t equals cosine of t. Sine of negative t equals negative sine of t. Tangent of negative t equals negative tangent of t.
Changing the sign of the angle leaves its cosine unchanged and changes the sign of its sine and of its tangent, so cosine is an even function and sine and tangent are odd functions.
- even function: f(−t) = f(t) for every t where f has a value
- odd function: f(−t) = −f(t) for every t where f has a value
- graph words: the graph of an even function is its own mirror image across the y-axis; the graph of an odd function lands on itself after a half turn about the origin
A tree at the edge of a still lake and its reflection: the same spot along the shore, but up becomes down. The shore is the x-axis, the spot along the shore is the cosine, and the height is the sine.
The same idea, other ways
Draw the unit circle and mark the point for t, here 40°, above the x-axis. Fold the paper along the x-axis. The point lands on the point for −t, below the axis. A fold along the x-axis moves points straight up or down, never sideways, so the x (the cosine) is unchanged. The point ends up as far below the axis as it was above it, so the y (the sine) keeps its size and changes its sign.
Two runners leave the easternmost point of a round track at the same moment and at the same speed, one counterclockwise and one clockwise. At every moment they are at the same east-west position (the same x, so the same cosine). They are also the same distance from the east-west line through the center, on opposite sides of it: while one is north of the line the other is south, and they cross it at the same moments (opposite y, so opposite sines). The first runner is at angle t, the second at −t.
The point (, ) is on the unit circle, because + = = 1. Call its angle t. Then cos t = , sin t = and tan t = ÷ = . Its mirror image below the x-axis is (, −), the point for −t. Read it off: cos(−t) = , the same; sin(−t) = −, the opposite; tan(−t) = (−) ÷ = −, the opposite.
Plot y = cos x. The height of the graph at the input −t equals its height at t, so the left half of the graph is the mirror image of the right half across the y-axis. Plot y = sin x. The height at −t is the opposite of the height at t, so turning the graph half a turn about the origin puts it back on itself. That is what an even function and an odd function look like.
Cos keeps, sin flips. Of the six functions, only cosine and its reciprocal, secant, are even: they drop the minus. The other four (sine, cosecant, tangent, cotangent) are odd: the minus moves out in front. A second device: Even = Echo, Odd = Opposite. An even function echoes the same value back at −t; an odd function hands back the opposite value.
| Function | At −t | Even or odd | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| cos | even | the mirror keeps the x | |
| sin | odd | the mirror flips the y | |
| tan | odd | : one minus | |
| sec | sec(−t) = sec t | even | : no minus |
| csc | csc(−t) = −csc t | odd | : one minus |
| cot | cot(−t) = −cot t | odd | : one minus |
Part 1: Cosine is even
Cosine is the x of the point: how far right or left of the center it sits. The mirror across the x-axis moves a point straight up or straight down, never sideways, so the x does not change. That makes cos(−t) = cos t for every angle t. A function that gives the same output at t and at −t is called an even function, so cosine is an even function. You can see it on the graph of y = cos x: fold the picture along the y-axis and the two halves match.
- Identity: cos(−t) = cos t
- Kind: even function, because its output at −t equals its output at t
- Graph: y = cos x is its own mirror image across the y-axis
- Holds for: every angle t, since cosine has a value at every angle
Worked example
Cos(−45°)
Find cos(−45°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a turn of clockwise. The output is the cosine, the x of the point.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Cosine is an even function: the mirror keeps the x.
- , so .That is the special-angle value for 45°, and an even function keeps it as it is.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- The x-leg of the point lies along the x-axis, right on the mirror, so the mirror leaves it alone: that is the whole reason cosine is even.
Part 2: Sine is odd
Sine is the y of the point: how far above or below the x-axis it sits. The mirror keeps that distance but swaps above for below, so the y keeps its size and changes its sign. That makes sin(−t) = −sin t for every angle t. A function whose output at −t is the opposite of its output at t is called an odd function, so sine is an odd function. On the graph of y = sin x, the height at −t is the height at t turned upside down.
- Identity: sin(−t) = −sin t
- Kind: odd function, because its output at −t is the opposite of its output at t
- Graph: y = sin x lands on itself after a half turn about the origin
- Holds for: every angle t, since sine has a value at every angle
Worked example
Sin(−30°)
Find sin(−30°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a turn of clockwise. The output is the sine, the y of the point.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Sine is an odd function: the mirror flips the sign of the y.
- , so .That is the special-angle value for 30°, with its sign flipped.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- An odd function that has a value at 0 must give 0 there, because f(0) = −f(0) leaves only 0. Sine passes: sin 0 = 0. Cosine gives cos 0 = 1, so it cannot be odd.
Part 3: Tangent is odd, because it is sine over cosine
Tangent needs no mirror argument of its own. It is sine divided by cosine, so it follows what those two do. At −t the top of the fraction, the sine, has changed sign, and the bottom, the cosine, has not. Changing the sign of the top alone changes the sign of the whole fraction, so tan(−t) = −tan t: the opposite of tan t, whatever sign tan t has. Tangent is an odd function, like sine. It has a value only where cos t ≠ 0, and since cos(−t) = cos t, an angle and its negative are always both allowed or both left out.
- Identity: tan(−t) = −tan t
- Reason: tan(−t) = = = −tan t
- Kind: odd function
- Holds for: every t with cos t ≠ 0, so not at 90°, −90°, 270° and so on (cos 90° = 0)
Worked example
Tan(−45°)
Find tan(−45°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is . The output is the tangent, the sine divided by the cosine.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Tangent is an odd function.
- , so .At 45° the sine and the cosine are equal, and a number divided by itself is 1.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Read the fraction : the minus sign on top moves out in front, so it is − = −tan t, the opposite of tan t. At 150°, where tan t is negative, −tan t is positive.
Part 4: Secant, cosecant and cotangent copy their partners
The last three functions are flips of the first three: secant is 1 over cosine, cosecant is 1 over sine, and cotangent is cosine over sine. Flipping a number never changes its sign: 1 over a positive number is positive, and 1 over a negative number is negative. So each one behaves like its partner. Secant is even, like cosine. Cosecant is odd, like sine. Cotangent is odd, like tangent, because its top stays and its bottom flips.
- sec(−t) = = = sec t, so secant is even
- csc(−t) = = = −csc t, so cosecant is odd
- cot(−t) = = = −cot t, so cotangent is odd
- Each holds wherever the function has a value: secant needs cos t ≠ 0; cosecant and cotangent need sin t ≠ 0
Even (cos keeps): cos(−t) = cos t, sec(−t) = sec t
Odd (sin flips): sin(−t) = −sin t, csc(−t) = −csc t
Odd: tan(−t) = −tan t, cot(−t) = −cot t
Worked example
Csc(−30°)
Find csc(−30°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is . The output is the cosecant, 1 over the sine.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Cosecant is an odd function, like sine.
- , so .The reciprocal identity gives csc 30° = , and dividing by is the same as multiplying by 2.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Flipping keeps the sign: 1 ÷ (−2) = − and 1 ÷ 2 = . So a reciprocal is even or odd exactly when its partner is.
5 How
- Look at the angle: a minus sign in front of it means the same size of turn in the other direction.
- Name the function in front of the angle.
- Cosine or secant: drop the minus, because they are even. cos(−t) becomes cos t.
- Sine, cosecant, tangent or cotangent: move the minus out in front of the function, because they are odd. sin(−t) becomes −sin t.
- If the function is squared or cubed, rewrite inside the parentheses first and apply the power after.
- Finish the work at the positive angle, then combine the signs: a minus times a minus is a plus.
- Check: add 360° to the negative angle (as many times as needed) and read the point at the new angle.
Getting rid of a negative angle
- Find every angle with a minus sign in front of it, such as −t or −60°.
- For each one, name the function that holds it.
- Even (cosine, secant): erase the minus inside.
- Odd (sine, cosecant, tangent, cotangent): erase the minus inside and write it in front of the function, in parentheses when something multiplies it.
- If a power sits on the function, rewrite inside the parentheses first, then apply the power.
- Clean up the signs: a minus times a minus is a plus.
- To decide whether a whole expression f(t) is even or odd, do the steps above on f(−t) and compare the result with f(t).
- Check with a test angle such as 30° or 60°, or by adding 360° as many times as needed and reading the point there.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Cosine, sine and tangent at −60°
Find the exact values of cos(−60°), sin(−60°) and tan(−60°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a turn of clockwise. Find three outputs there as exact numbers (fractions and roots, no decimals): the cosine (the x of the point), the sine (the y) and the tangent.Naming the input and the outputs first keeps you answering the question that was asked.
- .Cosine is an even function: the mirror across the x-axis keeps the x. The special-angle value is cos 60° = .
- .Sine is an odd function: the mirror flips the sign of the y. The special-angle value is sin 60° = .
- .The quotient identity says tangent is sine over cosine. Dividing by is multiplying by 2, and one minus sign makes the result negative.
- Compare with the odd rule for tangent: , the same value.tan 60° = , and tangent is odd, so tan(−60°) must be −. Two routes agreeing is a good sign.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
A quarter turn backwards
Find sin(−90°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a quarter turn clockwise. The output is the sine, the y of the point where the turn ends.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Sine is an odd function: the mirror across the x-axis flips the sign of the y.
- , so .A quarter turn counterclockwise ends at the top of the circle, (0, 1), whose y is 1.
Rung 2 of 7
Even does not mean positive
Find cos(−120°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a turn of clockwise. The output is the cosine, the x of the point.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Cosine is an even function: the mirror keeps the x.
- .120° ends in Quadrant II, 60° short of 180°, where x is negative, so its x is the x for 60° with a minus sign.
- So .An even function keeps the value exactly as it is, and this value was already negative. The minus comes from the quadrant, not from the rule.
Rung 3 of 7
Two minus signs meet
Find sin(−210°).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: the input is , a turn of clockwise. The output is the sine, the y of the point.Naming the input and the output first tells you what to look for.
- .Sine is an odd function.
- .210° is 30° past 180°, in Quadrant III below the x-axis, so its y is the y for 30° with a minus sign.
- .The opposite of a negative number is positive.
Rung 4 of 7
Values given, angle unknown
An angle t has sin t = and cos t = . Find sin(−t), cos(−t), tan(−t) and csc(−t).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: you do not know t itself, only its sine and cosine. Find four outputs at the input .The even and odd rules need only the values at t, not the angle.
- .Sine is an odd function.
- .Cosine is an even function.
- .The quotient identity, then dividing by is multiplying by its flip, ; the 37 on top and the 37 on the bottom cancel.
- .The reciprocal identity; 1 divided by a fraction is its flip, and the sign stays.
- csc(−t) = −
Rung 5 of 7
A negative angle inside a square
Rewrite (−t) + cos(−t) so that no negative angle is left.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: write an expression equal to this one for every t, with only t (never ) inside sin and cos.Knowing the goal tells you when to stop.
- Read as .The little 2 squares the value of the sine; it is shorthand, not a new function.
- .Sine is an odd function, so replace sin(−t) by −sin t inside the parentheses.
- t.A negative times a negative is positive, so the square erases the minus.
- .Cosine is an even function.
- Put the pieces together: .Each piece was replaced by something equal to it.
Rung 6 of 7
Even, odd or neither: a product
Is f(t) = sin t · cos t an even function, an odd function, or neither?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out and compare it with f(t). The same for every t means even; the opposite, , for every t means odd; anything else means neither.Those are the definitions of an even function and an odd function.
- .f(−t) means the same rule with −t put in wherever t was.
- .Sine is odd and cosine is even; a minus times a plus is a minus, and that minus can stand in front of the whole product.
- , so f is an odd function.sin t · cos t is f(t) itself, and this holds for every t.
Rung 7 of 7
Two odd functions multiplied
Is g(t) = tan t · sin t an even function, an odd function, or neither?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: work out and compare it with g(t), as in rung 6.The test is the same for any function.
- .Put −t in wherever t was.
- .Tangent and sine are both odd functions.
- .A minus times a minus is a plus: two odd functions multiplied give an even one.
- So g is an even function, wherever .g(−t) came out equal to g(t); where cos t = 0, for example at 90° (cos 90° = 0), tan t has no value, and then it has none at −t either.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: cos keeps, sin flips. Tangent is sine over cosine, so it flips too.
- Memory device: Even = Echo, Odd = Opposite. An even function echoes the same value back at −t; an odd function hands back the opposite.
- Check any negative angle a second way: add 360° as many times as needed to land on the same spot with a positive angle (−450° needs two: −450° + 720° = 270°), then read the x and the y of the point there.
- The quadrant chart agrees (All Students Take Calculus): the mirror swaps Quadrant I with IV and Quadrant II with III, and in each swap cosine keeps its sign while sine and tangent switch.
- There are two different mirrors. On the unit circle the mirror is the x-axis, because it carries the point for t to the point for −t. On the graph of y = cos x the mirror is the y-axis, because it carries the input t to the input −t.
- When you test a rewrite with one angle, use 30° or 60°, not 45°: at 45° sine and cosine are equal, so a swap of the two would slip through.
- Squares erase the minus and cubes keep it: (−t) = t, but (−t) = − t.
- The Pythagorean identity still holds at −t: (−t) + (−t) = (−sin t + t = t + t = 1.
- The rules do not care about units: in radians, cos(−) = cos = , the same as cos(−60°).
- The gaps are mirrored too: tan t has no value at 90° and none at −90°, so t and −t are always both allowed or both left out, and tan(−t) = −tan t never has a value on one side and none on the other.
7 The trap
The most common slip is pulling the minus out of cosine: writing cos(−t) = −cos t. Only the odd functions (sine, cosecant, tangent, cotangent) carry the minus out in front. Cosine and secant are even and drop it, because the mirror across the x-axis never moves the x. Say cos keeps, sin flips before you write the next line.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Why is cos(−t) = cos t and not −cos t?
Which of the six trig functions are even, and which are odd?
- Even functions: cosine and secant. The minus drops: cos(−t) = cos t.
- Odd functions: sine, cosecant, tangent and cotangent. The minus moves out in front: sin(−t) = −sin t.
Why is tan(−t) = −tan t?
Rewrite (−t) and (−t) in terms of sin t.
- Rewrite sin(−t) as −sin t first, then apply the power: two minuses multiply to a plus, three leave a minus.
Lesson 5 of 7
Simplifying an expression step by step
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 0
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
Picture a jar of coins from four countries. You cannot count it as it is. So you change every coin into dollars, add them up, and trade each stack of 100 pennies for one dollar bill. The amount never changes; the pile gets smaller. Simplifying a trig expression works the same way. Sine and cosine are the dollars: you change tan, cot, sec and csc into sine and cosine. You put fractions over one bottom and add. You trade t + t, a stack worth exactly 1, for the number 1. You cross out a piece that multiplies the whole top and the whole bottom. Beside each trade you write the exchange rate you used. In trig, that rate is an identity.
2 Picture it
Some Cats Prefer Cream
S, sine and cosine: rewrite tan, cot, sec and csc
C, combine: one bottom, then add the tops
P, Pythagorean swap: t + t = 1 and its forms
C, cancel: factor first, then cross out shared factors
Name the identity beside every line
Check: start and answer agree at 30° or 60°
Reminder
Reminder: A fraction bar means divide, Multiplying fractions, Dividing fractions, Adding fractions, Canceling, Powers of sine and cosine, Factoring, Distributing, A negative squared, Special angle values, What one test angle can do
- A fraction bar means divide. = 6 ÷ 3 = 2, so a big fraction is its top divided by its bottom.
- Multiplying fractions. Multiply the tops and multiply the bottoms: · = . Anything without a bottom counts as over 1: cos t = .
- Dividing fractions. Flip the second fraction and multiply: ÷ = · = = . Dividing by sin t is multiplying by .
- Adding fractions. Give them one bottom, then add the tops: + = + = .
- Canceling. Cancel only a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom: = = . But = , not 3.
- Powers of sine and cosine. t means (sin t = sin t · sin t, and t means sin t · sin t · sin t. So = sin t, because one sin t cancels.
- Factoring. Pull out a common factor: 2 − 2 t = 2(1 − t). Difference of squares: − = (a − b)(a + b), so 1 − t = (1 − cos t)(1 + cos t).
- Distributing. A number in front of parentheses multiplies each term inside: 3(1 + sin t) = 3 + 3 sin t, the way 3(1 + 4) = 3 + 12 = 15.
- A negative squared. A negative times a negative is positive: (−3 = 9, so (−sin t = t.
- Special angle values. sin 30° = and cos 30° = ; sin 45° = cos 45° = ; sin 60° = and cos 60° = .
- What one test angle can do. A test angle can catch a mistake but cannot prove an answer: different numbers mean an error; equal numbers are only a good sign.
3 Why
Every step swaps a piece for something equal to it at every angle where both make sense. An identity promises exactly that, and the algebra moves, such as a common bottom or canceling a shared factor, keep the value too. So the last line equals the first wherever every line is defined. Rewriting in sine and cosine leaves out no angle: tan t and have no value at exactly the same angles. Some swaps do leave one out: cot 90° = 0, but has no value at 90°. Trade cot t for instead, or check a lost angle on its own; then the last line equals the first wherever the first is defined. Why sine and cosine? The other four functions are built from them: tan t is and sec t is . In the same two pieces, parts that looked unrelated can be added, matched and canceled. Naming each identity lets anyone check each swap.
4 The rule
Simplify by replacing an expression, one step at a time, with a shorter one that has the same value.
Each step is a named identity (reciprocal identity, quotient identity, Pythagorean identity, or the even function and odd function rules for a negative angle) or an algebra move that keeps the value (common bottom, multiply across, flip and multiply, factor, cancel a shared factor). The result equals the original at every angle where the original is defined.
The same idea, five ways
tan t times cos t simplifies to sin t, meaning the short form has the same value as the long form at every angle where the long form makes sense. Read t aloud as sine squared of t.
Simplifying a trig expression means rewriting it, one named identity or algebra move at a time, as a shorter expression with the same value at every angle where the original is defined.
- tan t · cos t = sin t, for cos t ≠ 0
- tan t · cos t = · cos t (quotient identity) = sin t (cancel cos t)
- = (Pythagorean identity) = sin t (cancel sin t), for sin t ≠ 0
Changing a jar of mixed coins into dollars and trading each 100 pennies for a dollar bill: the same amount of money in fewer pieces.
The same idea, other ways
A recipe asks for 1 cup, 4 tablespoons and 6 teaspoons of sugar. To see how much that is, you turn everything into teaspoons with two kitchen facts, 1 cup = 48 teaspoons and 1 tablespoon = 3 teaspoons: 48 + 12 + 6 = 66 teaspoons. Then you write it in the biggest units you can: 1 cup and 6 tablespoons, since 48 + 18 = 66. Trig works the same way: teaspoons are sine and cosine, the kitchen facts are the identities, and the last regrouping is renaming, such as writing as tan t.
Every trig function is made from the two coordinates of one point on the unit circle: cos t across and sin t up, each negative when the point is left of the center or below it. Tan t is up over across, sec t is 1 over across, and csc t is 1 over up, each wherever its bottom is not 0. Because everything is built from the same two numbers, writing it all in those two numbers lets pieces that looked unrelated meet, combine and cancel.
Simplifying to drops the shared factor 2 and keeps the amount. Trig simplifying does the same. At t = 60°, the long form tan t · cos t is · = , and the short form sin t is sin 60° = too: one number, written two ways.
Stuck? Put everything in sine and cosine. Then hunt for a hidden 1: t + t, sin t · csc t, cos t · sec t and tan t · cot t all equal 1 wherever they are defined. Then factor and cancel. You are done when the expression is in the form the task asks for, or when none of these moves makes it shorter.
Each line equals the line before it, because the step used an identity, which holds at every angle where both sides make sense, or an algebra move that keeps the value, such as multiplying top and bottom by the same nonzero thing. A chain of equal links makes the last line equal to the first wherever every line is defined. That is why the short answer can stand in for the long expression at those angles; if a step leaves out an angle where the long expression is defined, that angle is checked on its own.
| You see | Swap it for | Name it |
|---|---|---|
| tan t | quotient identity | |
| cot t | quotient identity (tan t flipped) | |
| sec t | reciprocal identity | |
| csc t | reciprocal identity | |
| 1 | Pythagorean identity | |
| Pythagorean identity, t subtracted from both sides | ||
| Pythagorean identity, t subtracted from both sides | ||
| t | Pythagorean identity, divided by t | |
| 1 + t | t | Pythagorean identity, divided by t |
| t − 1 | Pythagorean identity, 1 subtracted from both sides | |
| t − 1 | t | Pythagorean identity, 1 subtracted from both sides |
| cos t | cosine is an even function | |
| sine is an odd function | ||
| tangent is an odd function |
Part 1: Move 1: everything in sine and cosine
Think of a sentence that mixes four languages. Before you can shorten it, you translate every word into one language. Trig expressions mix six functions, but four of them are fractions made from the other two: tan t, cot t, sec t and csc t are all built from sin t and cos t. Translating them into sine and cosine puts every piece in the same language, so pieces that looked unrelated can be compared, combined and canceled.
- Formulas: tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t =
- Names: the first two each use a quotient identity; the last two each use a reciprocal identity
- Memory cue: in each reciprocal pair exactly one full name starts with co: sine and cosecant, cosine and secant, tangent and cotangent
- Use it when: the expression has a tan, cot, sec or csc and no faster swap is in sight
- Gotcha: sec t goes with cos t, even though sec starts with s
cot t =
sec t =
csc t =
sine and cosecant, cosine and secant, tangent and cotangent
exactly one name in each pair starts with co
Worked example
Translate, then cancel
Simplify 4 cot t · sin t, that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever cot t is defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Rewrite cot t as : .Quotient identity: cot t = , the flip of tan t = .
- Multiply: .4 and sin t count as and ; multiplying fractions multiplies the tops and multiplies the bottoms.
- Cancel sin t: 4 cos t.sin t multiplies the whole top and is the whole bottom, so = 1.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- A function times its reciprocal is 1 wherever both are defined: sin t · csc t = 1 and cos t · sec t = 1.
Part 2: Move 2: one bottom for fractions
To add and , you cut both into sixths first, because pieces of different sizes cannot be counted together. Trig fractions work the same way. If the bottoms are sin t and cos t, the shared bottom is their product, sin t · cos t. Rewrite each fraction over it, then add or subtract the tops. Multiplying and dividing need no shared bottom: multiply straight across, and to divide, flip the second fraction and multiply.
- Same bottom: + = ; the bottom stays
- Different bottoms: use their product as the shared bottom, such as sin t · cos t
- Multiply: tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms
- Divide: flip the second fraction and multiply
- Name it: these are algebra moves, so write common bottom, multiply across, or flip and multiply as the reason
- Gotcha: never add the bottoms
Worked example
Two bottoms become one
Write + as a single fraction, that is, as one top over one bottom with the same value wherever both fractions are defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Choose the shared bottom .Each bottom fits into it: sin t · cos t is sin t times cos t, the way 6 is 2 times 3.
- Rewrite the first fraction: .Multiply its top and bottom by the missing factor cos t; that is multiplying by = 1, so the value stays.
- Rewrite the second fraction: .Multiply its top and bottom by the missing factor sin t, which again multiplies by 1.
- Add the tops: .The bottoms now match, so the tops add and the bottom stays.
- Look for a factor to cancel: there is none.The top is a sum, and neither sin t nor cos t multiplies the whole top, so nothing on top matches a factor of the bottom.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- The shared bottom of two different bottoms is their product; check that each old bottom fits into it.
Part 3: Move 3: swap a Pythagorean pattern
You met t + t = 1 on the unit circle. In simplifying it works like trading 100 pennies for one dollar bill: wherever you see the two pieces t + t, you may trade them for the single number 1, and you may trade back when that helps. Its rearranged forms are trades too: 1 − t for t, 1 − t for t, and 1 + t for t. The cues: a 1 next to a trig square, or t and t added together.
- Formula: t + t = 1
- Rearranged: 1 − t = t and 1 − t = t
- Divided by t: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t
- Divided by t: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t
- Name it: Pythagorean identity
- Gotcha: it is about squares; sin t + cos t = 1 is not an identity (at 45° the sum is , about 1.41)
Worked example
Two swaps in a row
Simplify t + t + t, that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever tan t is defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Group the first two terms: .Grouping an addition differently does not change the total, and this grouping shows the Pythagorean pattern.
- Swap for 1: .Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
- Swap for .Pythagorean identity divided by t: 1 + t = t.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Every Pythagorean swap works in both directions: t may become 1 − t when that sets up a cancel.
Part 4: Move 4: factor, then cancel
shrinks to because 2 multiplies both the top and the bottom: . You may cross out a piece only when it multiplies the entire top and the entire bottom. In trig fractions the shared piece often hides inside a sum or a difference of squares, so you factor first to bring it into the open, then cancel. A piece that is only added on top, as in , cannot be crossed out.
- Rule: = when a ≠ 0 and c ≠ 0
- Common factor: t − sin t = sin t(sin t − 1)
- Difference of squares: t − 1 = (sin t − 1)(sin t + 1)
- Powers: = = cos t, where cos t ≠ 0
- Name it: write factor, then cancel the common factor, as the reasons
- Gotcha: a term that is added cannot be canceled
Worked example
Factor to find the shared piece
Simplify , that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever the bottom is not 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Factor the top as a difference of squares: . − = (a − b)(a + b) with a = sin t and b = 1, since 1 = .
- Rewrite the fraction: .Replacing the top with an equal product keeps the value, and now the shared piece is in the open.
- Cancel the factor : .sin t − 1 multiplies the whole top and is the whole bottom, so it divides to 1. Where the original is defined, sin t − 1 is not 0, since it is the original bottom.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Test any cancel with small numbers first: is 5, but is , not 5.
5 How
- Say what the question asks: a shorter expression with the same value wherever the original is defined.
- Rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc in sine and cosine, and write quotient identity or reciprocal identity beside the line.
- If an angle is negative, swap cos(−t) for cos t (cosine is an even function) and sin(−t) for −sin t (sine is an odd function).
- Tidy the fractions: multiply straight across, flip and multiply to divide, and put added fractions over one bottom before adding the tops.
- Look for a Pythagorean pattern, such as t + t, 1 − t or 1 + t, swap it for its partner, and name the Pythagorean identity.
- Factor the top and the bottom, then cancel every factor they share.
- If a quotient or reciprocal is left, such as or , you may rename it tan t or csc t.
- Check: work out the start and your answer at one angle, such as 30° or 60°. They must give the same number.
Simplifying a trig expression
- Sine and cosine (S): rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc with a quotient identity or a reciprocal identity.
- Combine (C): multiply, divide, add or subtract fractions until one fraction is left.
- Pythagorean swap (P): trade any Pythagorean pattern for its partner.
- Cancel (C): factor the top and the bottom, then cross out each factor they share.
- Finish: rename a leftover quotient or reciprocal if that makes it shorter, then check at one angle.
6 Worked example
Worked example
All four moves in one problem
Simplify , naming the identity used at each step.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what is asked: find the shortest expression with the same value as at every angle where it is defined.Knowing the goal tells you when to stop: when nothing more can be rewritten, combined, swapped or canceled.
- Rewrite csc t and cot t in sine and cosine, reading the big fraction bar as divided by: .Reciprocal identity: csc t = , so 2 csc t = . Quotient identity: cot t = . A fraction bar means divide.
- Give 2 sin t the bottom sin t: .Fractions are subtracted over one bottom. Multiplying top and bottom by sin t multiplies by = 1, and sin t · sin t = t.
- Subtract the tops: .With one bottom, the tops combine and the bottom stays.
- Factor 2 out of the top: .Both terms on top, 2 and 2 t, share the factor 2, and pulling it out shows the pattern 1 − t.
- Swap for : .Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1; subtracting t from both sides gives 1 − t = t.
- Divide by by flipping it and multiplying: .Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip; then multiply tops together and bottoms together.
- Cancel sin t and one cos t: .t is cos t · cos t. The factors sin t and cos t each multiply the whole top and the whole bottom, so each pair divides to 1.
- Say where the answer holds: wherever and .The original needs sin t ≠ 0 for csc t and cot t, and it needs cot t ≠ 0, that is cos t ≠ 0, because cot t is its bottom. At all those angles every swap kept the value.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
Rung 1: one swap, one cancel
Simplify 6 sin t · csc t, that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever csc t is defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Rewrite csc t as : .Reciprocal identity: csc t = .
- Multiply: .6 sin t counts as ; multiplying fractions multiplies the tops and multiplies the bottoms.
- Cancel sin t: 6.sin t multiplies the whole top and is the whole bottom, so = 1.
Rung 2 of 7
Rung 2: factor, swap, cancel
Simplify , that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever sin t ≠ 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Factor 5 out of the top: .Both terms on top, 5 and 5 t, share the factor 5.
- Swap for : .Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1; subtracting t from both sides gives 1 − t = t.
- Cancel one sin t: 5 sin t.t is sin t · sin t; one of those factors cancels with the sin t on the bottom.
Rung 3 of 7
Rung 3: a negative angle
Simplify , that is, find a shorter expression in t with the same value wherever the bottom is not 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Read as , then swap for : .The small 2 squares the whole value sin(−t). Sine is an odd function: sin(−t) = −sin t.
- Square: .A negative times a negative is positive, the way (−3 = 9.
- Swap for cos t. The expression is now .Cosine is an even function: cos(−t) = cos t.
- Swap for : .Pythagorean identity, with t subtracted from both sides.
- Cancel one cos t: cos t.t is cos t · cos t; one of those factors cancels with the bottom.
Rung 4 of 7
Rung 4: rewrite, combine, swap
Simplify 3 cot t · cos t + 3 sin t, that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever cot t is defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Rewrite cot t as and multiply: .Quotient identity: cot t = . Multiplying the fraction by 3 and by cos t multiplies its top, and cos t · cos t = t.
- Give 3 sin t the bottom sin t: .Fractions are added over one bottom; multiplying top and bottom by sin t multiplies by 1.
- Add the tops: .With one bottom, the tops add and the bottom stays.
- Factor 3 out of the top: .Both terms on top share the factor 3.
- Swap for 1: .Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1, and the order of adding does not matter.
- Rename: .Reciprocal identity read backwards: = csc t.
Rung 5 of 7
Rung 5: two bottoms that hide a Pythagorean pattern
Simplify + , that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever neither bottom is 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Choose the shared bottom .Each bottom fits into it, the way 6 is 2 times 3.
- Rewrite each fraction: .Multiply each top and bottom by the factor its bottom is missing; that multiplies by 1.
- Add the tops: .Distribute each 3, then 3 sin t and −3 sin t add to 0.
- Multiply out the bottom: .Difference of squares read backwards: (a − b)(a + b) = − with a = 1 and b = sin t.
- Swap for : .Pythagorean identity, with t subtracted from both sides.
- Rename: .Reciprocal identity read backwards: = sec t, used twice.
Rung 6 of 7
Rung 6: a fraction inside a fraction
Simplify , that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever tan t is defined and sin t ≠ 0.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the top first. Rewrite tan t: the top is .Quotient identity: tan t = .
- Give the bottom cos t: , so the top is .Fractions are subtracted over one bottom; multiplying top and bottom by cos t multiplies by 1, and cos t · cos t = t.
- Factor sin t out of that top: .Both terms, sin t and sin t · t, share the factor sin t.
- Swap for : .Pythagorean identity, with t subtracted from both sides; sin t · t is three sines multiplied, t.
- Now divide by the bottom, : .Dividing by t is multiplying by its flip, .
- Cancel : .t is sin t · sin t · sin t; two of those factors cancel with t = sin t · sin t on the bottom.
- Rename: .Quotient identity read backwards.
Rung 7 of 7
Rung 7: split, then swap twice
Simplify + , that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever csc t and sec t are defined.
Show the steps and the answer
- Split the first fraction: .A difference on top splits over the same bottom, the reverse of combining tops: = − . Anything nonzero over itself is 1.
- Divide: , so the first fraction is .Reciprocal identity: csc t = . Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip, and the flip of is sin t.
- Do the same to the second fraction: .Reciprocal identity: sec t = , so dividing by sec t is multiplying by cos t.
- Swap each Pythagorean pattern: and . The sum is now .Pythagorean identity, rearranged two ways.
- Swap for 1.Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Write one step per line with the identity's name beside it, like a receipt that lists every item. If you cannot name the reason for a step, the step is probably a mistake.
- Memory device for the usual order: Some Cats Prefer Cream. Sine and cosine, Combine fractions, Pythagorean swap, Cancel. It is the usual order, not a law: use any move that applies.
- Check at t = 30°, 45° or 60°: work out the start and your answer as numbers. Different numbers mean a mistake somewhere; equal numbers are a good sign.
- Every row of the swap table works in both directions: t may become 1 − t, and 1 may become t + t, when that helps.
- Before canceling, ask: does this piece multiply everything on top and everything on the bottom? If something is added beside it, factor first or split the fraction.
- Shortcut: when a Pythagorean pattern in tan, cot, sec or csc is already in front of you, such as t − 1, swap it directly for t. Rewriting in sine and cosine also works; it takes longer.
- Two right answers can look different: and 3 csc t are the same. Test both at one angle to see that they agree.
- You are done when nothing more can be rewritten, combined, swapped or canceled: one fraction at most, no factor shared by top and bottom, and no Pythagorean pattern left.
7 The trap
Canceling a term instead of a factor. You may cross out only a piece that multiplies the entire top and the entire bottom. In the cos t on top is added to sin t, so it does not cancel; the fraction splits into + = 1 + tan t. When the piece is in every term on top, factor first and then cancel: = = 1 + sin t.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
When you simplify a trig expression, why does the last line have the same value as the first?
- Every step is an equal trade: a named identity, or an algebra move that keeps the value, such as canceling a shared factor. Swapping 100 pennies for one dollar bill shrinks the pile but not the amount
- in the same way, the last line equals the first at every angle where every line is defined. Pick trades that leave out no angle the first line allows: cot t = keeps 90°, but cot t = loses it.
Why do you rewrite tan, cot, sec and csc in sine and cosine first?
- All four are built from sine and cosine, for example tan t = and sec t = . Once every piece is in sine and cosine, parts that looked unrelated can be matched and canceled.
- Example: tan t · cos t = · cos t = sin t (quotient identity, then cancel the shared factor cos t).
Can you cross out sin t in ?
- No. On top, sin t is added to 1; it does not multiply the whole top. You may cross out only a piece that multiplies the entire top and the entire bottom.
- Split the fraction instead: + = 1 + csc t (reciprocal identity).
What does simplify to? Name each step, then check at 30°.
- = (sine is an odd function)
- = (Pythagorean identity)
- = −sin t (cancel the shared factor sin t; the minus sign stays)
- Check at 30°: 30° = and sin(−30°) = −, so the start is (1 − ) ÷ (−) = · (−2) = −, the same as −sin 30°.
Lesson 6 of 7
Proving an identity by working on one side
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 0
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
Someone hands you a handful of coins, three quarters and five nickels, and says it is one dollar. To prove it, you do not argue. You trade: five nickels for one quarter, then four quarters for a dollar bill. Each trade keeps the value the same, so when you hold one dollar bill, you have shown the handful was a dollar all along. Proving an identity works the same way. The messy side is the handful of coins. Each trade is a fact you already know, such as tan t = . You keep trading on that one side until it reads exactly like the other side. You never reach across and change the other side to make them match.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Reciprocal and quotient identities, Pythagorean identities, Even and odd, What t means, Adding fractions, Multiplying fractions, Dividing by a fraction, Squaring a fraction, Canceling, Difference of squares and common factor, A negative squared, Exact values at 30° and 60°, One test angle
- Reciprocal and quotient identities. csc t = , sec t = , cot t = , tan t = . Example: csc 30° = 1 ÷ = 2.
- Pythagorean identities. t + t = 1, 1 + t = t and 1 + t = t. Example: at 30°, + = 1.
- Even and odd. Cosine is an even function and sine is an odd function: cos(−t) = cos t, sin(−t) = −sin t, tan(−t) = −tan t. Example: sin(−30°) = −.
- What t means. t means (sin t: find the sine, then square it. Example: 30° = ( = .
- Adding fractions. Give both fractions the same bottom, then add the tops: + = + = .
- Multiplying fractions. Top times top, bottom times bottom: · = = .
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 5 ÷ = 5 · 3 = 15, and in the same way sin t ÷ = t.
- Squaring a fraction. Square the top and the bottom: ( = . So t = and t = .
- Canceling. Cancel only a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom: = , but = , not 7.
- Difference of squares and common factor. − = (a − b)(a + b), as in 25 − 9 = 2 · 8 = 16; and a·b + a·c = a(b + c), as in 3·5 + 3·2 = 3 · 7 = 21.
- A negative squared. (−a = , because a negative times a negative is positive: (−3 = 9.
- Exact values at 30° and 60°. sin 30° = , cos 30° = , tan 30° = ; sin 60° = , cos 60° = , tan 60° = . Flip them for csc, sec and cot: csc 30° = 2, sec 60° = 2.
- One test angle. Both sides agreeing at one angle does not prove an identity; disagreeing at one angle proves it false.
3 Why
An identity claims two expressions are equal at every angle where both are defined. A chain of steps, each one a fact you already know, carries the value along unchanged: if A = B and B = C, then A = C. That chain is the proof. Moving a term across the equals sign of the claim is different: it starts from the claim itself and shows only where the claim leads. That is a proof only when every step can be run backwards, and one step that cannot, such as squaring both sides, lets a false claim reach a true line. Start on the more complicated side because its pieces tell you what to do next; a one-term side gives no hint of what to build.
4 The rule
To prove an identity in this course, work on one side.
Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by or ) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here.
The same idea, five ways
Prove it on one side: start with the messier side and turn it into the other side, one known step at a time.
One way to prove an identity, and the way used in this course: rewrite one side, usually the more complicated one, with facts already known, until it reads exactly as the other side; nothing is moved across the equals sign of the claim.
- left side = form 1 = form 2 = … = right side
- If A = B, B = C and C = D, then A = D.
- tan t · csc t = · = = sec t
Trading a handful of coins, fair trade by fair trade, until it becomes the one dollar bill that was claimed.
The same idea, other ways
Picture a chain of links. The first link is the side you start with, the last link is the other side, and each link in between is one line of your work, joined to the one before by an equals sign you can defend with a known identity or a fraction rule. If every link holds, the first equals the last.
left side (copy it alone)
= next form (name the identity)
= next form (name the fraction rule)
= …
= right side (stop here)
You are asked to make a messy room match a photo in a catalog. You work inside the room only: fold, stack, put away. You never edit the photo to look like the room. When the room looks exactly like the photo, you are done. The messy side of an identity is the room, the other side is the photo, and each known identity is one tidying move.
Equals passes along a chain: if A = B and B = C, then A = C. Each line of a proof equals the line before it because of a fact already known, so the first line equals the last. Moving a term across the equals sign of the claim starts from the claim itself, which is not known yet. Such an argument shows only where the claim leads, and it proves the claim only if every step can be run backwards.
Prove that + = the same way. Work on the left side only: + = + = = . Each step is a fraction fact, and the last line is the right side, so the claim is proved. A trig proof has the same shape; only the facts change.
Rewrite, combine, swap, factor, cancel. Say the five verbs in that order as you work: rewrite in sine and cosine, combine fractions, swap with a Pythagorean identity, factor, cancel. If none of them helps and a bottom reads 1 + sin t, 1 − cos t or a pair like them, multiply the top and the bottom by the conjugate, which keeps the value wherever the conjugate is not 0.
| What you see | What to try | The fact that makes it legal |
|---|---|---|
| tan t, cot t, sec t or csc t | Rewrite in sine and cosine | tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t = |
| Two fractions added or subtracted | Combine over a common denominator | |
| A 1 beside a square, such as 1 − t or t − 1 | Swap the pair for one square | Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t, t − 1 = t |
| A factor in every term | Pull it out, then look inside | a·b + a·c = a(b + c) |
| A square minus a square | Factor into two parentheses | |
| A bottom such as 1 + cos t or sec t − 1 | Multiply top and bottom by the conjugate | Multiplying by is multiplying by 1 wherever 1 − cos t is not 0 |
| A negative angle, such as sin(−t) | Use the even and odd facts |
Part 1: Strategy 1: rewrite everything in sine and cosine
A recipe that mixes cups, tablespoons and grams is hard to check until you convert everything to one unit. A side that mixes tangent, secant and cosecant is like that. Sine and cosine are the common unit: each of the other four functions is a fraction built from them. Once every piece is written in sine and cosine, you can see which factors match, which cancel and which fractions combine.
- Swaps: tan t = , cot t = , sec t = , csc t = .
- When: the side mixes two or more of the six functions, or you do not know what else to do.
- Then: multiply or combine the fractions, and cancel factors that sit on the whole top and the whole bottom.
- Gotcha: the swap makes the line longer before it gets shorter. That is normal.
cot t =
sec t =
csc t =
Worked example
Proving tan t · csc t = sec t
Prove that tan t · csc t = sec t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two functions; the right side has one.
- Quotient identity tan t = and reciprocal identity csc t = .
- Multiply fractions: top times top (sin t · 1 = sin t), bottom times bottom (cos t · sin t).
- sin t is a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom, so it cancels and leaves 1 on top.
- Reciprocal identity read backward: = sec t. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: each reciprocal pair has exactly one co. Cosine goes with secant, sine goes with cosecant, tangent goes with cotangent.
- When you are stuck anywhere in a proof, this strategy is the safe first move.
Part 2: Strategy 2: Pythagorean substitution
A Pythagorean identity works like a currency exchange booth with a rate that never changes. 1 − t is always worth exactly t, so at any step you may hand over one and take the other. The signal is a 1 standing beside a square, or t standing beside t. Trade the pair for a single square, or trade a single square for the pair when the target needs it.
- Base: t + t = 1, so 1 − t = t and 1 − t = t.
- Tangent form: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t.
- Cotangent form: 1 + t = t, so t − 1 = t.
- Signal: a 1 beside a squared function, or t beside t.
- Allowed: these rearrangements are fine, because the Pythagorean identities are already proved, so every form of them is a known fact.
Worked example
Proving (t − 1)·t = t
Prove that (t − 1)·t = t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has a 1 beside a square and a product; the right side is one square.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 + t = t rearranged gives t − 1 = t.
- Quotient identity squared: t = ( = · = .
- t sits on the whole bottom and multiplies the whole top, so it cancels. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Look for the 1. Wherever a 1 stands beside a squared function, a Pythagorean swap is nearby.
- If the target has only sine, trade t for 1 − t; if it has only cosine, trade t for 1 − t.
Part 3: Strategy 3: factoring
Factoring is packing. If every item on a table carries the same sticker, you can put the sticker on the box once and list what is inside. In sin t·t + t, both terms carry a factor sin t, so you write sin t once in front of parentheses. Inside the parentheses a Pythagorean pattern often appears, and the whole group turns into 1. A square minus a square packs the same way, into two parentheses.
- Common factor: a·b + a·c = a(b + c). Example: sin t·t + sin t·t = sin t(t + t).
- Difference of squares: − = (a − b)(a + b). Example: 1 − t = (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t).
- Hidden factors: t = sin t · t, and t = (t.
- Then: look inside the parentheses for a Pythagorean pattern, and cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.
Worked example
Proving sin t·t + t = sin t
Prove that sin t·t + t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two terms and higher powers; the right side is one function.
- t means sin t · sin t · sin t, which is sin t · t. Writing it this way shows the common factor.
- Both terms carry the factor sin t, so pull it out: a·b + a·c = a(b + c).
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
- Multiplying by 1 changes nothing. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Check a factoring by multiplying it back out; you must get the line you started with.
- A fourth power is the square of a square, so t − t is a difference of squares in disguise.
Part 4: Strategy 4: multiplying by a conjugate
Two expressions with the same two terms and the opposite sign between them, such as 1 + cos t and 1 − cos t, are called a conjugate pair. Think of a key and its lock. Apart, each one is awkward. Multiplied together, the middle pieces cancel and leave a square minus a square, 1 − t, which the Pythagorean identity turns into one tidy term, t. So when a bottom reads 1 + cos t, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate, 1 − cos t. Doing the same to the top and the bottom multiplies by 1, so the value does not change.
- Say it: the conjugate of 1 plus cos t is 1 minus cos t.
- Write it: the conjugate of a two-term expression is the same two terms with the sign between them flipped.
- Math: a + b and a − b are conjugates, and (a + b)(a − b) = − .
- Like: a key and its lock; apart each is awkward, together they open into one tidy term.
- Useful pairs: (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) = t, (1 + sin t)(1 − sin t) = t, (sec t + 1)(sec t − 1) = t, (csc t + 1)(csc t − 1) = t.
- Why it is allowed: multiplying the top and the bottom by the conjugate is multiplying by 1, at every angle where the conjugate is not 0.
Reminder
Reminder: Difference of squares
- Difference of squares.
Worked example
Clearing the bottom 1 + cos t
Prove that = (1 − cos t)·t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads (1 − cos t)·t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Its bottom, 1 + cos t, is a two-term sum: the signal for a conjugate. Starting from the right side also works; the check does that.
- 1 − cos t is the conjugate of 1 + cos t. is 1 wherever 1 − cos t is not 0, so the value does not change.
- Multiply fractions: top times top, bottom times bottom.
- Difference of squares: (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) = − t = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- A fraction is its top times 1 over its bottom, and = ( = t by the reciprocal identity. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Put the conjugate on the bottom that has two terms; that is the bottom you want to turn into one term.
- To write a conjugate, copy both terms and flip only the sign between them: the conjugate of sec t − 1 is sec t + 1.
- At t = 0°, 1 − cos t = 0, so multiplying by does not work there. The right side contains csc 0°, which is undefined, so the identity makes no claim at 0° anyway.
5 How
- Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
- Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.
- Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.
- Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.
- Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.
- Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.
Proving an identity on one side
- Choose the more complicated side and copy it alone; the other side is the target.
- Clear negative angles: cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t; sine and tangent are odd functions, so sin(−t) = −sin t and tan(−t) = −tan t.
- Rewrite tan t, cot t, sec t and csc t in sine and cosine.
- Combine fractions over a common denominator, or split one fraction into two when the target is a sum.
- Swap with a Pythagorean identity wherever a 1 stands beside a square.
- Factor (a common factor, or a difference of squares), then cancel any factor of the whole top and the whole bottom.
- If a bottom is 1 plus or minus sin t or cos t, or sec t or csc t plus or minus 1, multiply the top and the bottom by its conjugate.
- Compare with the target after every line, and stop when they match exactly.
6 Worked example
Worked example
From (csc t − sin t)·tan t to cos t
Prove that (csc t − sin t)·tan t = cos t is an identity. In plain words: start with one side and rewrite it, using only facts you already know, until it reads exactly as the other side.
Show the steps and the answer
(csc t − sin t)·tan t
= ( − sin t)· sine and cosine
= · common bottom
= · Pythagorean
= cos t cancel sin t and one cos t
- Choose the left side, , and leave cos t alone as the target.The left side has three functions, a subtraction and a product; the right side is one function. The more complicated side gives you moves to make.
- Sine and cosine: the reciprocal identity csc t = and the quotient identity tan t = .
- To subtract, sin t needs the bottom sin t: multiply it by , which is 1, to get .
- The two fractions now share the bottom sin t, so subtract the tops.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1 rearranged gives 1 − t = t.
- Multiply fractions: top times top, bottom times bottom.
- t is cos t · cos t. The factors sin t and cos t each sit on the whole top and the whole bottom, so they cancel, and one cos t is left.
- The last line, cos t, is exactly the right side, so the proof is done.Every line equals the line before it by a fact you can name, so the first line equals the last.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 7
One swap, one cancel
Prove that cos t · tan t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two functions; the right side has one.
- Quotient identity: tan t = .
- Multiplying a fraction by cos t multiplies its top by cos t.
- cos t is a factor of the whole top and the whole bottom, so it cancels. This is the right side.
Rung 2 of 7
One Pythagorean swap
Prove that (1 − t)·csc t = sin t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sin t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has a 1 beside a square and a second function; the right side is one function.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- Reciprocal identity csc t = , then multiply the top by t.
- t is sin t · sin t; one sin t cancels with the bottom. This is the right side.
Rung 3 of 7
Dividing by a reciprocal
Prove that + = 1. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 1.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two fractions and four functions; the right side is the number 1.
- A fraction bar means divide, and the reciprocal identities give csc t = and sec t = .
- Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip: the flip of is sin t, and the flip of is cos t.
- sin t · sin t is written t, and cos t · cos t is written t.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1. This is the right side.
Rung 4 of 7
Two fractions over a common denominator
Prove that + = 2t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 2t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has two fractions to combine; the right side is one term.
- Common denominator: multiply the top and the bottom of each fraction by the other fraction's bottom, which is multiplying by 1.
- Same bottom, so add the tops.
- Top: sin t − sin t = 0 and 1 + 1 = 2 (gotcha: the sines cancel, so the top is not 2 + 2sin t). Bottom: difference of squares, (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t) = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- sec t = , so t = ( = . This is the right side.
Rung 5 of 7
Negative angles first
Prove that (1 + (−t))·cos(−t) = sec t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads sec t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .It has negative angles, a square and a product; the right side is one function.
- Tangent is an odd function, so tan(−t) = −tan t; cosine is an even function, so cos(−t) = cos t.
- A negative squared is positive: (−tan t = t. Gotcha: it is not −t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 + t = t.
- Reciprocal identity squared: t = . Then one factor cos t cancels from the top and the bottom.
- Reciprocal identity read backward: = sec t. This is the right side.
Rung 6 of 7
A difference of squares in disguise
Prove that t − t = 1 − 2t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 1 − 2t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Fourth powers are more complicated than the right side's single square.
- A fourth power is the square of a square: t = t · t = (t, and the same for sine.
- Difference of squares − = (a − b)(a + b), with a = t and b = t.
- Pythagorean identity: t + t = 1.
- The target has only sine, so trade t for 1 − t (Pythagorean identity).
- One t taken away, then another: − t − t = −2t. This is the right side.
Rung 7 of 7
Rung 7 (genuinely hard): a conjugate, then a square
Prove that = (sec t + tan t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads (sec t + tan t.
Show the steps and the answer
- Work on the left side, .Its bottom, 1 − sin t, is one of the conjugate pairs. The right side would also work as a start; the check does it.
- Multiply the top and the bottom by the conjugate 1 + sin t; that is multiplying by 1 wherever 1 + sin t is not 0.
- Top: (1 + sin t)(1 + sin t) = (1 + sin t. Bottom: difference of squares, (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t) = 1 − t.
- Pythagorean identity: 1 − t = t.
- A square over a square is the square of the fraction: ( = · = , read from right to left.
- Split the fraction: a sum on top over one bottom is two fractions with that bottom (adding fractions, read backward).
- Reciprocal identity = sec t and quotient identity = tan t. This is the right side.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: mess to match. Start with the mess, change only the mess, and stop when it matches the other side.
- Pick the side with more: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
- Write each step on its own line beginning with =, and name the identity beside it. If you cannot name the reason for a step, the step is suspect.
- Keep the target in view. If it has only sine, trade t for 1 − t; if it has sec t, aim for .
- You are done only when the line reads exactly as the other side: is not yet sec t until you write that last step.
- Check at 30° or 60°, not at 45°: at 45° sine and cosine are equal, so a mix-up between them goes unnoticed. Avoid 0° and 90° too, where some functions are 0 or undefined.
- Stuck? Rewrite everything in sine and cosine. Still stuck? Start over from the other side; a proof may start from either side, as long as you change only that side.
7 The trap
The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning t − t = 1 into t = 1 + t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
To prove tan t · cos t = sin t, which side do you start on, and why?
- The left side, tan t · cos t: it has two functions, and the right side has one.
- Its pieces point to the next step: write tan t as , then cancel cos t to reach sin t, the target.
The proofs in this lesson never move a term across the equals sign of the claim. Why?
- Moving it starts from the claim, which is not known yet. That shows only where the claim leads, and it counts as a proof only if every step can be run backwards, which then has to be checked.
- Copying one side alone and rewriting it until it reads exactly as the other side needs no such check.
When do you stop rewriting, and why does that finish the proof?
- Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side.
- Every step used a fact you already know, so the value never changed, like trading five nickels for a quarter. If A = B and B = C, then A = C, so the side you began with equals the other side.
You plug a test angle into both sides of a claim and get the same number. Does that prove the identity?
- No. One angle is not every angle: sin t = cos t holds at 45° but fails at 0°, where sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.
- The test angle catches slips; a proof needs an argument that covers every angle, such as a chain of known steps on one side.
Lesson 7 of 7
The usual mistakes in a proof
Open this lessonLeans on 0Comes back in 0
Leans on
No lesson links recorded.
Comes back in
No lesson links recorded.
1 In plain words
Picture a friend who tells you every outfit looks great, even the shirt with a ketchup stain. Their praise tells you nothing, because they would say it no matter what. Some moves in a proof behave like that friend: they can take a false line and hand back a true one. Call such a move a one-way step, because you can walk forward through it but cannot count on walking back. After a one-way step, a true line proves nothing about the line before it. This lesson shows the three usual mistakes: starting from the claim and working both sides as if you were solving an equation, squaring both sides, and dividing by something that can be zero. For each one you will see it fool you, then the safe move to make instead.
2 Picture it
Mistake 1, working both sides from the claim: a proof only if every step walks back.
Mistake 2, squaring both sides: 3 ≠ −3, yet = (−3.
Mistake 3, dividing by what can be 0: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0, yet 3 ≠ 5.
Safe: start from one side, rewrite it, end at the other.
Memory device: one side, no squares, no zeros.
Reminder
Reminder: The Pythagorean identity, What t means, Difference of squares, Squaring a negative, A square root is never negative, Dividing by a fraction, Multiplying fractions, Canceling a common factor, Points on the unit circle, One test angle
- The Pythagorean identity. t + t = 1 at every angle, so t = 1 − t; at t = 30°, + = 1.
- What t means. t means (sin t: 30° = ( = .
- Difference of squares. − = (a − b)(a + b), so 1 − t = (1 − cos t)(1 + cos t); with numbers, 1 − = (1 − 3)(1 + 3) = −8.
- Squaring a negative. A negative times a negative is positive: (−3 = (−3) · (−3) = 9, the same as = 9.
- A square root is never negative. means the number, 0 or more, whose square is a: = 3, not −3, even though (−3 = 9.
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: ÷ = × = = .
- Multiplying fractions. Tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms: · = = , since · = 2.
- Canceling a common factor. A factor in both the top and the bottom of one fraction cancels: = 5, allowed because the bottom 3 is not 0.
- Points on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): at 180° it is (−1, 0), so cos 180° = −1 and sin 180° = 0; at 90° it is (0, 1).
- One test angle. One angle where the two sides differ shows a claim is not an identity: sin t = cos t holds at 45° but fails at 0°, where sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.
3 Why
A proof has to lead from facts you already trust to the claim. An argument that starts from the claim and works both sides runs the other way: it shows that the claim leads to something true. False claims do that too: from the false 3 = −3, squaring gives the true 9 = 9. So such an argument proves the claim only once every step has been shown to walk back, from the true line to the claim, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring cannot be walked back when the two sides may differ in sign, because a number and its negative have the same square. Dividing by zero has no answer, so it cannot undo a multiplication by zero: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0, yet 3 ≠ 5. Rewriting one side never starts from the claim, so it has nothing to walk back.
4 The rule
A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim.
The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.
The same idea, five ways
A one-way step: a move you cannot count on walking back.
A one-way step is a move that can turn a false line into a true one, so a true line after it tells you nothing about the line before it.
- 3 ≠ −3, yet = (−3 = 9
- 3 ≠ 5, yet 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 = 0
- A = B gives = , but = gives only A = B or A = −B
Rounding prices to the nearest dollar: a 2.80 price and a 3.20 price both become 3 dollars, so a receipt that says 3 dollars cannot tell you which price it was.
The same idea, other ways
If it rained last night, the street is wet. You step outside and the street is wet. Did it rain? Maybe, or maybe a sprinkler ran. A wet street fits rain without proving it. Working both sides argues the same way: if the claim is true, then 1 = 1; 1 = 1 is true; so the claim is true? A true ending fits the claim without proving it.
Start from a claim you know is false, 3 = −3. Square both sides: 9 = 9, which is true. Start from another false claim, 3 = 5. Multiply both sides by 0: 0 = 0, true again. Both times a false start reached a true finish, so a true finish, by itself, says nothing about the start.
On the graph of y = , the height above 3 and the height above −3 are both 9. Two starts, one finish. Standing at height 9, you cannot tell which start you came from. A one-way step does that to a proof: the finish stops telling you where you began.
Ask of every step: could I walk it back and land exactly where I was? Squaring: not unless you know the two sides have the same sign, since 9 could have come from 3 or from −3. Dividing by something that is 0: no, the step has no answer to walk back from. Rewriting one side with an identity: nothing needs walking back, because every line equals the one before it.
Each line of a proof from one side swaps an expression for another that equals it at every angle where both are defined, by an identity already shown. A chain of equal things, left side = A = B = right side, makes the left side equal the right side wherever every line is defined. The chain never starts from the claim, so no step has to be walked back.
| The move | Why it tempts you | Why it fails | Do this instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting from the claim and working both sides | It is how you solve an equation. | It shows only where the claim leads, and a false claim can also reach a true line such as 1 = 1. It is a proof only if every step can be walked back. | Start from one side and turn it into the other. |
| Squaring both sides | It removes a square root and keeps equal sides equal. | 3 and −3 have the same square, 9, so a true squared line cannot tell the signs apart. | Do not take a true squared line as proof of the claim. To judge the claim, test an angle where one side could be negative. |
| Dividing both sides by an expression that can be 0 | It clears away a factor that both sides share. | Dividing by 0 has no answer: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 = 5 is false. | Rewrite one side; cancel a factor from the top and bottom of one fraction, which keeps the value wherever that fraction is defined, since its bottom is not 0 there. |
Part 1: Mistake 1: working both sides
Working both sides means writing the whole claim, left side = right side, as your first line, then doing the same thing to both sides until something true appears. Equations taught you that habit, so it feels right. Picture a detective who decides the butler did it, then shows that a guilty butler would fit the clues. The gardener might fit them too. The detective has shown the story is possible, not that it is true. A proof has to start from what you already trust. The method of this course starts from one side of the claim, which you then turn into the other side. An argument on both sides counts as a proof only after every step has been checked to run backwards, from the true line to the claim.
- What it looks like: the first line is the whole claim, and later lines change both sides at once.
- Why it proves nothing by itself: reaching a true line shows only that the claim leads there, and false claims can lead to true lines too. The true line proves the claim only if the steps can be reversed.
- What would repair it: a check that every step can be walked back, so that the true line leads to the claim. An angle where a step cannot be walked back is then checked on its own.
- Safe move: start from one side alone and write one chain, left side = ... = right side.
- Allowed on scratch paper: trying both sides to find an idea. In this course the proof you then write down starts from one side.
Worked example
From working both sides to a proof
Someone wants to show that = cos t + sin t is an identity. They multiply both sides by sec t to get 1 + tan t = (cos t + sin t) · sec t, rewrite the right side as = 1 + tan t, and stop because the two sides match. Say what this argument shows as written and what it leaves out, then write a proof that starts from one side.
Show the steps and the answer
= (1 + tan t) · cos t
= cos t + tan t · cos t
= cos t + sin t
- Say what the question asks: what the argument shows as written, what it leaves out, and a chain that starts at one side and ends at the other.A proof is judged by its steps, not only by whether the last line looks right.
- Look at the first move: it multiplies both sides of the claim by sec t, and the work ends at .That starts from the claim, so the matching lines show only that the claim leads to a true line. The move can be undone by dividing by sec t, which is never 0, but the argument does not say so, and saying so is what would make it a proof.
- Start the proof from the left side alone: .It is the more complicated side; a fraction with sec t in the bottom has room to be rewritten.
- Use the reciprocal identity : the left side is .A fraction bar means divide, and swapping sec t for does not change the value.
- Divide by by multiplying by its flip: .Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by that fraction turned upside down, and turned over is cos t.
- Distribute cos t: .Multiplying a sum by cos t multiplies each of its two terms by cos t.
- Use the quotient identity : , so the line is .The cos t on top cancels the cos t in the bottom of that one fraction; wherever tan t makes sense, cos t is not 0.
- The chain now ends at , the right side.Every line equals the one before it, so the first line equals the last.
- As written it shows only that the claim leads to the true line 1 + tan t = 1 + tan t. It leaves out the walk back: multiplying both sides by sec t can be undone by dividing by sec t, which is never 0, and the argument has to say so to be a proof.
- A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: = (1 + tan t) · cos t = cos t + tan t · cos t = cos t + sin t.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- If your first line already has an equals sign with the other side on it, stop: you are working both sides, and every step would need a walk-back check.
- Scratch work on both sides can show you which identities to use; reuse them in a chain from one side.
Part 2: Mistake 2: squaring both sides
Squaring is like printing a color photo in black and white. A red shirt and a green shirt can come out the same gray, and from the gray print you cannot tell which color it was. Squaring does that to signs: 3 and −3 both become 9. So when a squared line is true, the line before it may still be wrong by a minus sign. Square roots are where this tempts you, because squaring both sides makes the root disappear. A true squared line proves the unsquared claim only where both sides are known to have the same sign, so do not lean on it: test an angle where one side could be negative.
- What it looks like: a step that turns A = B into = .
- Why it fails: = is true when A = B and also when A = −B, so the squared line cannot tell which.
- With numbers: 3 ≠ −3, yet = 9 and (−3 = 9.
- Where it hides: claims with a square root, such as cos t = , which fails at 180°.
- Safe move: do not take a true squared line as proof of the claim; test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.
- When it can be walked back: only where both sides are known to have the same sign, for example both 0 or more.
Worked example
A square root claim that squaring seems to prove
Someone says cos t = is an identity, because squaring both sides gives t = 1 − t, which is the Pythagorean identity. Is the claim an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is cos t equal to at every angle where both sides make sense?That is what being an identity means. Here both sides make sense at every angle: t is never more than 1, so 1 − t is never below 0 and its square root exists.
- Flag the step that squares both sides.Squaring gives a number and its negative the same result, so a true squared line cannot show the unsquared claim is true.
- Look for an angle where the two sides could disagree in sign. The right side is a square root, so it is never negative; pick an angle where cos t is negative, such as .A negative number can never equal a number that is 0 or more.
- Left side at : .The point on the unit circle at 180° is (−1, 0), and cos t is its x coordinate.
- Right side at : .sin 180° = 0 is the y coordinate of (−1, 0), and = 1 because the square root is the answer that is not negative.
- Compare: , so the claim fails at .One angle where both sides make sense and differ is enough to show a claim is not an identity.
- Name what the true squared line does say: cos t is either or , and at it is the second. = holds when A = B and also when A = −B; squaring threw away which one.
- No, it is not an identity: at t = 180°, cos t = −1 but = 1.
- The squaring step hid the minus sign.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- When a claim has a square root on one side, find an angle where the other side is negative and test there first.
- A true squared line tells you the two sides are equal or opposite, never which one.
Part 3: Mistake 3: dividing by an expression that can be zero
Sharing 6 cookies among 3 friends gives each friend 2. Sharing them among 0 friends has no answer: nobody is there to receive them. Dividing by zero never has an answer. The trouble in a proof is that zero can wear a disguise. An expression such as sin t, cos t or 1 − cos t equals 0 at some angles, and t + t − 1 equals 0 at every angle. Dividing both sides by such an expression divides by zero at those angles, and that can turn a true line into a false one.
- What it looks like: a step that turns E · A = E · B into A = B by dividing both sides by E.
- Why it fails: where E = 0, the line E · A = E · B reads 0 = 0, which is true for any A and B, so it gives no reason for A = B.
- With numbers: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 = 5 is false.
- Where zero hides, from 0° to 360°: sin t = 0 at 0°, 180° and 360°; cos t = 0 at 90° and 270°; 1 − cos t = 0 at 0° and 360°, since 1 − cos 0° = 1 − 1 = 0; t + t − 1 = 0 at every angle.
- The same trap from the other end: multiplying both sides by an expression that can be 0 makes the line true at those angles whatever came before.
- Allowed: canceling a factor shared by the top and bottom of one fraction, because that bottom is already not 0 wherever the fraction makes sense.
Worked example
A zero in disguise
Someone writes: the line (t + t − 1) · sin t = (t + t − 1) · cos t is true for every t, so dividing both sides by t + t − 1 shows that sin t = cos t for every t. Find the mistake.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: find the step where true lines turn into a false one.sin t = cos t cannot hold at every angle: at t = 0°, sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1.
- Work out the bracket: , at every t.The Pythagorean identity says t + t = 1 at every angle.
- Read the first line again with the bracket replaced: , that is .Zero times any number is 0. The line is true, but it says nothing about sin t or cos t.
- So the step that divides both sides by divides by 0, at every angle.The bracket equals 0 everywhere, and dividing by 0 has no answer.
- Conclude: the division is the mistake; the true first line cannot be divided down to .A multiplication by 0 cannot be undone: 3 · 0 = 5 · 0 is true, yet 3 ≠ 5.
- The mistake is dividing by t + t − 1, which equals 0 at every angle.
- The first line only says 0 = 0, and sin t = cos t is false: at t = 0°, 0 ≠ 1.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Before dividing by an expression, plug in 0°, 90°, 180° and 270°, where sine or cosine is 0, and see whether it becomes 0.
- If the Pythagorean identity turns an expression into 1 − 1, it is a zero in disguise at every angle.
5 How
- Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.
- Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.
- Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.
- Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.
- Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.
- Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.
Checking a proof for the three mistakes
- Read the first line. A proof by this course's method starts with one side of the claim alone. An argument that starts from the whole claim is a proof only if every step can be walked back.
- Go line by line. Each line should come from the one above by rewriting one side with a named identity or an algebra move.
- Mark every step that squares, multiplies or divides both sides.
- For a squaring step, test the claim at an angle where one side could be negative, such as 120°, 180° or 210°.
- For a dividing step, find every angle where the divisor is 0 and plug each one back in to confirm it; also check whether the Pythagorean identity makes the divisor 0 at every angle.
- If a test angle gives two different values, the claim is false and no proof can exist. If the claim survives, write a fresh proof from one side.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Repairing an argument that works both sides
Someone wants to show that − cos t = 1 is an identity and writes:
Line 1: − cos t = 1
Line 2: = 1 + cos t (add cos t to both sides)
Line 3: t = (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) (multiply both sides by 1 − cos t)
Line 4: t = 1 − t (multiply out)
Line 5: t + t = 1 (add t to both sides), which is true.
They stop there. Say what the five lines show when read from top to bottom, what has to be checked before they count as a proof, and then write a proof that starts from one side.
Show the steps and the answer
= 1
- Say what the question asks: what the five lines show as written, what they still need, and a proof from one side.A proof is judged by how its lines are built, not only by whether the last line is true.
- Read Line 1: it is the whole claim, left side right side.The argument starts from the claim, the very thing to be shown, so the lines under it show where the claim leads.
- Read Lines 2, 3 and 5: each does the same thing to both sides (adds cos t, multiplies by , adds ).Doing the same thing to both sides is how you solve an equation. Each such step says: if the line above is true, the line below is true.
- Say what the lines show from top to bottom: if the claim is true, then . A true last line does not by itself make the first line true.False starts can reach true finishes too: squaring the false 3 = −3 gives the true 9 = 9.
- Check whether every step can be walked back, from Line 5 up to Line 1: subtracting undoes Line 5, Line 4 only rewrites the right side of Line 3, dividing by undoes Line 3, and subtracting cos t undoes Line 2.Dividing by 1 − cos t is allowed here because 1 − cos t is the bottom of the claim's left side, so it is not 0 at any angle where the claim's sides are defined. With this check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof; without it they are not.
- Now the method that needs no such check. Start from the left side alone: .It is the more complicated side; the right side, 1, has nothing to rewrite.
- Replace with : .The Pythagorean identity t + t = 1 gives t = 1 − t, so the value stays the same.
- Factor the top as a difference of squares: .1 − t has the shape − with a = 1 and b = cos t, and − = (a − b)(a + b).
- Cancel the factor from the top and the bottom: .Wherever the left side makes sense, its bottom 1 − cos t is not 0, so dividing top and bottom by it keeps the value. This is canceling inside one fraction, not dividing both sides.
- Combine: , which is the right side.cos t − cos t = 0, and every line equals the one before it, so the left side equals the right side.
- Read from top to bottom, the five lines show only that if the claim is true, then t + t = 1.
- To count as a proof they need a check that every step can be walked back. Here each one can, at every angle where the claim's sides are defined, because 1 − cos t is not 0 at those angles. With that check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof.
- A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: − cos t = − cos t = − cos t = 1 + cos t − cos t = 1.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 6
Rung 1: a false start and a true finish
What is wrong with this argument: 4 = −4, so squaring both sides gives 16 = 16, which is true, so 4 = −4.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: find the step that lets a false start look proved.4 = −4 is false, so some step of the argument must be unsound.
- Check the start: 4 and sit on opposite sides of 0 on the number line, so is false.Two numbers are equal only when they are the same point on the line.
- Square each side: and .A negative times a negative is positive.
- The squared line is true although the start was false. So the unsound step is the last one, which reads the true as proof of .Squaring sends a number and its negative to the same result, so a true squared line cannot be walked back to the line before it.
Rung 2 of 6
Rung 2: dividing by zero, with numbers
What is wrong with this argument: 7 · 0 = 2 · 0 is true, so dividing both sides by 0 gives 7 = 2.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: find the step that turned a true line into the false .7 and 2 are different numbers, so 7 = 2 is false.
- Check the first line: and , so it reads , which is true.Zero times any number is 0.
- Look at the next step: it divides both sides by 0.Dividing by 0 has no answer, the way sharing among 0 groups cannot be done.
- So the division is the mistake.The first line stays true with any two numbers in place of 7 and 2, so it cannot single out 7 = 2.
- Dividing both sides by 0.
- The line 7 · 0 = 2 · 0 is true for every pair of numbers, so it gives no reason for 7 = 2.
Rung 3 of 6
Rung 3: squaring hides a minus sign
Someone claims that cos t and −cos t are the same number at every angle, because their squares, t and (−cos t, are the same number at every angle. Is the claim right?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is cos t equal to at every angle?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides make sense, and here both sides make sense at every angle.
- Flag the squaring step: is true, but it says nothing about cos t and themselves.A negative times a negative is positive, so squaring wipes out the minus sign: two numbers with the same square can still be opposites.
- Test : , so the left side is 1 and the right side is .The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), and cos t is its x coordinate.
- Compare: , so the claim fails at .One angle where both sides make sense and differ is enough to show a claim is not an identity.
- No: at t = 0°, cos t = 1 but −cos t = −1, so cos t = −cos t is not an identity.
- Squaring made a false claim look true.
Rung 4 of 6
Rung 4: a square root claim with secant
Someone claims sec t = is an identity, because squaring both sides gives t = 1 + t, a Pythagorean identity. Is it an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
sec 180° = = −1
- Say what the question asks: is sec t equal to at every angle where both sides make sense?Both sides need cos t ≠ 0, since sec t = and tan t = , so the test angle must avoid 90° and 270°.
- Flag the squaring step.A true squared line can come from a false claim.
- The right side is a square root, so it is never negative. Look where sec t is negative: has the sign of cos t, so pick , where .1 divided by a negative number is negative.
- Left side at : .This is the reciprocal identity, with cos 180° = −1, the x coordinate of (−1, 0).
- Right side at : , so .This is the quotient identity, and 0 divided by any number that is not 0 is 0.
- Compare: , so the claim fails at .Both sides make sense at 180° and differ there.
- No: at t = 180°, sec t = −1 but = 1.
- The squared line is an identity; the claim is not.
Rung 5 of 6
Rung 5: a sound proof that only looks risky
Someone proves = like this:
= · = = .
Does the proof make any of the three mistakes?
Show the steps and the answer
Allowed: multiply one fraction by , a form of 1
Not allowed: multiply both sides of the claim
- Say what the question asks: check the proof for working both sides, squaring both sides, and dividing by an expression that can be 0.If none of the three appears and every line is a true rewrite, the proof is sound.
- Look at the first line: it is the left side alone, not the whole claim.So the proof works on one side; the right side appears only at the end.
- Look at the second line: it multiplies the top and the bottom of that one fraction by , the conjugate of . is 1 wherever 1 + sin t is not 0, and multiplying by 1 changes how the side looks, not its value. The other side of the claim is never touched.
- Check where is 0 in one turn: only at , since . There , so the right side's bottom is 0 and that angle is not part of the claim.The claim only covers angles where both sides make sense, so no angle that counts is lost.
- Check the third line: the top is , and the bottom is .Distribute the 3 over the sum; the bottom is a difference of squares, (a − b)(a + b) = − with a = 1 and b = sin t.
- Check the last line: is replaced by .The Pythagorean identity t + t = 1 gives t = 1 − t.
- Nothing squared both sides and nothing divided both sides; every line equals the one before it.So none of the three mistakes appears.
- No mistake: the proof is sound.
- It starts from one side, and the conjugate step multiplies one fraction by a form of 1, not both sides of the claim.
Rung 6 of 6
Rung 6, genuinely hard: a zero hiding at one angle
At t = 45°, sin t = cos t. Someone starts there and writes:
Line 1: sin t = cos t
Line 2: t = sin t cos t (multiply both sides by sin t)
Line 3: t − t = sin t cos t − t (subtract t from both sides)
Line 4: (sin t − cos t)(sin t + cos t) = cos t (sin t − cos t) (factor each side)
Line 5: sin t + cos t = cos t (divide both sides by sin t − cos t)
Line 6: sin t = 0 (subtract cos t from both sides)
But sin 45° = , not 0. Which step is wrong?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: every line came from the one above, so find the first line that is false at ; the step into it is the mistake.A sound step never leads from a true line to a false one.
- Line 1 at : , so it is true.The point at 45° on the unit circle is (, ): its two coordinates are equal.
- Line 2: , and is the same product, , so it is true.Tops times tops and bottoms times bottoms, with · = 2.
- Line 3: as well, so the left side is and the right side is , so it is true.Subtracting the same number from two equal numbers keeps them equal.
- Line 4: the left side is Line 3's left side factored as a difference of squares, and the right side is Line 3's right side with the common factor cos t pulled out, so both sides still equal 0 and it is true.Factoring rewrites an expression without changing its value.
- Line 5 at : the left side is , and the right side is , so it is false.Two halves of make a whole , which is twice the right side.
- So the step from Line 4 to Line 5 is the mistake: it divides both sides by , and at that is .Line 1 said sin t = cos t, so sin t − cos t was 0 from the start: a zero in disguise.
- The step from Line 4 to Line 5: it divides both sides by sin t − cos t, which is 0 at 45°.
- Lines 1 to 4 are true at 45°; Line 5 is the first false one.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device for the safe habit: one side, no squares, no zeros. Start from one side, do not square both sides, do not divide by an expression that can be 0.
- Read the first line of any proof. If it already shows both sides of the claim joined by an equals sign, the argument is working both sides, and every step then needs a walk-back check.
- To catch a squaring mistake, test an angle outside the first quadrant, such as 120°, 180° or 210°: inside the first quadrant every sine and cosine is positive, so sign errors hide.
- Before you divide, find every angle where the expression is 0: set it equal to 0 and solve. Start with 0°, 90°, 180° and 270°, where sine or cosine is 0, but do not stop there: sin t − cos t is 0 at 45° and 225°. If the Pythagorean identity turns it into 1 − 1, it is 0 at every angle.
- Scratch work on both sides is fine for finding the idea. The proof you write down starts from one side and reuses the identities you found.
- A test angle can show a claim is false, never that it is true: a match at 60° is a good sign, and a proof needs an argument that covers every angle, such as the chain from one side.
7 The trap
The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
What is a one-way step in a proof?
Why is squaring both sides a one-way step?
Why can a proof not divide both sides by an expression at an angle where it is 0?
An argument starts from the claim, works both sides and reaches a true line. Why is that not yet a proof, and what does this course do instead?
- It shows only that the claim leads to a true line, and a false claim can be carried to a true line the same way. It would be a proof only if every step were checked to run backwards.
- This course writes the more complicated side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it is exactly the other side.